UVA vs Vanderbilt

<p>I am an aspiring neuroscience major and I already know that the programs at both schools are about equal. I visited vandy and liked it and I am currently at UVA, although it's too early to say how I feel about it.</p>

<p>I'm hoping for more of a direct compare and contrast between the two schools socially, so if students could weigh in, that'd be awesome. Both schools have strong Greek systems, although neither school is overpowered by them. They both also have gorgeous campuses. It's no coincidence that my college search has settled upon two schools that are so similar.</p>

<p>I applied to both and ended up choosing UVA. Have you looked into the other threads about this?
[url=&lt;a href=“Google”&gt;Google]Google[/url</a>]</p>

<p>Are you a candidate for financial or merit aid? If you will be a full payer, UVA will save you about $20,000 a year.</p>

<p>Let’s pretend that aid is a non-issue and focus on campus life/atmosphere/amenities</p>

<p>Neuroscience will mean going on for further education (?). Money should play a part in your decision, because you will need thousands more for grad school. You may not be approved of much in the way of loans for grad if you have to take out loans for undergrad. And don’t count on teaching assistant grants with a competative major like neuroscience (especially if you want to go to a similarly prestigious school for your grad). You do have to play this a bit like a chess game --you have to think a couple moves ahead or you may later have regrets. All this being said, if you are instate, UVA is a no brainer. I personally love UVA and if instate that would be my rec.</p>

<p>I would say …</p>

<p>Business, law -> UVa</p>

<p>Medicine-> Vandy</p>

<p>Humanities&Social Science-> About the same</p>

<p>But, No matter what your major is, you can’t go wrong for either of them!
Remember that overall prestige, rather than departmental, should be the first priority when it comes to undergraduate!</p>

<p>I recommend U.Va :)</p>

<p>“Remember that overall prestige, rather than departmental, should be the first priority when it comes to undergraduate!”</p>

<p>I hope you mean that school prestige is just more important than departmental prestige, not that school prestige is the most important factor…</p>

<p>Since you are on grounds at UVa (I am guessing for the Jefferson Scholars Finalist Program) you may want to make time to go to the neuroscience department and speak with the Professors and TA’s. Specifically ask about the undergraduate program and its curriculum path as well as their research opportunities. While there inquire about the graduate program too. </p>

<p>Best of luck to you!</p>

<p>

</p>

<p>For clarification, are you a first year at UVA who’s considering transferring, or are you at UVA now simply visiting? Have you already been accepted to both schools? Assuming you are a current hs senior, I’ll share my thoughts seeing as how my D is pre-med and looked carefully at both:</p>

<p>First, these two schools are EXTREMELY similar, IMO, both academically and socially. If UVA was private, I’d venture to say these two would have more cross applicants than just about any of the others. Socially, both schools have a southern, preppy vibe. Because geographically UVa is so close to the beltway, it’s going to feel a bit less southern and a tad more cosmopolitan. </p>

<p>You will notice a strong Greek life at both schools. I’ve heard 1/3 of UVa’s student body is in a frat/srat; I don’t know the percentage at Vandy, but I would think it’s higher. UVa students seem more relaxed when it comes to the Greek scene. If you choose to join, great…if not, no big deal. When we visited Vandy (several times), it seemed to us that Greek life was the be all/end all. My D wanted (is) to be part of a sorority, so she liked this social aspect; however, she enjoys the fact that at UVa it doesn’t define you. </p>

<p>Both schools offer diverse student bodies; however, because 2/3 of the students at UVa are from VA, you’ll have more geographic diversity at Vandy. I will say that over the past few years, Vandy has been fighting tooth and nail to dispel their image as a rich, southern, white school. Their admissions department has recently tended to favor those living north of the MDL and URMs. As hard as they’ve tried to change their image, many Americans will always perceive it as a school for the blue blood, white, southern, prep schooler. </p>

<p>Both campuses are absolutely gorgeous. Vandy is nestled in an arboretum, and its buildings are uniform. UVa also has that uniform architecture (something my D found appealing), but it’s nestled in the Shenendoahs. Both campuses embody the stereotypical picture of what a campus should look like. UVa does have, however, the rich history behind it that Vandy does not. I heard the rotunda is the only building on any American campus that was selected as part of some world landmark registry.</p>

<p>Vandy is in an urban setting that is very vibrant. Nashville is a great place, and there are a lot if things to do. UVa sits more in your quaint and charming college town. You’ve got restaurants galore in CVille, and you’re just a couple of hours from the beach and DC if you find that appealing. Our D has never felt that Charlottesville was too small/closed-in, but then again as a science major, she rarely has the time.</p>

