<p>To Eringo:
Yes it is possible to transfer to Tisch from GSP, just as it's possible to transfer from Tisch to any other school. But remember, there's no guarantees; you must audition for Tisch as a transfer student, and you're only guaranteed admission to the school you originally applied to from GSP.</p>
<p>To bimachris:
Helurr!
Well, I'm not sure exactly what to tell you about your film audition requirements. The vast majority of film students do have some form of past film experience, considering it's quite a technical art form, in addition to gaining experience and having an eye for what to film. But you should definitely do the requirements that you're most comfortable with; if you feel more comfortable writing a dramatic scene, do that. For the dramatic essay, it reads as if they require one essay that can be both comedic and dramatic, but don't submit two essays. NYU kind of hates more than the necessary requirements (including recommendations, etc.) because they have so many applicants.</p>
<p>Maybe this isn't my place...if film is something you feel passionate about and you think you can give a competitive audition/portfolio, do that. But if you feel that your portfolio isn't the best/won't quite make the standards of the other auditions, and you REALLY like NYU as much as you say, you might want to just apply to CAS and try to transfer into Tisch. That way, you could possibly get more experience with film enough to audition. You should keep in mind that you can only apply to ONE school at NYU. If you don't get into Tisch, that's it, you can't apply to NYU at all until another year has gone by. Maybe you can still take the chance and then if you get in, great, but if you don't, there's always next year as a transfer student.</p>
<p>Tisch had a 23% acceptance rate for the Class of 2011. That year (last year, my year), the university had an overall acceptance rate of around 29-33%. This year, the acceptance rate (based on CC boards I've seen) is 24%, and I can only assume that there's a less percentage rate this year for Tisch (although it still might be 23%). And I've heard that Tisch Film and Television is second only to USC's program (although things like that are subjective). </p>
<p>Hopefully I've given you some more things to think about this coming year...if you're applying to NYU next year, maybe you should go to a film program or residency this summer and film all you can...that way, you can have a portfolio/some experience. Creative work for film can also include creative writing and stuff like that, if I'm not mistaken. I wish you all the best, and don't hesitate to ask any questions.</p>