Borderline student...can someone read my essay

<p>The average gpa of a Poltiical science transfer student last year was a 3.65. I have a 3.66, but there are 2,000 more applicants this year (so prob. about 150-200 more poli sci applicants). Besides the random factors (ex. I get priority admission as a UC student, higher avg. gpa for the major, who knows honestly??) it seems that my essay will be a huge factor. This is better of the two essays, so if anyone could read it, and tell me what they think, that would be great. Also, does anyone know if they read both essays, or if they just pick one? Thank you</p>

<p>My most memorable accomplishment did not come in the shape of a trophy or a certificate. In fact, one should not call it an accomplishment, for it can never truly be completed.</p>

<p>Growing up, I struggled extensively with obesity. Throughout high school, it seemed my weight was a consistent roadblock to my ambitions. Whether it was asking a girl out on a date, trying to get more playing time on the basketball team, or running for student government, my figure always stood between me and success. Each rejection helped reinforce a domino effect, resulting in my sitting at home binging on comfort food. The verbal abuses stung, and I concluded that the world hated me. As a result I became increasingly depressed, and hid my insecurities by putting on an air of arrogance in front of my classmates.
I might have continued in this fashion, had it not been for my grandfather. He was diagnosed with diabetes, and the doctors warned him that his blood-sugar levels had become life-threatening. He and my father had also struggled with their weight, and both had let it affect their careers and personal lives. Looking at his physical condition was like looking at a window to my future, and I realized I needed to make changes or risk going down the same path. A strenuous diet and exercise regimen was certainly intimidating, but the consequences of failing would be far worse. I began slowly by jogging regularly and cutting out the junk food that had sustained me for so long. It was definitely an uphill battle, forcing myself to run when I was exhausted, or declining my mother's dessert even when it made my mouth water. I had always assumed that my greatest challenges would come from the academic world, but restraining myself pushed me to my physical and emotional limits.
As I began losing weight, I started noticing other changes. The emotional roller coaster I had been on came to a stop, and I was able to control myself in stressful situations. Instead of wallowing in self-pity, I acknowledged the true culprit: my own laziness. I had spent too much time feeling sorry for myself, assuming that things would get better magically. I had not been willing to go out and make the changes for myself, and I suffered for it. I started to feel better about the world around me and developed a stronger work ethic. It became clear that what I had lacked before was not a fit body, but rather the belief in myself. From a whopping 225 pounds I entered college at much-healthier 175 and, more importantly, with a drastically different outlook on life.
I choose not to call my lifestyle change an accomplishment, for doing so would imply that it is no longer a part of my present being. I am aware of how easily I could slip back into my old habits, but the discipline and dedication skills I have learned from the journey reflect my potential as an individual. The lessons gained from this undertaking can be applied to any aspect of my life, be it sports or school. The self-confidence lacking earlier now projects itself with conviction. I apply to the schools I have always dreamed of attending with the same hope of being accepted, but now without the same fear of rejection. The commitment I made to myself taught me that I have the skills to succeed no matter where life takes me, and made me believe in myself both as a student and as a human being.</p>

<p>check you use of commas, air of arrogance?
separate your paragraphs.
sounds helluh cliche – the whole essay. things like emotional coaster lol like lets be original, yeh
i like this –> It became clear that what I had lacked before was not a fit body, but rather the belief in myself. From a whopping 225 poun
–> always dreamed of attending with the same hope of being accepted, but now without the same fear of rejection. = like B but u can do a better job of articulation
ur clincher needs to be stop riding the diq of cliche and come from your heart. like do something very narrow rather than being super super super broad.
does it mean u can’t succeed as a robot. ahahah ***</p>

<p>Okay here’s how I felt about it.</p>

<p>I thought that your conclusion was particularly well written and powerful. However, I feel like your body is a little redundant, and I found myself trailing off a bit in the middle. That’s not to say that admission reps would, but just my experience. </p>

