I am very disappointed that TAMU is discarding the Academic Admit category.
I personally think that students who are in the 10.1 to 25% of their graduating HS class AND have the required SAT/ACT scores are academically ready to thrive at TAMU. Having everyone from 10.0 % and down go into Holistic review will make the process take a lot longer and will be stressful for so many more students and their parents.
This is coming from a parent of 2 Aggies, NEITHER of which was an Academic admit.
My oldest daughter was HS Class of 2012, in the 27% of her class with the required ACT score for her application year. She received a full admit offer in mid Feb of 2013. She had some AP and DC credit, graduated on time, Cum Laude (3.5 gpa) from TAMU in Spring of 2016. She is now working in her profession.
My youngest daughter was HS Class of 2017, in the 53% of her class, 3.5 unweighted gpa, (above 4 for weighted gpa, just can’t remember actual number), with SAT 1250 (E670/M580) /ACT 27 scores, which were below the Academic Admit threshold, but at the average for TAMU enrolled students. Her gpa and SAT scores were not a lot lower than her older sister’s, but the HS just gets more competitive every year. She was offered Blinn-TEAM on Feb. 14, 2017. She just successfully completed 2 years on Blinn-TEAM and is now an Aggie Junior. WHOOP! Some of her journey is on the Blinn-TEAM parent perspective thread.
This past admissions cycle was brutal and the offers seemed to take forever to be issued. I think that the volume of applications will be so high that it will take even longer for ALL of those applications to go through Holistic Review. I realize that something has to be done with the admissions process, but I don’t think that throwing the Academic Admit category away is the best way to deal with the volume of applications from so many high achieving students.
The waiting until mid Feb. to receive their decisions was very difficult for both of my girls. I know that the students who achieved Academic Admissions had a much less stressful HS Senior year. And they earned that admission and the opportunity to enjoy their HS Senior year. Hate to see that category scrapped.
This past TAMU admissions cycle was brutal. So many students who would have been full or Blinn-TEAM in past years were offered PSA. There were over 50,000 applications for Fall 2019!! That is mind boggling! I am sure that a portion of those were Academic Admits, high achieving students who ranked in the Top 25% AND had SAT/ACT scores above the TAMU average and who are well rounded, just the type of student expected to thrive at TAMU. Those students worked hard for their class rank AND scores, and they were able to enjoy their Senior year of HS. To now put ALL of those highly qualified students into the Holistic Review will just make the whole process take a lot longer and will make it much more stressful.
Now there will be so much more “playing the gpa/class rank game” to secure a coveted Top 10% slot as that is now the only sure thing. As far as I can see, broadening the Holistic Review category is going to cause more stress on HS students and their parents, and possibly encourage the switching of schools/districts to chase the elusive Top 10%. I can’t imagine how hard it will be when my (future) grandchildren are applying to college.
Just my 2 cents. I hope I am wrong and that the change will magically streamline the process.