This stupid wrote all negative about himslef in the essay

<p>[Essay]
** Describe the world you come from, for example your family, clubs, school, community, city, or town. How has that world shaped your dreams and aspirations?**</p>

<p>My grandmother’s house was full of religion; sometimes there were ceremonies that went on for days. Yet no one explained us, children, what was going on; I doubt if even my grandmother knew what their significance was: they were carried on, unquestioned, because they were ancient.</p>

<p>I come from a family of Civil Servants and professors. My paternal grandfather’s father was a officer in the British Raj, so is the rest of my father’s family (including my father). My maternal grandfather was a Professor, so is rest of my mother’s family (including her). ‘Modern Caste system’ my grandfather used to comment, jokingly. Caste is the central to Indian psyche. Class is a system of rewards; caste on the other hand, imprisons a man into his proclaimed function, rest becomes subsidiary. It was only when my father objected on working besides school that I realized how deep the concept of Caste was rooted in Indian mind. A driver will drive only and not wash; a secretary will only take down notes and not type; a businessman will make money, even if that means selling colored water in place of medicines and as a student, I would study only, nothing else. </p>

<p>It’s said, by Naipaul and other post-colonial writers, that Indians can’t look directly at their country or else the distress they would see will drive them mad. Much is also said about their ability to ignore the obvious, ability to retreat in fantasy, ability to successfully negate the truth.</p>

<p>It’s only through self-inquiry that I am able to realize how much of this philosophy has been mine. The Smugness; the refusal to see what’s unpleasant; double talk and double think; my reverence for the ancient, however awkward it may be.</p>

<p>I am for that matter, a true Indian. If I was asked to portray India I would, typically like an Indian, point at its pacifism; it’s ability to absorb everyone- be it Arab merchants or Turk conquerors; it’s National religion, Hinduism, which is perhaps the only religion in this world which doesn’t claims to be the true religion; it’s pluralism, about my house, where the tinkling of bells from a Hindu temple mixes with the muzzling from a mosque situated on the opposite site of the road, in between stands a plaque proclaiming Marxist atheism. I would gloss over its superstitions, its inequalities, and its obscurantism.</p>

<p>Like any other Indian I don’t had (and perhaps still don’t have) any sense of History. In a democracy like India historical facts can’t be surpassed, in fact they are acknowledged and ignored. For my ancestral house was a Hindu temple till an invader form Afghanistan defiled it; yet during my stay there I am woken up innumerable times by people who want to pray in the small remain, that miraculously survived. A Thousand year old temple still lives! This is India, eternal. Or perhaps, is this sentimental conviction that India will go on the cause of our neglect towards our country? </p>

<p>Mahabharata and Ramayana, the two Sanskrit epics, are the focal point of Indian life. Both are the stories of great wars fought on the principle of Dharma (Dharma, Righteousness underlying law). I could still remember my grandmother telling me the story of Ram, the hero of Ramayana, who set against the crusade against the abductors of his wife, Sita.
Looking back at these epics I realize how far we have come from a utopian land, where truth and Dharma were worshipped to a land of rampant corruption and endemic faithlessness. But for that we ourselves are to be blamed. Like the ceremonies in my grandmother’s house we don’t question our world- we accept it as it comes. Passivity.</p>

<p>The courageous struggle of my father against corruption has inspired me the most. All my life, I have seen him struggling: he’s often transferred to remote districts, It’s often months till we see him; often he is often pressurized by corrupt officers and politicians; yet I have never seen him complaining.
If I were him, then probably I would have yielded to all this. It’s through him that I realize that there’s a need to be good. It was perhaps a feeling of anger which prompted me to work for Right to Information act. </p>

<p>Perhaps what could be said about India- every truth about India has an opposite, which is also true- is also true about me. I am atheist, yet a devout Hindu; Schizophrenic may be the right word to describe me when I pray in the Shiva temple, along with million of Indians, before each and every launch by our Space agency; I am interested in Science, yet arts attracts me.</p>

<p>As a child we know nothing, apart from what we see. As I child we aren’t supposed to know anything. A new born learns what he sees; I have spent 18 years of my life here; India has made me what I am, be it good or bad.
[/Essay]</p>

<p>Now i am getting worried, any thoughts?</p>

<p>I like the content but there are numerous grammatical errors....</p>

<p>"Yet no one explained us, children, what..."---should be: Yet, no one explained to us children what...</p>

<p>"My paternal grandfather’s father was a officer in the British Raj"---'A' should be 'an'</p>

<p>"along with million of Indians"---should be millions</p>

<p>Also, the commas throughout are pretty inconsistent and often wrong. </p>

<p>However, on a brighter note, I really like your content, and that should help you a lot.</p>

<p>I wouldn't have posted my essay online... you should PM it.</p>

<p>Edit: a little late, I guess.</p>

<p>It's too specific; i don't think that anyone could copy it.
Btw, what do you think about it(Essay)?
Actually my application packet to Midd got lost; i would be faxing it tomorrow.
Can anyone please review it? I seriously need some advise.
Thanks</p>

