Deciding to go to UMBC or other college?

<p>Okay, I'm in a college-bound dilemma, so please bear with me.</p>

<p>UMBC is my cheapest financial option, especially since I got a decent scholarship from them. Unfortunately, it was also my fallback option (I would say that it was my worst and least competitive school). I really don't want to go there because its academics, ambiance, and overall merit and ranking are below my other schools (Wisconsin-Madison, Illinois, UMD, Michigan), but my parents are really pushing me towards this school. </p>

<p>Is it really that much easier to get good grades at UMBC than UMD, or is that a myth?</p>

<p>I'm worried that going to this school will place me at a disadvantage (however slight) for applying to a good or prestigious medical school since UMBC isn't that competitive of a school. If there are any UMBC pre-med students out there, how did you guys decide to go to UMBC versus other colleges, and how have you prepared for the medical school admissions? Is UMD more well-known for better MCAT preparation, or does UMBC have a good track record for the MCAT as well (that is, an average of 30+)? How are the research opportunities and the Biological Sciences Program of UMBC versus UMD?</p>

<p>Also, has anyone received a Honors College acceptance/ denial letter yet? I have yet to hear back from them with a decision of any kind; I plan to call UMBC tomorrow, but I wonder about everyone else's status at this point. </p>

<p>I got into Wisconsin-Madison's L&S Honors Program and UMD's Life Sciences Scholars Program and got some smaller scholarships from Illinois and Wisconsin. However, unless I take a loan, my Midwestern schools are probably not financially viable, and whether I get an acceptance from the Honors Program will definitely factor into my weighing of UMD versus UMBC. Anyone have an opinion on whether Scholars from UMD or Honors from UMBC is better?</p>

<p>My son and I are going to visit UMBC a second time tomorrow. He has been accepted into the Honors College (back in February) and has been offered an impressive OOS merit scholarship. </p>

<p>Our shared impressions of UMBC are rather at odds with your characterization of it. It appears to be an impressive academic institution as it is focused on undergraduate education, particularly in providing research experience that leads to graduate work. In fact, the focus of the school is to get the students exceptional grad school placements (including med school), particularly in the STEM fields. </p>

<p>If anything, the possible deficits with UMBC are (1) it’s still not the flagship school in the state of MD and (2) they’ve historically put less focus on the non-academic portion of the student experience than the flagship schools you’ve mentioned above.</p>

<p>I can add some more insights tomorrow, as we’ll have a chance to chat with staff from the Honors college. But it seems that you give up very little in terms of grad school placement at UMBC – what you give up is the big-time atmosphere of a flagship university. You have to decide whether that’s important to you.</p>

<p>Thanks for the reply. So would you say that the STEM major programs at UMBC are better than UMD? Did your son apply for UMD as well? </p>

<p>I plan on visiting UMBC soon too on one of their open house dates.</p>

<p>I’m an in-stater, and most of my friends also placed UMBC as a last-choice school; many of them didn’t even apply for UMBC because of its overall lack of prestige and panache- the campus is just nowhere as nice to look at. :P</p>

<p>I would still say that UMBC’s academics are nowhere as good or competitive as UMD’s… maybe a STEM major who’s already had some UMBC experience could give his/ her opinion about the school?</p>

<p>My son did not apply to UMCP – we are NJ residents, so Rutgers (and Stony Brook) were his flagship schools of choice. In terms of prestige, probably UMCP is better. In terms of the **quality of the undergraduate academic experience <a href=“even%20their%20rethinking%20the%20way%20introductory%20STEM%20classes%20are%20taught”>/B</a>, it’s hard to argue with UMBC’s value proposition. </p>

<p>Look at some of the past threads on CC – UMCP certainly has the cachet, but some Marylanders (is that what you call yourselves?) who are accepted to both have chosen UMBC because:

  1. It’s a much more personalized experience, without sacrifcing the opportunity to learn at a Carnegie High Research university
  2. They are willing to sacrifice the social / athletic aura of College Park</p>

<p>As I said, we’ll ask questions to explore some of the points about the undergraduate experience to a greater depth when we visit tomorrow.</p>

<p>if you’re deciding between UMD & UMBC, I would suggest UMD. I’m in-state for Maryland & I got accepted for UMBC’s honors program & UMD’s scholars program. I chose UMD because, in my opinion, it has the whole package. It definitely prepares you for the MCAT. My cousin went to UMD as a biology major & from there, went to medical school in Indiana & now works at John Hopkins as a surgeon for their hospital. It also has the social aspect that UMBC seems to lack, at least from what my friends tell me who go to UMBC. I’ve visited UMBC, I liked the campus, but UMD’s was definitely much better. & UMD is right next to DC, being in the Life Sciences Program definitely helps you get research opportunities that you wouldn’t get at UMBC.</p>

