So agree with you and see even more issues with how CB has handled their once-valuable outreach program.
Each school has a budget for scholarships. The AZ schools have BIG budgets to draw in top students, and so ASU was in a great rhythm for multiple years of attracting talent and drawing them in (with top notch marketing / PR / messaging for Barrett, etc).
Whatever changes hit out graduating class really is not on ASU, and I can see why they are scrambling since it is hard to ‘make change’ to financial policies in the educational space, especially at a state school since they answer to their state in addition to their board. The College Board’s sudden and dramatic changes this year to a long established program would cause these schools to run out of budgeted scholarship $s real fast. (No one in an admissions or financial aid department wants to lose their job by blowing their budget by millions).
Just even one year ago, 2021-2022 entering class, the only game in town regarding CB programs was NMF and NRHP. And NRHP required top 2.5%. College Board in one year expanded to three more ‘affinity’ groups (I say ‘affinity’ not to offend or minimize anyone’s heritage, but rather to state the obvious that Westlake, TX and Laguna Beach, CA are NOT underserved, small rural towns… check that list, it is insane.) And they had it apply to top 10% which further expands the pool. Plus other ways to qualify like the 2 AP Test criteria noted by @martinezcs. All of that together could easily have generated enough candidates by Nov 1 to fill the entire Barrett entering class, with no one paying tuition… That would a) way blow past whatever their budget is and b) exclude many Arizona resident students with high credentials who did not apply super early.
CB has kind of turned their formerly life-changing (as measured by it’s ability to generate scholarships, and therefore access, for awardees) into more of a cynical PR tool for CB to pat itself on the back for recognizing diverse and underserved communities. (With the exception of the incompetent try at targeting rural students with less access.). You get a certificate and a recognition to list on applications, which of course is still of value, but the tuition awards go away.
OK, done with today’s rant. Just saying that as much as the schools’ changes sting, it really is not fair to place blame on ASU or UofA for leaning into whatever high school grade/GPA standard their state BOE provides input into. The GPA thing, blessed by the State of Arizona already, gives ASU cover in a bad situation. ASU was all in on CB’s PSAT, and attracted the students needed to ensure Barrett’s effectiveness for future employers, until they got cut off at the knees.
And now, we parents wait to see what the fallout is for our 2022 graduates.