<p>dgebll,</p>
<p>I affirm that Emory is a liberal arts college at its root. Like you mentioned, the majority of students graduate outside of the pre-med and b-school tracks. The curriculum is a liberal arts curriculum, all-be-it a loose one that has requirements that can easily be fulfilled in a year or two and allow students to fulfill each one by taking any one of a long list of classes. The average class size is impressively small, and professors are known to be friendly and accessible. The medium-sized student population, the residential and relatively small campus, and division III athletics all hammer the point home that Emory is a liberal arts college.</p>
<p>While I think that Emory students who major in the liberal arts (the one’s who don’t take pre-med classes) are serious, smart students who are legitimately interested in what they major in, I don’t think, on the whole, they are particularly committed to academia. Again, I point to the percentage of these students who go onto to receive a PhD. While I have been able to find this statistic for other universities, I haven’t found it for Emory, but judging from my personal experience, I imagine the percentage is quite low. Moreover, it is worth noting that lots of liberal arts majors who aren’t pre-med were pre-med or pre-business at one time, but dropped these programs because they couldn’t make the grades or for some other reason. I knew several Sociology, Pyschology, etc. majors who fit this mold. These students are hardly less pre-professional – unless the spirit of pre-professionalism is formed by classes rather than aptitude – than their peers who were successful or dedicated enough to keep in these pre-professional programs. Moreover, a large percentage of liberal arts majors at Emory see undergraduate as a stepping stone to law school or some other professional graduate school. While there may be many liberal arts majors who don’t have any developed preprofessional interests, I don’t think this says all that much about Emory’s students passion for the liberal arts. The reason many don’t have pre-professional interests is not because they are too passionate about their academic interests to consider such things or because they want do research or teach after college, but rather because they don’t know what the heck they want to do with their degree after college. </p>
<p>My argument is not that Emory College offers a bad liberal arts education. On the contrary, I think Emory offers a good liberal arts education. Particularly, I think there are great opportunities for student-professor interaction. And all of the other things about Emory – Atlanta, the beautiful campus, etc. – make for a great place to attend college. </p>
<p>But my point is, I don’t think Emory College’s liberal arts program make it stand out from many other colleges that charge over forty thousand dollars per year. There are tons of liberal arts colleges and other national universities that offer comparable liberal arts educations. Whereas the liberal arts (both classes as well as general environment) at some colleges – the Ivies, UChicago, Reed, etc – does stand out and above from Emory and countless others.</p>
<p>What makes Emory special, in my view, is the b-school and pre-med program. That’s what the college guidebooks say. The fact, moreover, that pre-med and b-school are so often discussed on this CC forum says a lot. On other top CC university forums, threads asking, “Is university X really only good for pre-med and b-school?” don’t come up like they do here. It seems to me that Emory students who regularly post on this forum try to deny or play down stereotypes about Emory’s education. This counter effort is a good cause, which is backed by the force of much truth, but I think the counter is often way exaggerated. There is lots of truth to the stereotypes; the rich student body, the high concentration of Long Islanders, the lack of school spirit. These are aspects of Emory that I hope every applicant seriously considers. And the generalization that “Emory is only good for pre-med and business” is poorly stated and offensive, but there is some real wisdom concealed behind it. It is important we recognize that the pre-med program and b-school are the gems of Emory’s education. Not many other universities, even the most pretigious in the natiuon, have a b-school like that of Emory’s. Nor do many other of these universities have such a prominent pre-med program.</p>