<p>I don’t think it is as cliche as nujabes claims. You improved your outlook on life by improving the physical condition of your body. Is it the most original story ever…no. Is it cliche?..not really. </p>

<p>I feel like your writing skills were satisfactory enough and that your idea was well conveyed and supported…especially at the end. </p>

<p>This was a solid essay on the whole. I’ve definitely read much worse.</p>

<p>I think it’s good. I took a different approach with my second prompt, and found a quality I thought I have then gave several examples. I think my approach went a long way to demonstrate a strength. For some reason I avoided talking at length about difficulties, but I know they like when people do that. </p>

<p>My only criticism of your’s is it could have used some more hopeful notes. You spent a lot more time focusing on your weaknesses and not the person they helped you become. I felt like you were telling me who you were and not who you are.</p>

<p>There are some cliched things going on in there, I didn’t feel like your personality came through, but what’s more important is the overall content.</p>

<p>Thanks for the feedback… EmpathyInAnarchy, you’re right it was difficult trying to get both past and present in. In 600 words it’s a little tough to include everything, hopefully that won’t count too against me.</p>

<p>I actually picked it because I thought it was a pretty original story, and something I actually went through without having to stretch the truth. Most people don’t really worry about weightloss until they’re middle-aged, so I thought that as a teenager I would have something unique. Overweight kids deal with a lot of bullying and the teasing leads to insecurity. Yeah I suppose it does sound a little cliche, but I guess you had to be in my predicament (Kids can be cruel, we all know that)</p>

<p>I didn’t mean your story was cliche, just the way you described it. You framed it in the typical way you would any hardship, and that’s what made it cliche. It almost felt like you took an essay about hardship, and where it said “drug addiction” you replaced it with “weight problems.” And of course, I’m not saying that about your whole essay. It just could have been less generic in places.</p>

<p>Judging from your stats on the other thread, you have a good shot.</p>

<p>My thoughts:</p>

<p>It’s a good STORY per se, but as a personal statement, you want to stir the reader’s emotion… Really grab their attention and bring them into the story. This didn’t do that for me. I didn’t empathize but rather… kind of pitied you (in the most non-*****y way possible). It’s a great topic, yeah, but I think your APPROACH is actually a bit cliche. (I struggled… because of… I worked on it… it was me in the end… now I’m fantastic.) Plus the two words “growing up” is probably the most-used intro in all of personal statement writing history, ha… ha.</p>

<p>Don’t focus too much on your grandpa’s or dad’s health issues. Sure, it’s only a few sentences, but direct the attention more towards yourself (let your inner ego free!). You can make those three sentences into one (which is another problem - you seem to just drag on what you’re trying to say. You can be precise and detailed at the same time.)</p>

<p>The second paragraph was eh to me… I don’t want to know how you lost weight. Rather, I’d like to know the struggles you were going through while doing so - struggles deeper than things like resisting your mom’s dessert. Show me your emotions, thoughts, feelings, all that jazz.</p>

<p>I feel like you’re emphasizing more on the physical weight loss itself rather than the experience of it (unless that’s what you’re going for?).</p>

<p>The last paragraph is alright but a bit vague. You say it reflects who you are now and you’ve learned lessons that can be applied to all aspects of your life. Either explain yourself (what kind of lessons did you learn? how does it reflect who you are?) or simply narrow it down.</p>

<p>Crack open the thesaurus (but not too much…). I know it’s a rough draft but make sure you really work on ways to impress - higher-level vocabulary, consistency (organization), sophistication… yada yada. Work on writing skills most definitely.</p>

<p>Good luck!</p>

<p>I agree with edelynly.</p>

<p>Overall, I felt like there was some sort of void in this essay. Maybe it’s the lack of emotion but I didn’t feel your struggles; I just read about it.</p>

<p>Also, cut this essay by 100 words or so since it’s superfluous and you’ll have more words for the other prompt.</p>

