Wrong Writing Choice Answer in the BlueBook?

<p>Consider this sentence:</p>

<p>"American journalist Harriet Quimby, the first woman to pilot a plane across the English channel, doing it just nine years after the Wright brothers' first powered flight."</p>

<p>The two I narrowed it down to were:</p>

<p>C) Harriet Quimby became the first woman to have piloted a plane across the English Channel and did it</p>

<p>D) Harriet Quimby became the first woman to pilot a plane across the English Channel, accomplishing this feat</p>

<p>I chose C, but the answer is apparently D. Why?</p>

<p>“have piloted” sounds awkward
“did it” also sounds awkward
i cannot explain grammatically why it’s wrong though, sorry…</p>

<p>“to have” is incorrect.</p>

<p>Have can only be used in the present and future tenses.</p>

<p>Thanks a lot.</p>

<p>to have is incorrect? whats the correct form, then? to… ?</p>

<p>^The perfect tense “to have piloted” is incorrect; the infinitive form “to pilot” is correct.</p>

<p>Zap is correct.</p>

<p>To have pilot is wrong .You need the infinitive ;]</p>

<p>Page 537 #5 BB</p>

<p>Choice (D) is correct. It avoids the error of the original by using a complete verb (“became”).</p>

<p>Choice (A) creates a sentence fragment. It lacks a complete verb (the participle “doing” is not a complete verb).</p>

<p>Choice (B) creates a sentence fragment. The subordinating words (“who”) make two dependent clauses without a main clause.</p>

<p>Choice (C) involves an error in verb tense. The sentence shifts from simple past tense (“became”) to present perfect tense (“have piloted”) for no reason.</p>

<p>Choice (E) involves improper coordination. Two complete thoughts (“Harriet…Channel” and “the feat…flight”) are connected by only a comma, without the word “and” to introduce the second thought.</p>

<p>Just as Ireland has produced many famous writers and the Netherlands an abundance of famous painters, so Finland has provided a large number of famous architects.</p>

<p>Why the hell is it A, that is correct? I picked E, which happens to make the MOST sense to me… Choices are:</p>

<p>B) Finland provides famous architects ,and by large numbers
C) Finland’s contribution is to provide famous architects in a large number
D) and so then, for Finland, a large number of famous architects is provided
E) and like them Finland has provided a large number of famous architects</p>

<p>Just…so is correct. Not Just…and.</p>

<p>Does anyone have a comprehensive list of those associations?</p>

<p>“Just…so”, etc.</p>