As I reread your post let’s get back to your point that UF is ranked higher and you can deduce this by acceptance rate.
Yes UF is ranked higher and yea it has a lower acceptance rate but I would not correlate the two.
I mean your best supply chain colleges, for example, have high acceptance rates. I’m talking about ASU, Mich State, UTK, etc. similar to Syracuse In communications, also a high rate, etc.
The other thing that worries me is you are asking, in essence, which to apply to.
How about both.
My son applied to both (UF and ERAU), Fl Tech, UAH, Arizona, Alabama, Purdue, Maryland, Mines and many more. The original intent was AE but he ultimately did ME because as others pointed out it’s maybe more an avenue to more things. While my son got into all, he ultimately chose Alabama OOS because frankly he could get a single and nice dorm room. Crazy reason but each kid is different.
So what I’m saying is you don’t need to worry about which to apply. Apply to both. Or visit both and see does he dislike one. For example if UF is too big, then focus on small and mid size. If ERAU has shortcomings, then eliminate it and similar.
In the end you want a varied list. Reach. Target. Safety. Don’t know your stats but there are kids with stats off the charts that were turned down at UF and scrambled last minute. So don’t assume it’s a given.
If he likes Florida, there are similar in and out of state schools (many cheap) but if he prefers ERAU, while the list of ‘focused’ schools is smaller, there are fine small/ medium alternatives.
At this point you’ve gotten no offers, etc and with 20 common app spots there’s no reason you can’t easily apply to both.
One thing I’ll warn you about ranking. Forgetting they are different because each judges different things. More importantly, one will spend four years on campus - Day after day after day. A ranking doesn’t bring joy except for b4 enrollment. Find the right fit. I know a W Michigan grad excelling for Collins and while my son decided to go automotive, he knows several interning in Huntsville, Colorado and California at companies like Lockheed and SpaceX.
So find him the right school. US News shouldn’t decide. He should.