<p>Mombee, I must totally disagree with your post based on our personal experience. I am not sure whether to giggle at, or be taken back by your statement, “Remember, high school ROTC is designed more to ‘capture’ those at-risk students and give them focus rather than to prepare the highly talented for college.” I am curious: Where has your perception come from?</p>
<p>Our WP cadet was involved in AFJROTC all 4 years of his high school career. He served as Cadet Commander (CC) his Sr. year and during those 4 years earned numerous ribbons and several national awards (indicating his commitment and activity level in the program). He was also chosen to attend AFJROTC Honors Camp — in the top 1% nationwide — where he met 3 other future WP classmates, one of whom is now his USMA roommate. His participation in no way precluded him from any other after-school activities — he was also Sr. Class President, Science Club President, a member of Marching Band, Jazz Band, and Concert Band, Track Team, Civil Air Patrol-CC, Boys Stater, church youth group, etc., etc. Besides all these ECs, he managed a pretty rigorous curriculum of AP and Honors courses on a 4x4 semester block schedule. He was hardly an at-risk student, nor were his peers. The CC the year before him now is a Jr. at Vanderbilt and the CC prior to that is a Firstie at WP, and another several years prior is in Med School. This program seems to have done a pretty great job of “preparing the highly talented for college”! </p>
<p>I am also unsure what “other, more beneficial, extracurricular activities” you had in mind when you posted this answer. From my point of view, the benefits of this program over other ECs are numerous: an understanding of military history, military bearing/drill and ceremony are second nature during parades and formations, an understanding of respect for peer leadership and chain of command, physical training and endurance, creative problem solving, and the opportunity to earn college credits (Management) from a state university.</p>
<p>That said, as with any activity, there can be dangers of becoming one-dimensional, and JROTC cadets desiring to attend service academies (or any college, for that matter) are encouraged to be well-rounded. To the OP, if your son does participate in the AF JROTC unit in your school, encourage involvement in a variety of leadership experiences and he will be fine. :)</p>
<p>Mombee, slim or not, as I stated in a previous post, the extra slots for ROTC sometimes do come from JROTC units. It gives a few extra nominations to the academy to allow more candidates from a particular area to have an opportunity for admission. We know from experience these extra slots do make a difference.</p>