<p>But it really all comes down to you.</p>

<p>Thank you both for your replies! </p>

<p>mtown, I agree that it’s more personalized, but I think that’s just because it can cater to fewer students because of its smaller campus size. I have heard that their STEM program is pretty good because of its proximity to hospital and research opportunities, but I’ve also heard that their pre-med program isn’t as good as UMD, and their overall academics still don’t seem as strong as Maryland.</p>

<p>I personally would prefer to go to UMD myself (and, yeah, I definitely agree that UMBC is lacking in the social side), but I’m kind of apprehensive of UMD’s supposedly more difficult coursework over UMBC’s. trackdude, it’s interesting that you chose UMD’s Scholars over UMBC’s Honors; it’s one of the dilemmas that I have to consider right now. What benefits do you have in UMD’s Scholars over UMBC’s Honors or vice versa? Are you currently pursuing a research opportunity? That’s really cool for your cousin, btw!</p>

<p>I know of at least one person from UMD who ended up not being able to become a doctor because her grades weren’t high enough. I also heard that if you want to pursue the Pre-Med track, you can’t ever get a C or lower on a transcript grade unless you manage to retake it. Is that true for both College Park and Baltimore County? Would it be listed on my transcript that I retook a course, or would it be listed like I took the course for the first time?</p>

<p>I have to say I’m a little bummed out that UMBC doesn’t seem to offer studio art courses or majors; could someone back me up or refute that finding?</p>

<p>well, the scholars program has sub programs within the program & I chose Life Sciences. luckily, I was admitted into it & I’m a chem major (luckily I was admitted into that as well). with me being in Life Sciences, it allows me to have a plethora of research opportunities, assistant opportunities & actually be able to see what it’s like to work in the medical field which is something I’d like to do. sure, the coursework is more difficult, but in the long run it will definitely be worth it. </p>

<p>unfortunately, I don’t have the answers to your other questions. when it came down to it for me, I didn’t look at the cons of either school, I just saw which school’s pros outweighed the other. it was clearly UMD for me</p>

<p>DS in sort of the same dilemma - UMBC scholarship, accepted to honors program; UM no offers, but much better program. DS studying music and UM’s school of music carries much more prestige than UMBC’s (if they carry any). </p>

<p>Let me just say that one time we visited UMBC and met a premed student who was in his last year and was being courted (with generous offers) by Johns Hopkins and Harvard (or some other Ivy). He chose Johns Hopkins. Said that to say that it seems that even great med schools value UMBC’s premed training.</p>

<p>Kikobird,</p>

<p>I just saw this thread and don’t know if you have made a decision yet. If you are pre-med then undergrad is not your terminal degree. You need to ask yourself which school will provide you with the support that YOU need to get into medical school. Visit the schools again and go to the pre-med office or Office of Professional Advising. Tell them what you want to do and ask them how they will make that happen for you. Do not worry about the “panache” of a school. Worry about which school is going to help you achieve your goals and it sounds like right now your goal is gaining entrance into medical school. It is achievable from both institutions but you have to sit down and think about what is best for you, not for your friends, but for you.</p>

<p>easy pre-med??? There is no such thing. UMBC STEM is outstanding. Research and internship opportunities are amazing. They have amazing placement for MD and PhD programs. The campus is VERY academic…but isn’t that what you should be looking for? I’ve never met a pre-med student who has the time for lots of activities outside of studying. I think you need to do some more research.</p>

<p>Hi, all, thanks for responding more to my post. No, I haven’t made a decision yet. I really want to make one this week, though, just to get it over with so that I can hopefully secure a dorm in time. I recently talked with some former College Park students, and they actually said that while College Park is the more academically difficult school overall (especially because of those massive freshman classes!), the Pre-Med program at UMBC is rumored to be quite difficult, which is a bit of a surprise, considering the higher national prestige of UMCP in general.</p>

<p>proudmom1313, I know that pre-med is bound to be a stressful, back-breaking program, but there is most likely a distinction. If the entry stats to either school say anything, UMBC is expected to be somewhat less academically competitive than UMCP. I also know that they’re more lenient with transfer credits and retake policies, so that speaks for aspect.</p>

