UC Personal Statement #1: Feedback/Critique needed!

<p>Here's my response to topic #1: "Describe the world you come from — for example, your family, community or school — and tell us how your world has shaped your dreams and aspirations."</p>

<p>I mainly want to know the following:
-Do I sound too whiney, negative?
-Do my ideas make sense?
-Are they cohesive?</p>

<p>Thanks!</p>

<p>"I’ve grown up in a relatively privileged family. I have an older brother and a mother and father who are still together. We had food, shelter, and extra money to spend on leisure. However, despite our fortune, I had grown up under a shadow composed of double standards and sexism that no amount of money could chase away.</p>

<p>Both of my parents were refugees who came from Vietnam during the Vietnam War. With them, they brought their culture and tradition to America. Unfortunately, with their traditional values, they retained their rather unfavorable view of women as a whole. In many Asian cultures, women are seen as naturally weaker in both physical and emotional aspects. Overall, we are considered the inferior half. While time and modernization have helped alleviate the problem, the inequality remains.</p>

<p>Before I knew the definition of “sexism” I was aware of the unequal treatment between my brother and I. Like every other child who is denied something by a parent, I would ask “Why?” and the answer would always be the same: “Because you are a girl.” Unlike my mother, I had the opportunity of growing up in Oregon and I knew that this was not right. Torn between my family’s traditional values and the western values I adopted, I grew bitter and angry. However, no matter how frustrated I was, the answer remained simple to me. There was no use dislodging my parents from their beliefs; the only one I could change was myself. Fueled by my desire to disprove them, I worked harder to be stronger, kinder, and smarter than my brother. While I harbored no ill will towards him, I began to view him as a rival I needed to surpass. </p>

<p>Most recently, I realized that even then, I was succumbing to the shadow by working towards my success out of spite. Despite what they have done for me, I was still angry with my mother and father for trying to force me into their mold of an ideal woman and future wife. Hard work alone failed to satisfy me and it took many nights of self-reflection to admit that I pitied myself by secretly blaming my parents for my bitterness. While I still do not accept their strongly biased views considering men and women, the first step I needed to take in order to avoid collapsing under the weight was to accept that working to simply prove them wrong was not enough. I couldn’t afford to depend on them for approval and acceptance. From then on, the extra hours I spent on schoolwork, volunteering, and exercising were for my own benefit. </p>

<p>I do not have to work hard because I am a woman, but because I am a person wanting to succeed. For years, it was my own bias that bogged me down. I can only hope that my parents will eventually accept me as a person who refuses to be bound by her gender; however, the future where I am free to be in a career I enjoy, where I am surrounded by friends, is a future I have to earn for myself and not for anyone else’s approval. "</p>

<p>What I learned about you from this essay:
you’re kind of the black sheep of the family.
you don’t like to be pigeon-holed.
you know what you want career wise.</p>

<p>if this is what you want the admissions committee to learn about you then you are set.
Other then that I didn’t really get to know much about you. I learned about your parents though.</p>

<p>take my feedback for what it is lol</p>

<p>You described the first half of the question rather well, which is the world you come from. I think it might be a bit focused on ‘sexism’. Your second paragraph does not say much about you and it sounds a bit negative. And instead of saying your are unequally treated, maybe you could describe it better with a short incident. </p>

<p>May I suggest you to elaborate more on the second half of the question, your dreams and aspirations? Perhaps describing a specific field that you would like to pursue or how do you picture yourself a few years from now.</p>

<p>Great essay thoguh, Cheers!</p>

<p>PS: I could totally relate to your situation about your parents molding you into their ideal person. Asian parents, huh?</p>

<p>Thanks you two for the feedback! I guess I do need to talk more about myself and my aspirations. Truth is, I don’t really know exactly what I want. The only thing I feel strongly about is “do what you want for yourself, not for your parents.”</p>

<p>I plan to major in general Biology, but I’m not sure how to relate it to the issue of gender inequality here. As for a specific instance, it’s more like different attitudes concerning me and my bro. “You can do what you want, just don’t get arrested” vs. “You can’t do that, you’re a girl.” </p>

<p>I’ll try my best to trim down what I have now to make some more room since I’m really close to the limit. Thanks again!</p>

<p>Edit: Rereading my essay, my dreams and aspirations are really general. I just want to get somewhere satisfactory with my hard work and hopefully prove to my parents that I’m just as capable as any guy (something I don’t want to depend on). Now that I’ve summed that up, I feel like the issue here is that I don’t have a super solid field or career in mind. </p>

<p>So can the “aspiration” part revolve more around abstract things such as motivation and inner strength, or is the mention and relation of a specific field more effective?</p>

<p>Hi, it’s the tone in the body of your essay I’m concerned about, it comes across as venting and bitter. Keep in mind admissions is looking at trait and character of applicants as they make acceptance decisions. Consider making your points from a different angle and/or tone.</p>

<p>Good luck! :)</p>

<p>I was afraid of that, thank you!</p>

<p>One more thought, and this isn’t necessary for your essay. Consider forgiveness. Your parents are doing their best they know how to raise their children, based on “the world” they came from and grew up in. Somewhere down the road, forgive them for raising you not the way you wanted but knowing they love you with all their heart and always wants the best for you. Through your successes, you can educate and show them a different perspective, helping them understand your world. :)</p>

<p>I do agree with eCoachJen. If you portray it in a positive light, i’m sure they will view you as strong and unyielding. You could describe the unequal treatment but do it without any resentment. </p>

<p>And about the second part, aspiration means strong desire or ambition. If your ambition is to become a strong, independent woman, you can mention that. But since this is a college essay, it would only be appropriate to mention your potential major Biology as well. </p>

<p>Just my honest opinion. I’m in no way an expert. :D</p>

<p>I have a better understanding of how I should rewrite things, so thank you everyone :slight_smile: If I can’t pull it off, I may just pick something entirely different but we’ll see.</p>

<p>Alright, I completely rewrote it (but didn’t change the main idea entirely). I would really appreciate it if anyone is interested in reading it again ;P</p>

<p>I don’t mind reading it. I wrote my UC essay, couldn’t have done it without other people’s help. So, sure I will help you out.</p>

<p>Thank you, I sent a message via email.</p>