Choosing Teachers for Recommendation

<p>Hello, I am a junior, and I am very undecided on which teachers to ask for recs. The problem is that I have performed well in many of my classes, but I also feel that I made a few bad mistakes in all of them.</p>

<p>Of course, I might be too worried about those mistakes, but after reading some threads on CC, I have a feeling that I can only receive good recs by being a crystal-clean star student.</p>

<p>Here are some possibilities I have in mind:</p>

<p>1) Junior-year AP Biology teacher</p>

<p>Good: My grade in her class is quite stellar. I believe my average was either highest or very close to highest among all of her AP Bio classes in the first quarter. During class, I always strove to participate the most in my class. I went to every extra credit field trips she announced. I occasionally chatted with her about the latest news on Scientific American.</p>

<p>Bad: During presentations, I showed tendency to go a bit overtime. Once, I mistakenly followed an old class monthly schedule and failed to turn in a quiz-level assignment that she does not accept late. Although I knew she would not grade the assignment, I still turned one in the next day to show that I could have turned it in. During the second quarter, I performed poorly in one of her weekly tests and two of her (almost) daily quizzes. Once, I dropped a dissecting scope plate that was easily replaceable but not very cheap.</p>

<p>2) Sophomore-year/(definitely) senior-year math teacher</p>

<p>Good: Despite his reputation for being extremely tough, I managed to get an A in all but one tests. Although I was not planning to take his extremely rigorous post-AP math course in the beginning of the year, I managed to change my schedule for the second semester after incessantly lobbying with my counselor. Even though I did not have him for junior year, I went to greet him almost everyday. I will have him again during senior year for another highly rigorous course of his. Also, I have heard that he is quite good at writing recs.</p>

<p>Bad: Because I had to run around in hot sun (PE/Gym) right before his class, I was very often tired in his class. On several occasions, I was awake enough to take notes, but I am afraid he noticed that I had a hard time keeping myself awake. Also, I am not sure how he interpreted my taking another math course taught by another math teacher during junior year. I took the other course mainly due to my interest in the subject, and I knew that I would take his course in my senior year.</p>

<p>3) Junior-year/(possibly) senior-year AP Physics teacher</p>

<p>Good: I performed well in all his tests, maintaining a near-top average for the whole year. I have never turned in a late assignment in his class. I participated in a club that he sponsored. I did every single extra credit problem he gave weekly. I have heard that he was a terrific rec writer, who is willing to call colleges if he believes that certain student should have been admitted.</p>

<p>Bad: I could never really open up to him. I do participate in class, but not as much (well, it could be argued that he doesn't really give any student chance to speak up). Similar to my mistake with sophomore-year math teacher (but to much less extent), I had hard time keeping myself awake during some classes. I am not sure whether he noticed or not, since I still took good notes.</p>

<p>Please reply with your words of wisdom!</p>

<p>All of those teachers seem fine; honestly, I doubt that any of them will screw you over with a horrible recommendation just because you took another math class after theirs (they’re not going to see it as adultery or anything) or dropped a scope plate two years ago. The only piece of advice that I have is to get a recommendation from a teacher that you’ve had most recently and to follow the recommendations of the college. Some colleges actually ask you not to use senior year teachers because they haven’t had you for an entire year yet, but that won’t be an issue for you.</p>

<p>I definitely agree that any of those teachers would probably be fine. The problems you had with them seem minor, and, to be honest, I doubt they would even remember those things. My suggestion would be to pick teachers that have seen your personality. If you participate in his/her class or actually have conversations with them outside of class, it will probably be much easier to ask for the recommendation, and the teacher will be more willing to write it. So, yeah, whichever teachers you are closest to would probably be the best choices. And don’t worry about those minor issues; I’m sure they’ve seen much, much worse.</p>

<p>Thank you for the advice!</p>

<p>I will make sure to focus more on speaking with them outside of class.</p>

<p>You seem like a good student, so I’m sure all of those teachers will have great things to say about you. My advice is to also consider the promptness and reliability ot each teacher. I would have really liked my bio teacher to write me a rec (since I would like to major in biology) but I decided against it because I knew she isn’t too reliable and would likely write something at the last minute.</p>