<p>I visited both for official college visit dates just this past weekend, basically. I absolutely loved CP’s campus; I’m kind of turned off by BC’s bleaker, more barren campus, unfortunately. Still, I found out more information about my status regarding the two schools that may make a huge influence. </p>

<p>For CP, I unfortunately learned that I’m only in the Letters and Science program right now, so I wasn’t good enough to get into the Bio major program right off the bat. I’ll need to take some gateway courses to get into the major, so I can’t appeal until probably my sophomore year. I don’t know if that would make a difference in the eyes of medical school admissions or if I would lose time in my college career (as in, could I still take the same classes as most freshmen Bio majors?). :frowning: </p>

<p>For BC and all my other schools, I fortunately did get into the Biology major, so on that respect, BC wins. However, another dilemma I have is that I did not get into the Meyerhoff or Honors Program at UMBC; I just heard back recently. I’m very disappointed, so in that respect, UMCP has the advantage with the Scholars Life Sciences Program. In high school, I was in a selective program, so to go to UMBC without a selective program placement like the Meyerhoff or Honors Program would require me to seriously swallow my pride… It’s just a little depressing, really. I know that some students are able to apply for the Honors Program during college, though; does anyone know of anyone who has successfully done this alternate route into the Honors Program? Do you think it’s worth turning down the College Park Scholars Program for a UMBC Scholarship?</p>

<p>I checked the stats at UMCP at their Open House session; according to them, they have a higher matriculation of students into medical school. Their stats say that about 40% of UMBC pre-med students go onto to med school whereas 60% of UMCP’s pre-med students go into med school and 88% of UMCP’s “competitive” pre-med students go into med school. Also, it seems that the well-rounded students do best. UMBC has some clubs, but they obviously lack the bustling campus and club opportunities of UMCP. I heard that UMCP has 600+ clubs and organizations, which is kind of a mind-blowing transition from high school. Is it really hard to stand out in College Park, especially in the eyes of the professors (I’ve heard their freshman classes can be about 300-500 kids)? Also, is the transition from high school to College Park really that difficult? Would it be easier at UMBC?</p>

<p>Again, thanks for taking the time to contribute to this post; it’s given me stuff to think about, for sure. I really am trying to decide by Friday or Saturday at the latest.</p>

<p>Kikobird - it looks like you are giving this some thought which is a good thing . I would talk to college park and ask abt the support that you will receive as a Pre-med major and will you be able to graduate on four years. Also ask both schools about research opportunities that will be available to you . That is something that medical schools will want to see as well. Keep us posted on your thought process.</p>

<p>Hel Proudmom1313
can you send me a personal message at cpmd2013@**********, as i am a new member.we are in the similar boat but my son is not in the Myerhoff program so how is the predmed curiculum for non Myerhoff and what are the stats for Med schoo acceptance from a non Myerhoff pgm?</p>

<p>Thanks, hsmom, for the support. Btw, pre-med at both of these schools isn’t a major, it’s a general course pathway or program for students planning to enter medical school. As I’ve said before, I am planning on doing Biology as a major, but my problem with CP is that I have to take gateway courses before officially declaring since I didn’t get into the major right away. Does anyone know if this is a disadvantage?</p>

<p>It would appear that there are more research opportunities near UMCP because it’s somewhat near NIH, and the school is regarded as a research university. UMBC also has research opportunities, but they don’t seem as abundant. However, the competition at CP to both get those research opportunities and to get into medical school/ get good grades is obviously tougher…</p>

<p>cpmd2013, I am also not in the Meyerhoff Program or the Honors Program at UMBC and would like to know the answer to your question as well. If anyone could supply an accurate answer or depiction of our current situation, it would be greatly appreciated.</p>

<p>Sorry for bumping, but I really would like some final opinions on which school is better based on my situation.</p>

<p>I would really like to know if it’s worth going to UMBC at all if I didn’t get into the Meyerhoff or Honors Program but got into the Biology major (is that even selective at UMBC?). At UMD, I have the Life Sciences Scholars Program, but I didn’t get into the Biology major yet; I have to take gateway courses. In terms of which school would contain more “peers”, my entry stats are way above UMBC’s averages but are just about on target if not a little higher than UMCP’s. Which is a better academic situation for a prospective pre-med?</p>

<p>In terms of research and work opportunities, I currently have a volunteer research offer from a lab near UMBC. I don’t have any research opportunities from UMCP’s area, though, but I do have a prospective hospital job and a work-study offer. It doesn’t matter about the hospital job, though, because I could do that during school breaks regardless of which school I choose to attend. Does anyone know if it’s easier to get a paid internship from UMBC or UMCP’s area (i.e. NIH)?</p>

