<p>I would say neither Amherst nor Williams would fit the description of having a "city feel," nor would they be able to provide you access to one. Amherst is located in a VERY cute college town, to be sure, but it's definitely more New England-cutesy than city-like. That being said, as others have brought up, with the five-college consortium there would a dynamic social scene, or at least, more so than that at Williams (which is VERY isolated, or felt that way to me). If you're looking for a college that will give you access to a major city, neither school is a particularly good choice; however, if you don't mind not having city access, Amherst fits the rest of your preferences.</p>
<p>Some other "top" LACs to consider would include (I also listed information about the cities within range, the frat/sorority scenes, and the sport level offered at the school, because those seem to be the features which could help you narrow things the most)... [ul]
[<em>]Bowdoin College (ME): 5 miles from Portland & 120 miles from Boston, no frats/sororities, Division III sports.
[</em>]Davidson College (NC): 19 miles from Charlotte, has an active fraternity scene (40% of guys are involved) but not sororities, Division I sports with Division IAA football.
[<em>]College of the Holy Cross (MA): 45 miles from Boston, no frats/sororities, Division I sports.
[</em>]Trinity College (CT): located in Hartford (but has a very distinct campus), both frats (20%) & sororities (16%) are offered, Division III sports.
[<em>]Lafayette College (PA): 60 miles from Philadelphia, both frats (24%) & sororities (45%) are offered, Division I sports.
[</em>]Gettysburg College (PA): 36 miles from Harrisburg & 80 miles from Washington DC, both frats (40%) & sororities (26%) are offered, Division III sports.
[<em>]Franklin & Marshall College (PA): 60 miles from Philadelphia, both frats (26%) and sororities (12%) are offered, Division III sports with Division I Men's Wrestling.
[</em>]Union College (NY): 15 miles from Albany, both frats (30%) and sororities (32%) offered, Division III sports with Division I Men's Ice Hockey.
[<em>]Middlebury College (VT): no nearby cities (rural campus), no frats or sororities offered, Division III sports.
[</em>]Colgate University (NY): 38 miles from Syracuse (rural campus), both frats (28%) and sororities (33%) offered, Division I sports with Division IAA football.
[<em>]Washington & Lee University (VA): 60 miles from Charlottesville (rural campus), both frats (83%) and sororities (74%) offered, Division III sports.
[</em>]Hamilton College (NY): 50 miles from Syracuse (rural campus), both frats (29%) and sororities (19%) offered, Division III sports.
[<em>]Kenyon College (OH): 50 miles from Columbus (rural campus), both frats (25%) and sororities (10%) offered, Division III sports.
[</em>]Bucknell University (PA): a university with a LAC feel (only 157 grads and a campus population around 3600), 75 miles from Harrisburg (rural campus), both frats (39%) and sororities (40%) offered, Division I sports with Division IAA football.[/ul]</p>