I’ve seen mixed opinions on whether subject tests are really “optional” if you’re middle/upper-middle class.
Normally, I’d want to err on the side of caution and take them; but is it worth it if I’ll really only send them to one college? I’m planning to stay instate, and am looking at Rice and UT Austin as my top choices for an engineering major. Besides that, I’ve got public schools like A&M, UTD, etc. on my list. None but Rice consider subject tests, as far as I know.
Will I be disadvantaged if I don’t send in subject tests? I’m one of those good stats, solid extracurriculars, but nothing special applicants, but I don’t want it to be a negative tipping point. At the same time, Rice isn’t my die-hard dream school, but still a top contender.
Any advice appreciated.
I forgot to mention: I’m a rising senior, so I’d either take Math 2 and Physics in August (retake in October if need be), or just focus on writing great essays.
Rice no longer requires subject tests but suggests them. When a school has an admit rate of below 9 percent, anything you can do to stand out in the crowd is helpful. If you take the subject tests and the scores aren’t good, don’t send them.My daughter’s guidance counselor said that for selective colleges an applicant should treat “optional” as “required.” This thread is helpful. http://talk.qa.collegeconfidential.com/rice-university/2077757-rice-subject-tests.html#latest
DS took his subject tests yesterday- Math 2 and Chemistry. He currently has one school on his list that requires them, so it was pretty much only to meet that criteria. That being said, he found that the math and science he has taken to date (just finished AP Calc BC and AP Chem) were good preparation and he didn’t need to do additional prep work. He took a full practice exam and was happy with the results, and felt even better after the tests yesterday (of course, the proof of that won’t be seen for a couple of weeks) 
Perhaps one thing would be for you to see how you would do without investing a large amount of prep time and that will simplify the decision?