OK, I’m late to the conversation but here’s my take. My son was a spring admit this year (just finished freshman year). He was ecstatic to go to USC, it was his first choice and had been for several years. Here are the pros: (1) once you start in the spring, it takes about, oh, 1 hour, to become “just” a Trojan. Nobody knows you’re a spring admit, unless you want to tell them.
(2) He took fall classes at Santa Monica college, met quite a few other spring admits, all of whom became very good friends, shared a social life during the fall, and helped each other to acclimate to the college atmosphere.
(3) He’ll graduate at the same time as fall admits, thus saving a semester of tuition (go ahead, figure that one out – at a yearly cost of almost $65,000, that’s a savings of $32.500 (yeah, I’m good at math), so either he saves it or I do, in either case, money in our bank, not USC’s.
(4) He went to all the football games, any spring admit can go, you get a pass for the entire home games.
(5) He had a chance to relax after the hectic and stifling atmosphere of senior high school, even though taking 3 classes at SM College (and by the way, that knocked out 3 of his GE’s, so he could focus on the courses he really wanted to study at USC).
(6) He met plenty of spring admits from earlier years and to a person, all of them were very happy at being spring admits. Not a one said anything negative about the experience.
(7) Yes, maybe some kids have trouble adjusting to being at college (yeah, go ahead tell me the freedom from the hovering, helicoptering Mom and Dad provides a major boost to getting on the campus and suddenly being “free”), so show me how many kids really have that much trouble adjusting to the school of their dreams.
(8) Waitlisting is a waste, if you don’t already know, your chances of getting accepted are slim and none with none holding the Ace card.
(9) Look around, more and more colleges are taking the spring admit approach, from Ivy League schools to small liberal arts colleges. When you start lowering your acceptance rates below 20% and as an applicant, you really really really want to go to that school, spring admit status is like being nominated for the Oscar – even if you don’t win (ie be a fall admit), you’re in rarified company just to be nominated (spring admit).
Sorry to go on. My son is ecstatic over the moon and would galdly do spring admit again and again as long as he got here.