<p>I live closer to UMCP; UMBC is more than an hour away, so UMCP is more convenient.</p>

<p>I love CP’s campus. UMBC is far more drab in comparison. On the other hand, it’s easier to find your way around UMBC, I guess.</p>

<p>I’m scared of UMCP’s entry class size, though, but I do have the Scholars program, so some of my class sizes will probably be much smaller.</p>

<p>I’ve heard that UMBC’s science courses are a bit hard and are actually skewed to make you have to retake… is that true? Is the pre-med program more successful overall at UMBC or UMCP?</p>

<p>Finally, I have a scholarship from UMBC and only a work-study from UMCP, so UMBC is financially cheaper despite the longer commute.</p>

<p>UMCP is ranked higher overall to UMBC, so in that regards, I would lean towards UMCP. However, could someone answer my question about which school would appear to be a better fit for me based on my given information? Thank you!</p>

<p>Hello Kikobird, </p>

<p>I am currently a 3rd Year Biology major (B.S.) at UMBC. My advice for you is to check out UMBC’s Class of 2014, 2015, or 2016 Facebook pages and direct message to talk to various students on there (most of us are friendly) and then do the same for UMCP.</p>

<p>I don’t know of any Biology B.S. majors at CP currently, so I cannot speak much on that. But what I have heard from professors and other students (here at UMBC) is that for some science classes, the test questions at CP are easier in that they are all multiple choice and test for material memorization. This is in contrast to classes here, which test if you really understand the material, so the questions, while still mostly in multiple choice format, really want to know if you really understand the material, and can apply it to problem applications. For example, instead of a test asking what is one of the major functions of the nuclear envelope? and giving options A-D with a clear answer choice…UMBC professors tend to ask If a cell’s nuclear envelope were defective, which would be the most immediate harm? and then the choices A-D would all list possible harms but you have to pick the BEST answer (that the professor wants, which is not always what the book or internet says), and also the professor might throw in choices will be 2 of the above or none of the above. Basically, the science courses here are no joke, if you decide to come here, you have to be prepared to 1) go to class everyday 2) read everyday 3) sacrifice your weekends and figure out good time management and study skills. This is true for every college, but specifically for a tough program like UMBC’s biology program (if you decide to go B.S., not BA…BA is much easier and allows you to live a little, I would say)–you really won’t be having that much time for a social life. But I really do believe I am getting a superior education in Biology by choosing UMBC compared to other schools. I was in a similar dilemma as you in deciding between UMCP, UMBC and various other colleges…I was pre-med and ultimately chose UMBC for the “smaller class sizes” and “personalized attention.” <----To be honest, the smaller class sizes is not true except for 400 level Bio courses which you don’t take until senior or junior year., so most of my classes are still lecture-hall with ~200-300 students. But the personalized attention is very true–the professors in the Biology and Chemistry (and humanities departments as well) are really helpful and dedicated to teaching…they are always staying behind class for questions and in their office for office hours. We also have various tutoring centers, but most known is the Chemistry tutoring center, which I 100% recommend even if you think you don’t need it. Your first 2 years are heavy on chemistry (Chem I, II, Organic I, II) and you really need to make sure you do well in those courses especially if you are pre-med. There are tons of people that start at UMBC as a pre-med, usually Bio major, and after the 1st year or so the intro classes are too difficult and they end up being a psych major or something totally different. If you can stick it out though, I really do believe I am learning A LOT of information and actually really understanding it so that when I shadow various health professions, I have a fairly strong background that I can look at an MRI image and/or doctor notes on a patient and recall things that I have learned from my classes. I also find it really cool when I read about recent news in science and the medical world and can relate it to my coursework that I’ve studied. Reputation-wise, locally, UMBC is well known for its science rigor and many people I talk to know this…when I shadowed a health professional who was a UMBC alumni from the 90s, flat out told me that she knows how tough the science curriculum is there and that grades aren’t everything (for admissions to grad programs). For CP, since its the older and flagship, I think employers and professionals look to it as a good public school, but that its evenly good at both the sciences and humanities so people are less likely to have that image of it being tough on natural science majors (Engineering doesn’t count). I don’t want to sound like I am promoting or boasting UMBC, but I always joke and think what if I had gone to a school like Towson, I could easily be skating through with a 4.0 and have a nice social life. (I can’t say that for UMCP…but I will say this: someone from my h.s., not a bio major but psyc major at UMBC, was strugging in classes here her freshman yr getting B’s and A’s but now at CP and is getting all A’s). I suspect that CP classes have a huge curve, based on the fact that their lecture-hall classes are probably double the size of UMBC and there are always people who don’t show up to class or put in effort so they have such low exam scores that the professor will curve up in the end of the semester so that many people won’t fail. UMBC curves too; some classes are known for greater curving when exam averages are in the 60s, but the curve only helps students around the D-C border to get C…the curve rarely helps the B student get an A if they didn’t earn it with the test scores). </p>