<p>CONDENSE, CONDENSE, CONDENSE</p>

<p>“I might have continued in this fashion, had it not been for my grandfather. He was diagnosed with diabetes, and the doctors warned him that his blood-sugar levels had become life-threatening. He and my father had also struggled with their weight, and both had let it affect their careers and personal lives. Looking at his physical condition was like looking at a window to my future, and I realized I needed to make changes or risk going down the same path.”</p>

<p>can become
I might have continued in this fashion, had it not been for my grandfather’s diagnosis with diabetes. His condition had become life-threatening. He and my father had also struggled with their weight, and both had let it affect their careers and personal lives. Looking at his physical condition was like looking at a window to my future, and I realized I needed to make changes or risk going down the same path did not like what I saw.</p>

<p>YAY [s] doesn’t work…
I might have continued in this fashion, had it not been for my grandfather’s diagnosis with diabetes. His condition had become life-threatening. Looking at his physical condition was like looking at a window to my future, and I realized I did not like what I saw.</p>

<p>half the length and equal impact. Congrats, now you can add more content and important details.</p>

<p>here I’ll just rewrite some of it. You’ve got a great foundation, there’s just a bit too much bloat.</p>

<p>Growing up, I struggled extensively with obesity. Throughout high school, my weight seemed a consistent roadblock to my ambitions. Whether it was asking a girl out on a date, getting playing time on the basketball team, or running for student government, my figure always stood between me and success. The verbal abuses stung, and I concluded that the world hated me. Each rejection reinforced itself in a domino effect, and I regressed to sitting at home and binging on comfort food. As I became increasingly depressed, I hid my insecurities by putting on an facade of arrogance in front of my classmates.
I might have continued in this fashion, had it not been for my grandfather’s diagnosis with diabetes. His condition had become life-threatening. Looking at his physical condition was like looking at a window to my future, and I realized I did not like what I saw. A strenuous diet and exercise regimen was intimidating, but the consequences of failing would be far worse. I began slowly by jogging regularly and cutting the junk food that had sustained me for so long. It was an uphill battle forcing myself to run to exhaustion, and declining my mother’s dessert made my mouth water. I had always assumed that my greatest challenges would come from the academic world, but restraining myself pushed me to my physical and emotional limits.
As I began losing weight, I started noticing other changes. The emotional roller coaster I had been on came to a stop, and I was able to control myself in stressful situations. Instead of wallowing in self-pity, I acknowledged the true culprit, my own laziness. I had spent too much time feeling sorry for myself, assuming that things would get better magically. I had not been willing to go out and make the changes for myself, and I suffered for it. I started to feel better about the world around me and developed a stronger work ethic. It became clear that what I had lacked before was not a fit body, but rather the belief in myself. I entered college 50 pounds lighter and with a drastically different outlook on life.
I choose not to call my lifestyle change an accomplishment, for doing so would imply that it is no longer a part of my present being. I am aware of how easily I could regress into my old habits, but the discipline I have learned from the journey will not wane. The lessons gained from this undertaking can be applied to any aspect of my life, be it sports or school. The self-confidence lacking earlier now projects itself with conviction. I apply to the schools I have always dreamed of attending with the same hope of being accepted, but now without the same fear of rejection. The commitment I made taught me that I have the skills to succeed no matter where life takes me, and made me believe in myself both as a student and as a human being.</p>

<p>and on top of that you could still cut some more(it’s at 500 words, aim for 400) and swap some words around. I can think of more things to cut, but you should be doing that yourself. REMOVE CRAP. Read through it, it should sound like a speech, if you had to give a speech and had to deal with a time constraint you’d hit big details and add in a little bit of powerful language here and there. College admission personnel read through A LOT of crap, make their job easy for them. I would redo the first paragraph(and combine the first line with it please)</p>

