<p>Consider the following alternatives to Wheaton (sorted by USNWR ranking, which usually corresponds to selectivity):</p>
<p>Davidson (Presbyterian)
College of the Holy Cross (Roman Catholic)
St. Olaf (Lutheran)
Earlham (Quaker)</p>
<p>Like Wheaton, these are all small, top-100 LACs. They all have a religious affiliation (as indicated) but are more secular/ecumenical in orientation than Wheaton. As for costs, the average aid (both need-based and merit-based) is higher at all four than it is at Wheaton … although their average debt at graduation is also higher than Wheaton by a few hundred dollars (Davidson) to a few thousand dollars (the others). </p>
<p>([Best</a> Values in Private Colleges, 2010-11](<a href=“Kiplinger | Personal Finance News, Investing Advice, Business Forecasts”>Kiplinger | Personal Finance News, Investing Advice, Business Forecasts))</p>
<p>If you want a lively, urban setting then you may need to consider some larger schools. Richmond, IN (Earlham) would indeed make Wheaton, IL look like Manhattan on Monday morning. </p>
<p>For good academics + religious affiliation + urban … but larger … consider Catholic schools (Georgetown, Boston College, Fordham, Villanova, etc.) For good academics + urban + small … but minus the religious affiliation… the few options include Barnard (if female), Macalester, and Colorado College. All three of these schools carry lower average debt at graduation than Wheaton. All three are MUCH more liberal in atmosphere than Wheaton (although Colorado College is in a city where many conservative/Christian organizations are headquartered.)</p>
<p>Academics, cost, and location aside … I think the key question is whether you are looking for a school with Wheaton’s religious orientation (a “Christian School”.) If so, then Wheaton is probably the best school of its kind for academic quality. If not, keep looking.</p>