<p>But it really does not matter what college you choose for undergrad even if you’re pre-med. Medical school admissions committees do not place that much emphasis on your undergrad institution…they look at your GPA (has to be >3.5…but 3.5 is still too low, I would say 3.8-3.9 and nothing less…but obviously if you go to a state school, they are expecting your GPA to be higher than someone at an IVY), your research experience, volunteer and shadow hours, and extra-curricular leadership. You can be successful in all of these areas at any reputable school that has resources available to help you with this, but you have to be the one driving yourself to do this…no one is going to hold your hand and show you the way. </p>

<p>Also on ranking: yes UMCP is higher but it has been around much longer, has much more money from alumni (greater alumni size), and has more current students which factor into those rankings. UMBC is steadily moving up in rankings. </p>

<p>Oh and no, the UMBC bio major is not selective …its whatever you listed, is what they assign you…you can always change it at orientation. So unlike CP, I feel if you didn’t get placed into the Bio major there, then that indicates that your high school grades (compared to the rest of the 2017 incoming class) may indicate you may struggle in your intro classes. It’s different for everyone though, some people do better in college than they did in high school, and some people do better at a certain college after they transfer. I think though if you’ve ruled down to these 2 state schools, then it doesn’t matter which you pick because you can always transfer if you’re unhappy after the first semester. Hope I’ve helped!</p>

<p>sosoandso3, thank you so much for your in-depth summary guide to UMBC; it’s given me a lot to think about. So have you stuck with Pre-med? Have you taken the MCAT yet, and if so, how did you do?</p>

<p>Also, do you know if UMBC offers advanced painting or drawing courses? Could I cross-register with JHU or MICA, and is there a limitation on how many cross-registered courses I can take?</p>

<p>If the grade inflation of the school is that much higher at CP, I wonder if it might be better for a pre-med student to go to CP. However, my major concern is about how difficult the math courses are (i.e. Calculus I); I only want to take the minimum for that. How was your experience for freshman math? How big were the class sizes, and what was it like (hard or easy)? </p>

<p>I was initially leaning towards CP because of the beautiful campus, prestige, and Scholars Program, but my parents have been again reiterating the perks of UMBC. I think that, if the Scholars Program really isn’t that big of a deal, then I may go with UMBC after all…</p>

<p>Edit: Actually, if UMBC is really that hard in terms of question-giving and grading, then I’m not sure… again… :S Is it true that UMBC has a higher tendency to give out Free response or essay questions and harder Multiple choice? I’ve actually heard that it was the opposite. Could someone please verify this? Thanks again!</p>

<p>Kikobird - See [Special</a> Enrollment - Registrar’s Office - UMBC](<a href=“http://registrar.umbc.edu/services/special-enrollment/]Special”>http://registrar.umbc.edu/services/special-enrollment/) to answer questions about cross registration. </p>

<p>If math poses a difficulty for you then you can always go to the math lab for tutoring while taking Calculus. Don’t think short term on this: think long term. Preparation for medical school is not meant to be a cakewalk anywhere. Sit down and make a pro / con list of each school by yourself, think of your long range goals, and then discuss with your parents by this weekend.</p>

<p>Yes, you’re right, hsmom, about pre-med not being a cakewalk. However, if the grading and tests are really that much more difficult at UMBC, then it may be more beneficial in the long-run to go to UMD, which is ranked higher. It’s a little sad to not pursue that research opportunity and the scholarship, though.</p>

<p>I’ve talked to my parents and shown them the forum posts that I’ve gleaned from and browsed in the past month or so. Like me, they were also surprised that UMBC was professed to be harder in the STEM program… they seem convinced, though. I wish I had a couple more witnesses to that. </p>

<p>I think at this point I’m pretty much ready to accept UMCP, though; it’s been recommended to me way more than UMBC. Still, I’m holding off for any last comments as well as because giving up a 4-year academic merit scholarship and a research opportunity will be slightly regretful… Could someone please verify the difficulty of UMBC’s pre med and bio major vs UMCP’s?</p>