A new style of SAT essay - please grade

<p>I have decided to move away from the typical 3 example essay that I have been so obsessed with for the past two weeks and see how I fare with one essay that just focuses on a personal example (inspired by all the college board featured personal example essays that received 12s). Here it is:</p>

<p>Do memories hinder or help people in their effort to learn from the past and succeed in the present?</p>

<p>Memories can either be a hindrance or an aid to people depending on the sort of memory and how they handle it. If one analyzes a memory and sees ones mistakes then one has a lot to gain from the memory, however, if one becomes overly obsessed with the memory then one will never be able to see what is to gain from the memory.</p>

<p>My grandmother experienced both sides of this. 4 years ago, when my aunt and my cousin brother died in a tragic car accident, my grandmother was filled with grief. She cut herself off from the world and locked herself up in her room for hours on end as she cried. She lost all hope and love for the world and would not speak to anyone. Over time everyone else in my family recovered but not my grandmother. Unable to tolerate her state, my uncle reached out to her but she screamed at him and told him to leave but he was relentless. Unfortunately, his tolerance had limits and after a year he couldn’t handle seeing her state anymore and he left the house to live elsewhere with his family. My grandmother was unable to relieve herself of the memory and she distanced herself from everyone who loved and cared about her, including her own son.</p>

<p>Over time, though, she realized what she had done and decided that she had to amend her mistakes. She approached my uncle and explained that she understood that he had undertaken a significant amount of grief as well and it was selfish of her to treat him the way she did. Though, it took a while, he forgave her and, together with his family, moved back into the home where they used the memory of my aunt and cousin as a reminder of how quickly life could change and decided to life larger than they had before. My grandmother, eventually, used the memory of my aunt to succeed in her relationships and her life.</p>

<p>The story of my grandmother’s recovery has always been close to me and I have always remembered how my grandmother utilized the most tragic of memories to succeed to my own benefit, be it breaking up with my girlfriend or messing up an examination. A memory has the potential to both be a hindrance or a help – it only depends on what you make of it.</p>

<p>Just of note: I did this on the computer and I realized that you can type significantly faster than you can write so I avoided going through for big words and just wrote as fast as I could (it took me 9 minutes if it matters).</p>

<p>What do you reckon? Critiques and scores are greatly appreciated?</p>

<p>Anyone at all?</p>

<p>Sorry for not responding with anything helpful but where did you find the ‘inspired by all the college board featured personal example essays that received 12s’?</p>

<p>I bought the SAT online course and almost all, if not all, examples that received 6s are purely based around personal examples.</p>

<p>Oh I see. That’s the approach I’m going to be taking as well.</p>

<p>What do you think about the essay? What score would you give it?</p>

<p>Please, I really need someone to critique this essay. The SAT is in 5 days and the essay is where I am screwed!</p>

<p>I’d say overall its pretty good. I’d give it a 10ish. Try to spell it out by the way (like the numbers 4, etc)</p>

<p>I’d give it a 4. Take some more time developing it and expressing yourself better. I really can’t help you much, I’m not usually a person who can dissect an essay and tell people what’s wrong with it. But it could be better.</p>

<p>Thanks for the tip gotmilk. Jimmy, what do you reckon is wrong with it? I tried to make it over 400 words because I read somewhere that essays with over 400 words generally got double digit marks, according to MIT. I think it was about 410 or something.</p>

<p>Meh, that’s not totally accurate. I have excellent language and filled up 2 pages last time and still got a 9, whereas in January I filled up around 1.5/1.75 pages and got a 10. Ironically. This time I’m just going to do it backhanded and fill up as much as I feel is necessary. Probably will invent some stuff if I can’t think of a reference that I know in details. </p>

<p>Seriously, details matter like hell. Try to be very specific in your examples.
As for your essay, well I honestly can’t say. You DID do it in 9 minutes and I felt the grammar could be slightly better. Length does matter, I think it guarantees you an 8 as long as your language isn’t horrible and your examples are relevant. Anyway, for a higher score, try: varying sentence structure, going into details, using some vocab words (CORRECTLY!), and telling them how you learned about your experience and how it affected your thinking.</p>

<p>Alright. Thanks a lot mate.</p>

<p>I’d give it a 10/11. Really, it is that touching. And it is believable. With better vocab and maybe a bit longer conclusion(like 4 sentences), you could get a 12. </p>

<p>And I could give you my personal take on essays. I always fill up the 2 pages that they give, whether it is the ACT or the SAT. I took these tests for a total of 5 times. 4/5 times I got a 10, 1/5 times I got a 9.
I also always have 2 body paragraphs(2 examples) that are well developed.
Luckily, my 10 was with a -0 MC and I ended up with an 800 in writing. (lol Jimmy, I saw your post on another thread that you got -3 w/ 10 and -0 w/ 9 and never got an 800. I’m like the complete opposite. good luck in June :wink: )</p>

<p>Aw dude, that’s totally not fair :smiley: A 790’s fine for me, but I really wanted that 800. Writing is that section that I excel at without studying. You know, I’m totally regretting not studying for the January test. I seriously stood a hell of a chance at an 800 M and W and like a 720+ CR. It was THAT easy. And if the June test is difficult I’m never getting that score. So please, College Board, just make this one as easy as the Jan/May tests, and I’ll be indebted :smiley:
Also, I’d better get like a 12 this time. I’m going to avoid using literary/historical examples and instead make up some story about how I grew or something. They seem to love those and I’m good at writing that kind of stuff. Still going to do the writing MC backhandedly though (will probably get it almost all right at any rate), I want to concentrate more on the M and CR.</p>

<p>^ I think it is much harder to write a 12 essay using personal examples rather than literary/historical examples. I suggest using a personal example only if you cannot think of 1-3 strong literary/historical/scientific examples for the given prompt.</p>

<p>I excel at writing narratives and creating them. And I have limited knowledge of literature and world history. The only thing I could write about is Einstein/Newton, and I’ve done that. Twice. I’ve decided to just try my luck - why not turn it to my advantage. It’s not like I’m helping myself by using historical examples that I only knew very general details about.</p>

<p>Just so you know, aren’t we allowed to make up the examples? I don’t think they look for accuracy in literacy works/historical examples.</p>

<p>However, if your made-up example is obviously wrong (like George Washington is the current US President), the graders may mark you down for that. Even if they don’t, they’ll be thinking about how stupid a person has to be to write that the whole time they’re reading the essay, which is not an impression anyone wants to give the readers.</p>

<p>Dude, READ my previous posts. I’m going to exaggerate based on personal experiences, I’m not going to make up history. If I were stupid enough to do that I shouldn’t be taking the SAT at all :smiley:
Read the 6 essay in the BB. It has this girl/guy talk about how he/she is a perfectionist and grew from the experience. Only example they used. I’m kind of aiming for a similar style.</p>

<p>Really like your essay. Keep posting more :)</p>