<p>@celesteroberts. The major differences between ASU and U of A is this for In-state students, ASU draws so many students from the Phoenix-metro area far more than the dorms can handle freshman year, few very few Sopho’s let alone juniors ever stay in dorms at ASU, and I am not sure that even Barrett students can stay in dorms past their second year. At UofA the oos students fill all the dorms freshman and they also have to option to dorm 2nd year, often times in-state Phoenix students dorm their 2nd year, my DS11 could have but moved into the fraternity house his HS bf lived in the dorms sophomore year. Further many more Phoenix students attend ASU as a % than Tucson students attend UofA, I heard from admissions its like 60%/40%, so a student has a much higher chance to dorm at UofA second year than an ASu student during their sophomore year. Anecodtotal I agree!</p>
<p>I have to disagree graduating from ASU is not recognized as a good thing, it is one of the easiest schools in the country to get into, that’s my point, students go there often because its easy to get into, Barrett has become embarassingly easy recent years to get in because its so large, Barrett and 6000 students is more than 3 x larger than my DS14 LAC, student/faculty ratio even at Barrett is nowhere near LAC levels because ASU is SO BIG. As an employer ASU students generally are not as bright as other colleges, good but not really a generally ‘bright’ as UC or East Coast Privates or Publics. I can call a Purdue/NYU/PennState /UCSD/UCLA grad from an ASU student most days and I know which all other things being equal will get the job.</p>
<p>To @beaudreau’s point Whilst I agree a good proportion of ASU/Barrett students go onto to grad school, you would have to admit they don’t do so at the same rate or to most schools which often OOS privates or even UC’s do.
I was at Vassar recently and their grad school rate was far higher than ASU/Barrett and the school’s Wesleyan grads get into was off the charts comp to ASU (btw I popped into career services at ASU to check)!, They are in a different league.</p>
<p>It’s a different league!, you either buy a Ford to get you from A to B and don’t care about the ride, or you buy a BMW get a different vehicle and are known to drive a BMW, even though the Ford may get you to the same place in the same time, horses for courses!</p>
<p>I agree with your neighbor I would not send my DS to Fordham (overrated catholic school) for Brophy kids who want to be in NYC, but when you DS is good enough to get full tuition to an EC private LAC, why not when it could cost less than in-state public and they get 4 years on campus dorms!</p>
<p>One last point to Beaudreau I DO think it makes difference to Grad schools where you got your undergrad, whilst I agree after grad school your undergrad matter less. Competitive programs at PharmaD schools in the Midwest and EC are very keen on where you did your undergrad and to get into a Top 10 law School, YOU really do need to be graduating from a better undergrad program (ASU does not cut it) if you want a good chance to be accepted, I am not familiar with Med schools, not my area, but I do suspect it is the same, your undergrad University or college I really do think matters. I recently interviewed for ASU a grad from Berkeley, who did grad school at U Mich, he got the nod over another who graduated from ASU and did grad school at U Washington, both good grad school programs but the ASU grad could not play with the Berkeley undergrads SAT/Scores and known selective nature (% admittance), ASU is NOT as strong at getting grads into top grad school programs, it cant be, though there should be exceptions at Barrett/ASU.</p>