<p>Bump
I seriously need some advise.</p>

<p>I think its quite interesting and i don't think you have to worry about anyone copying you, its very specific to your situation but there were a number of grammatical errors, so i would carefully review it and correct them, other than that, nice!</p>

<p>I really love this essay!!:)</p>

<p>i think the essay is great too, a little pessamistic, but in a wise way that reveals great depth and understanding. and review the grammatical errors, other thatn that i think it is very personal and representative, great!</p>

<p>You do an excellent job analyzing your own culture and how you fit into it. I really love that part, but I feel that I want to know more about you from this essay that you never give us. You end by saying that you are the opposite of everything in India, yet the same. You say you like science but the arts too. How? I kind of want you to show me and not tell me so much, but, other than that, it is a very nicely written essay that conveys a lot about yourself.</p>

<p>the last paragraph doesnt quite fit in... looks like you've just put it there just because it is oodles of attitude... and as others said, there are a few grammatical errors...</p>

<p>otherwise, the essay is so very well done.. made me feel like i'm reading anita desai's for a while..</p>

<p>i really liked the "I pray in the Shiva temple, along with million of Indians, before each and every launch by our Space agency" part... it just adds to the dramatic flow of the essay...</p>

<p>The content is interesting, but the grammatical errors will hurt -- they're quite noticeable. The ending, particularly, seems a little rushed (and error-fraught) -- especially your mention of your own interest in science, which seems a little out-of-place considering that you haven't mentioned anything of the kind in the rest of it.</p>

<p>First paragraph -- how can your father be an officer in the British Raj? It doesn't exist any more. (I know that's probably not what you meant, but that's the way it sounds.) Also, insert a 'the' before 'rest becomes subsidiary' (makes more sense), and change 'objected on' to 'objected to'.
The paragraph where you mention that you don't have (you've written 'had', it ought to be 'have') a sense of history confuses me a bit -- what, exactly, are you trying to say? That India-in-general is not especially history-conscious, or that it is? The beginning of it obviously suggests the former, but 'a thousand-year-old temple still lives' would point toward the exact opposite. (And what do you mean by 'historical facts can't be surpassed'? It sounds a little strange.)</p>

<p>In the paragraph talking about your father's work against corruption, you might want to find some synonyms. Both 'struggle/struggling' and 'corrupt/corruption' are repeated, which is jarring.</p>

<p>Second-to-last paragraph: I'd put the 'schizophrenic' clause (about the temple) in a paragraph. It's a very nice inclusion, but it detracts from the pattern of the sentence (the provision of contrasting opposites: atheist/Hindu, science/arts). </p>

<p>The good stuff: the essay is genuinely interesting; most of the stuff I've seen written to that topic has been 'my dad's an engineer, my mum's a physicist, blah blah, and this is how my research project informed me of the ultimate awesomeness of the something or other, et cetera'. This is very different, and will stand out for that reason. </p>

<p>(As a complete coincidence, I happened to write to this topic, and wrote about India as well; took a diametrically opposite viewpoint, though. Which amuses me slightly.)</p>

<p>It's probably too late for you to make any of these modifications, really, but see if you can go over it again for Middlebury at the very least. Good luck! :)</p>

<p>And when I said 'put the clause in a paragraph', I actually meant parentheses. Sorry.</p>

<p>
[quote]
The good stuff: the essay is genuinely interesting; most of the stuff I've seen written to that topic has been 'my dad's an engineer, my mum's a physicist, blah blah, and this is how my research project informed me of the ultimate awesomeness of the something or other, et cetera'. This is very different, and will stand out for that reason.

[/quote]
</p>

<p>wow.. that is my essay put in three lines..</p>

<p>Er, oops? :o Didn't mean to offend, but I've seen rather a lot of dull essays by my classmates which run to that pattern. Wasn't suggesting that yours was boring, or anything.</p>

<p>lol.. i know you weren't..</p>

<p>I liked it because i learned new things from it, and got to know you as a person. The "self-inquiry" is the theme, and you demonstrate that the things that trouble you about Indian culture impel you towards seeking more equality and less corruption. Also, good critical thinking where you differentiated between class and caste. </p>

<p>If you're worried that you sounded too pessimistic, then just replace your final paragraph with a short list of values that you got from being Indian that you feel are wondrous, beautiful, or uplifting, in your mind. Leave them feeling positive.</p>

<p>My essay was actually quite different, almost diametrically opposite to the style expressed here. I didn't talk about India, didn't talk about my background, or in fact about anything that was 'at hand', so to speak.</p>

<p>As regards your essay Abhi, well, a number of points:</p>

<ol>
<li>I definitely prefer this essay to the others you've written.</li>
<li>The content's good, as the previous posters have said, but my God, the grammar. That'll be a major stumbling block, in my opinion.</li>
<li>Don't bother being worried now. The essay's been submitted, you can't change it. Hindsight's 20/20, but there really is no advice that any of us can give you now that'll be of any use to you at all. Focus on the good parts of the essay. The part about being inspired to fight against corruption, the RTI bit. </li>
</ol>

<p>Best of Luck!</p>

<p>Thanks everyone for reviewing my essay.
Noldo and GettingIn1: Thanks especially for correcting grammar.</p>

<p>that was good! it really was. you're a great writer.</p>