Yale vs Notre Dame decision

Hello, I am being recruited for track and field by both Yale and Notre Dame and trying to decide between the two. I am planning on majoring in something STEM related such as engineering. Yale is cheaper for me as Notre Dame will cost about 9k more per year. I’m mostly drawn to the overall prestige of Yale and their residential college system. However, I do believe that I’ll be a better fit for Notre Dame, as I’m catholic and from the Midwest and very interested in sports. (Not that interested in the fine arts which Yale seems to be heavily involved in) Basically, do you think it would be better to turn down Yale and go to Notre Dame for the better “fit” and sports culture even though it’s 9k more a year? Thanks

Follow up to a previous post:

As the creation of more than one account is not allowed, I’m closing. OP can start a new thread under the original account.