I stand corrected. I just went back and check our spreadsheet from his college application days. He applied ED to American. Deferred to RD, then denied. But thinking back, I’m not sure if it was ED. Either way, the decision was “no”. lol
He ended up at University of Dayton, which is working fine.
We needed a significant amount of FinAid to make a private university affordable and UD was one of about 8-12 that did so for us. The funny thing is all the urban schools on the backend of USNWR T125 list have low admit rates … because they are in famous locations and made the T100 (or are close.) Want to go to any city (city with a capital C) on the East Coast and attend a top-100 school? Better bring great stats and, for some like American, expect little FinAid.
However, my search of hundreds of schools (and applying to dozens) revealed little academic differences between the two groups of schools. Of course, everyone’s opinion may vary and some will insist there is some sort of significant difference. I checked graduation rates, employment rates, and salary outcomes, and I found no meaningful differences or differences that favored the “other” schools.
So, Fordham U is a difficult admit for your stats, but Marquette is not so difficult. American U is difficult, but maybe Rollins or Marist are less difficult. Howard and Spelman are difficult admits, but Clark U or NCA&T or Hampton U are less so - and Clark shares a campus with Spelman/Morehouse and some classes.
If you still have slots open on Common App, check out schools like Dayton, Marquette, Rollins, Marist, Manhattan College, Christopher Newport, Emerson, St Joseph and even SMU (which accepted my son for Jan admission and offered enough FinAid to be affordable.) They’re all in decent sized to large cities, if you’re trying to avoid rural locations. And all are seemingly within your search radius, though Marquette may be a bit further out. But if Marquette is workable, also check out St Louis U, Butler, Depaul and U of St Thomas.
In our case, negligible FinAid (somewhat expected because CNU is an OOS public) eliminated CNU from our consideration though he was offered admission. In your case, CNU would be affordable.