AFAIK, no one here asked anyone for an apology as to their views. I certainly didn’t.
I am a big believer in “different strokes for different folks” (a la Sly Stone). What chord resonates with one, might not with another. That’s extremely cool, and that’s life.
However, I think the point of the show yesterday is that some of these artists were some of the biggest ever. For example, I think it’s pretty fair to say that several of these folks are mega-superstars, so it’s a bit surprising that folks haven’t heard of them. That’s cool too: I haven’t heard of a ton of musicians myself.
There’s probably no sure way to quantify this, but I would think that Eminem was perhaps the biggest musical star of the first part of the 21st century. After doing some research after seeing some of the comments here, I was astounded to see “Lose Yourself”, the song he performed last night, being number 1 for more weeks than “Hey Jude” (one of the all-time greats). I just knew it was a fabulous song when I first heard it 20 years ago. It IMMEDIATELY resonated with me. Check out the lyrics: they are incredibly positive, and I would be happy if my DCs listen to great stuff like this and get their inspiration, in part, from it. I know my older C has. And that is very fine with me.
Yup, the sound last night was not great, and the sets could have been much better. But there is absolutely no denying the importance of rap/hip-hop has had, and is having. I am glad the Super Bowl, at long last, took that opportunity. That was why it was so important. It’s not just based on skin color: this genre has affected all sorts of people, regardless of “race”, ethnicity, nationality. For me, that’s the hallmark of something imperative to hear.
It’s funny: I love Sean Connery as James Bond. However, one of the most infuriating moments in any of his movies, was in 1964’s Goldfinger, where he talks about wearing earmuffs to get rid of the Beatles’ “noise”. That’s a line that hasn’t aged well. That “noise” in 1964-1970 transformed the lives of untold numbers of people around the world. It is the same with rap/hip-hop, which has affected so many lives for decades because it is such an accessible form of music.
The very greats in this genre belong to the pantheon of music much like Diana Ross, Johnny Cash, Earl Scruggs, Marvin Gaye, Smokey Robinson, Willy Nelson, the Beatles, Elvis, Frank Sinatra, Bob Marley, Beethoven, Mozart, Sly and the Family Stone, Woody Guthrie, Janis Joplin, Louis Armstrong etc, etc, etc. All of these, and more, transformed lives and took music far beyond just a sonic dimension.
I am very certain that super-greats like Paul McCartney et al would agree that last night was LONG overdue.