I think the disconnect here is that some on this thread haven’t watched shows from this franchise before.
Every season, there are people from the lead’s past (and sometimes to the contestants past), who reach out to the media hoping for 15 min of fame. THR didn’t go hunting for “Carolyn.” She came to them. I don’t know how much THR vets claims, but Reality Steve is now pretty careful about what he publishes. I haven’t seen him comment on this (so far). It could be because, as skieurope says, who cares?
I thought early on that Joey would be cast as the Bachelor. My concern is that, I didn’t know how they would spin a tennis coach living in Hawaii. Since moving to HI in 2017, he hasn’t held a job for more than 1.5 years. Last night, they said he was a tennis player. That’s okay. After being the Bachelor, his world will change. He will make more as an influencer than he ever made as a tennis coach.
The same thing for Gerry, Leslie, Susan and April (who got a gig on Joey’s season). They will not go back to their regular lives. They’ve already started pitching products and receiving perks. In the LA Times article I linked to above,
In addition to your upcoming nuptials, any other show business aspirations now that you’re a huge TV star? Or are you just planning a quiet future with Theresa?
I don’t think those two things are mutually exclusive. I can have a great, quiet life with Theresa and still look at the aspirations and ambitions that may be out there. But I will say this, I am absolutely going to savor every moment until I get to that altar and say my “I do’s.” I want every single moment to be as joyful for her as it is for me, and I never want to look back and feel I hurried through anything. We’ll deal with the aspirations after that.
For people that watch Reality TV regularly, editing can make you believe what they want you to believe. Very rarely are those who are portrayed as villains, not nice in real life. There are always exceptions (ex. Kat). We saw one conversation about Theresa’s profession and didn’t see much after that. That doesn’t mean that the profession is the one thing that made him fall in love with her. There was plenty of footage on that we didn’t see.
In interviews, Gerry spoke about the conversations that they had when they were alone. Production touched on it when we saw him tell Leslie that she hadn’t asked him many questions about what their life would like together. When he was with Theresa, there were topics he wanted to discuss and, before he could bring them up, she did. He also mentioned in the finale, that she had a successful long marriage. I think that was a direct reference to Leslie’s two failed marriages.
The Fantasy Suites proved just as pivotal to Gerry.
“In my head, I had this checklist of four or five things that, ‘I got to know this stuff,’” he says. “And so she accepted to go into the Fantasy Suite, and those four or five things, before I even had a chance to ask them, she was like, spouting it out there. She was like, ‘Okay, and this is going to happen, and I want you to know this and this.’ And it’s like, ‘Oh my God, we are exactly on the same page.’”
Interesting, because it was brought up up thread, this People article says,
Theresa and Gerry plan to bring their families together to celebrate Hanukkah this month. “We’ll have a holiday dinner together with everyone,” Gerry says.