Carnegie Mellon, poor SAT 2's, retake?

<p>Kay, so I'll give all the basics and then discuss my thoughts at the bottom.</p>

<p>96% average, weighted. Would that be 4.0?</p>

<p>4th out of about 90, so top 5%.</p>

<p>4 on US History AP, taking Calculus and English Literature AP this year.</p>

<p>SAT's (taken a year ago)
670 Reading
660 Math
750 Writing</p>

<p>Subject
620 Physics
730 Math 2</p>

<p>ACT's
35 English (32 combined)
35 Math
32 Reading
30 Science
33 Composite</p>

<p>EC's</p>

<p>National Honor Society VP, National Merit Commended Scholar.</p>

<p>I'm president of my church's and school's Christian youth groups. This year, I raised the membership of the school youth group to 4X it's original number. The church youth group volunteers every second Saturday.</p>

<p>Cross Country and Track, captain.</p>

<p>Technology Student Association, highest scorer on the school's math team.</p>

<p>I will be visiting Carnegie Mellon for Sleeping Bag Weekend later this month. I'll get to talk to professors, admissions, coaches, get an interview. I figure it'll help.</p>

<p>Both of my essays, I believe, were very good. They do not worry me.</p>

<p>Really, my main worry is my physics SAT. The story on that is that I realized about November that SAT Subject Tests were required. I took it in December. I'm pretty good with advanced math, but I'm only taking physics THIS YEAR, so I was definitely ill-prepared (I actually asked my physics teacher to mention this in his recommendation.) I can't imagine that one aspect of my application can be that damaging - can it? What are your thoughts? I'm already set up to retake, and I'm pretty sure the new score can be slipped in before the time I'm judged, but how important are the SAT 2s to Carnegie Mellon? Any semi-experts on the place? Thanks!</p>

<p>Could I at least get a comment about the SAT 2 scores? Thank you!</p>

<p>i wouldn’t worry about them; i’m turning in a 650 physics myself and i’m really not that worried.</p>

<p>depends what yer lookin to study?</p>

<p>if yer lookin towards engineering then those aren’t the best scores possible :confused: unless ye have a 5 in AP physics or maybe a 4 that proves ye otherwise, it won’t really help yer app :(</p>

<p>Yeah, actually I am going for engineering…it’s like my ONE bad thing. How harmful do you think that is?</p>