Chance me please! Plucking up the courage to ask for opinions.

<p>Ever since I sent my ED app for Columbia in, I have been obsessed with CollegeConfidential chance me's. In order to ease my impatience, will you all chance me?</p>

<p>Chance Me? </p>

<hr>

<p>ACT: </p>

<p>Composite: 31
Reading: 36
Math: 27
Writing: 36
Science: 29
Combined English/Writing: 34 (10 out of 12 on the essay)</p>

<p>Sat Subject Tests
670 on US History, 710 on Literature</p>

<p>GPA: Weighted is 3.92, Unweighted is 3.63</p>

<p>AP Tests:
5 on English Language, 4 on US History, 3 on AP Euro</p>

<p>EC:
Key Club President
Tutor a student at my church weekly (volunteer)
Newspaper Staff -- section editor
Varsity Basketball
NHS
Active in church youth (leader) and choir</p>

<p>Awards:
AP Scholar
Bearden's Best (highest grade in AP English III across all classes)
Published in school's literary magazine</p>

<p>Recs: One really good one (English teacher and newspaper advisor), one pretty good one (Senior English teacher)</p>

<p>Other factors: Great essay about overcoming insecurity to run for president of key club; visited Columbia and tied that visit in for my "why Columbia question" on the app.</p>

<p>Thank you guys so much for doing this! I appreciate your time and effort. :D I'm excited to be a part of this community with my first post!</p>

<p>Oh, I also had an alumni interview that went very well. I was able to ask intelligent questions, learn more about the school, and I think I seemed very knowledgeable about Columbia and its programs.</p>

<p>Bump? Anyone?</p>

<p>why do you want people to chance you? what if someone told you you did not have a very good chance?</p>

<p>You have as good of a chance as anyone else. Good luck to you. Let know know!!!</p>

<p>@admisisonsgeek, I think a lot of the things you post are really informative and helpful! </p>

<p>I don’t understand why but for whatever reason a lot of the things you posted today were rude and extremely unkind…If you reread what you wrote, your responses were really harsh. Maybe the next time you post take a second to read a question a little more slowly and if you choose to respond you do so with a calmer voice.</p>

<p>Thank you stopandbelieve. I definitely agree. And admissions geek, why does anyone do chance me? We want to make the waiting time go faster and prepare ourselves for the decision. I want a reality check so I am not crushed when the decision comes. You should remember that the people who post on here are KIDS. There is no need to be condescending and rude just because you graduated from an ivy league school and are knowledgeable about admissions.</p>

<p>The reason why( i think) admissions geek was ****ed today was because he gives his time over and over again and it seems no one is reading the posts and learning anything. They were just talking about chance threads and how useless they are.</p>

<p>it was an honest question here - why do you want to be chanced? because if it is for a reality check, i think the problem with chance threads especially if you have already submitted an application is that if you get bad news - is that better than just receiving no news? i’m thinking from an education perspective, what is healthiest for you.</p>

<p>i choose not to participate in chance threads because i think they are unnecessarily fatalistic, and proved by the fact that you have bumped your thread hoping for something. my effort here is to extinguish the desire to ask for chances than necessarily to fuel it. i thought about my comments, and though i was more annoyed at another post, sure it carried over, i sometimes think that a bad guy is fine on these fora. i am not here to make you like me, i am here to push things in appropriate directions. chance questions are best for people who know you - guidance counselors, private counselors, friends with more insight. especially as none of us have expertise on this matter, we are novices trying to help, and that can in fact hurt.</p>

<p>i will however break my rule because i guess i think it might demonstrate the problem with chance threads. i have a feeling you know your chances are not that great, which prompts the chance forum in the first place. in reality you are on the borderline, there are some students who look like you who may be admitted, but the vast vast vast majority will not. you are a good student who seems to be doing everything right, but nothing about your application is outstanding or would help you stand out in a pool, even in an early decision pool. without knowing everything, we might veer to negatively, or perhaps we might be too positive.</p>

<p>like how good are you at executing your essay about being insecure, the problem with ‘weakness’ essays is that their attempt often to make it seem like you rose like a phoenix comes across as contrived and ultimately uninteresting for a reader. what if your personal reading of your essay is not the way your admissions officer sees it? your work in writing seems to be a focal point, but your sat IIs don’t really showcase your talents. key club certainly might be something of interest, but it is unclear from just this thread what it actually means - how much time, how important is it to your school, what have you done that is different than your predecessors, perhaps this is answered in your essay, perhaps not. </p>

<p>the biggest factor that folks for the most part on chance threads don’t know - and i must admit i don’t know how to weigh this either - is deal with the question of context. are you impressive coming from tennessee? i guess that depends if you’re applying from knoxville, memphis or somewhere smaller. it depends on your socioeconomic background, what do you have access to. is your family from eastern tennessee and the applachias? these are context clues that would massively change how to read your application. if i were to do a snap judgment on your profile, i’d say you stand a very poor chance of being admitted, but would i then be helping or hurting you? making you feel less good about yourself and your amazing accomplishments by refocusing the gaze on how good are you at the admissions game instead of concentrating on how good you are as a person? would i be properly contextualizing your experience and providing the right kind of support? i think not, i’d rather you read the above with deep skepticism. and hopefully you will come to trust your own instincts about things.</p>

<p>What hurts you, Clairebear, is that you haven’t ventured much beyond your high school. For example, there’s nothing with something like a Governor’s School (at the state-level) or making an all Conference athletic team (at the regional-level). Take the time you have left to work on your other applications, and make sure that you give yourself some choices when it comes to decision time (don’t apply to too many reach schools like Columbia). Best of luck to you in your college search!</p>