<p>Vandy requires all students to live on campus all four years – UVa only requires it the first year. This can be good or bad according to your perception. </p>

<p>Vandy can’t compare to UVa, IMO, when it comes to school spirit, tradition, and pride. We’re OOS, and I had no idea how intensely loyal UVa kids/alums are to their school until I went to the first football game. The streets upon streets of tailgaters and rowdy fans could even rival some of the schools down here in TX! (If you’ve ever been to a UT game, you’d know that’s no easy feat!) The students at UVa support ALL sports which I find charming. And because of the history of being the first public school in the US, the tradition UVa offers is unlike no other. (You’ll learn all about them should you decide to matriculate.)</p>

<p>Academically, both schools are comparable. They’re both going to be very challenging. I would not presume for one second one will be easier than the other. When our D entered UVa last fall, her grades/# of APs and scores/SATs, etc. put her toward the very top at both. She came prepared, but she must study a lot to maintain her desired GPA for her intended degrees. They both have highly ranked med schools/hospitals on the main campus, so internships, shadowing, volunteering, etc. can be attained at both. I feel academically, these two are perceived by most to be comparable institutions. </p>

<p>In the end, they’re both FABULOUS schools, and you can’t go wrong with either. I’d select the one that “feels” right and the one that’s the best value. (Vandy is not worth an extra $20K and vice versa especially if med school is on your horizon.) Good luck to you!</p>

<p>Great post jc40. I’m here for the jefferson finalist weekend and I’m trying to get a read on what the school’s strong points are. Clearly, the school Is excellent as a whole, but I’m looking for distinguishing features.</p>

<p>Its worth pointing out that if I were awarded the Jefferson scholarship, I would be here in a heartbeat. The opportunities that the program provides are simply unparalleled. That being said, I have also been offered aid at Vanderbilt, so I really wanted a side by side comparison. Jc40’s post was excellent.</p>

<p>Please really research the major at UVa. S1 had an interest in neuroscience, his advisor is a professor in that department. Please ask about the curriculum path and what is available course wise for an undergrad. </p>

<p>I know what a campus has to offer is extremely important but what is available for your intended major I believe takes precedent.</p>

<p>I think my son has his choices down to UVA and Vandy. Based on our campus visits I would give UVA the edge as the classic college town, but felt like Vandy being in Nashville might provide more things to do overall, especially after fresman year.</p>

<p>One big consideration for us is the financial aid. It seems like UVA is just not that motivated to give aid to out-of-staters, while Vandy is making the price of admission comparatively inexpensive.</p>

<p>I think my son is geared towards some sort of double major in math and public policy.</p>

<p>I’d be interested to hear any reactions on all these points.</p>

<p>Thanks,</p>

<p>DadLuvsA7X</p>

<p>Good problem to have. Visited both with my D. She only applied to UVA, the whole sorority thing bothered her at Vandy. Vandy is a great place though and its all about fit. If your S can see him self at either I would go with the best financial deal…I guess in this case that would be Vandy.</p>

<p>Dad -
Noting that this thread is two years old, UVa gives out no different aid to OOS students then instate students. They use the Profile, as Vandy does, to determine need, and guarantees to meet 100% of demonstrated need. That may be different then what you feel you are comfortable paying. UVa has not given FA offers to any newly accepted students that I’m aware so I’m not sure how you’re comparing offers this early. </p>

<p>In the end your student, and you, must take all things into consideration, including affordability, when your student selects a school. Both UVa and Vandy have a lot to offer.</p>

<p>It looks as if the OP in this thread chose UVA - hope he’s having a great experience there.</p>

<p>On sororities - My middle d chose Vanderbilt over UVA in 2005, in large part because of a generous merit scholarship. She is now at UVA Law. She was quite active in Greek life at Vanderbilt, including a position overseeing sorority recruitment her senior year. Just for what this is worth, she thinks the Greek scene at UVA is slightly more intense than at Vandy, despite the fact that a higher percentage of students at Vanderbilt are Greek than at UVA. Just one data point, and it may be because she’s several years older the undergrads she knows at UVA; and of course, she’s just an observer there.</p>

<p>In any event, both schools are outstanding.</p>

<p>DadLuvs – I don’t know how need-based aid would compare between Vandy and UVA OOS. But as a private school, there’s probably more merit award money available at Vandy than at UVA (although it could be tough to get at a school as selective as Vandy).</p>