Which colleges are safety schools reaches or matches for me?

From Massachusetts
HS GPA- 3.94 but it is somehow slightly weighted
SAT scores (first time around)- 1800
Mostly Honors classes
Activities:
14 years of dance
2 years in peer mediation club
10 years singing in my church choir
All four years of high school chorus
2 years of show choir/performance singing
4 years of the school musical
volunteer work in the public library and at church food drives, events, etc
Waitress at Friendly’s restaurant for 2 years

I am interested in colleges around the east coast area, and in schools who offer good financial aid. Any suggestions on where I should be applying to?

What is your intended major? Do you prefer smaller or larger schools?