<p>ohh and on an unrelated note, you should probably be looking to gain some weight back(muscle mass) <a href=“http://bodybuilding.com/[/url]”>http://bodybuilding.com/&lt;/a&gt; if you only cut, you’ll basically starve yourself and destroy your endocrine system, you need to bulk up a bit to benefit from a health perspective(you can always alternate between bulking and cutting) This is coming from someone who went the other way(5’9" 100lbs to 5’10" 160 and lean) you want to be lean AND muscular. you’ll notice your skin will look MUCH healthier and you’ll feel better in general. Good luck man, it really is a lifestyle.</p>

<p>^ I agree with xelink</p>

<p>Dieting the starving doesn’t work. You have to fundamentally change your diet. </p>

<p>Cut out the refined sugar , Cut out the processed food , cut out all the seasoning and start on a exercise regime. You really start building body mass and cut away the fat. </p>

<p>You weight isn’t really a problem it’s excess fat you can try p90x but it’s a bit intense if you aren’t in some shape already or try their beginner program power 90 which is easier but not by much and it’ll get you ready for p90x</p>

<p>Are you applying for next year or something? Haven’t you already submitted it and can’t change it anymore?</p>

<p>Yeah, Isn’t it a bit too late for this?</p>

<p>Bingeing… you spelled in binging</p>

<p>That said, xelink is giving you some good advice. Condensing is always good- why use 2 words when you can use 1? (Mark Twain said that)</p>

<p>And if people don’t feel your struggles, it’s because they’ve never dealt with something similar. (Which is something to keep in mind- what if the admissions reviewer can’t relate? Did you make everything clear enough?) Your situation is pretty much identical to my boyfriend’s, but I watched him go through this process. It’s not easy- it consumes your life. I think you related it well to school both at the beginning and at the end. I like it a lot, but it could use a re-write with a lot of xelink’s tips.</p>

<p>Who cares what your essays say? It’s all a done deal now. Good luck homie! Waiting sucks but we are all in the same boat. Writing those essays were difficult… I think you will make it in. :)</p>

<p>Shouldn’t you have written this to explain who you are in the context of why you want to study poli sci at UC _____?</p>

<p>Think of it (prompt 2) as a typical question for job interview, when the hiring manager says to you, “So, tell me about yourself.” You wouldn’t respond by telling him/her about your weight problem. It should be relevant to what your applying for. In this case, you might want to communicate some of the accomplishments you’ve made as a student, volunteer, student gov’t committee member, etc. and use these examples to reinforced your decision to continue with your education. Also, if you have weaknesses do not use negative language to describe them. You wouldn’t do it in a job interview, don’t do it in the personal statment. There is always a more positive alternative to a negative phrase.</p>

<p>The personal statement is technically two essays but it should read as one. If you spent the first essay talking about your interest in poli sci and the second talking about your weight you probably left admissions readers feeling disconnected and, if you did, your personal statement as a whole is definitely diffuse. </p>

<p>Overall, your statement is not going to keep you out of anywhere but it definitely won’t give you that extra boost if you’re borderline. They will probably just feel that you did not completely understand the purpose of the writing assignment and consider it a failed opportunity.</p>

<p>Well, too late now. But good luck anyways. </p>

<p>BTW where did you apply?</p>

<p>agreed, it might bet two essays but it SHOULD read as one. When I did both of my essays, they read fine independently but reinforced each other when read together. </p>

<p>remember, this essay is NOT about your weight, it’s about your perseverance and character. You should focus on how you’ve developed. These essays are like first dates or a job interview. Speak up on yourself, be a little cocky but don’t come off as being conceited. You accomplishment isn’t your weight loss, it’s the acquisition of character and the development of discipline you acquired from it.</p>

<p>I’ve heard the opposite advice. There are two prompts as a reason. Both responses should be about the applicant, and ultimately relate back to the applicant’s major, but talking about leadership or perseverance in one and their passion for their field of study in the other doesn’t seem diffuse. It’s what they asked for.</p>

<p>EmpathyInAnarchy is spot on. My advisors said the exact thing.</p>