@respacings ,
I was sort of suggesting that economics as a major is fairly commonplace, and while I do not deny that the so-called “elite” colleges can act as pipelines to great jobs, I also like to remind students that even if they attend a school that is lower on the prestige ladder (note: but not lower in terms of academics), they can still do quite well, whether the goal is graduate school (an MBA) or direct entry into the job market.
As for colleges that are not as tough to get into as Williams/Amherst/Wesleyan/Bowdoin and so on, Colgate and Hamilton have success in sending its students into successful careers in business. Of course, neither school is an easy admit!
You might do research into LACs that offer business majors. For instance (and I use this school simply as an example, not as a direct recommendation that you apply here, though it could work as a safety school?), Lake Forest College, an LAC in one of Chicago’s very wealthy north shore suburbs, offers both business and accounting. Its proximity to Chicago (and the fact that there’s also the Lake Forest Graduate School of Management) means that Lake Forest has strong programs in business and economics, and graduates fare well landing interviews and jobs in the Chicago area, even though Lake Forest is rarely mentioned on this site and is listed somewhere around #100 on that questionable US News thingie. Again, I just use this as an example of an LAC that offers business.
Here is a mixture of selective and mid-level LACs that offer business, and this combo (LACs with business) might be a nice fit for you (economics will still be offered as a major too!). Lehigh isn’t really a classic LAC, though it definitely has a beautiful campus (and wealthy students to boot!), and it has majors in finance, accounting, and marketing. Of course, Lehigh is not an easy admit. Rhodes College (51% admit rate) offers business. Brandeis (34%) is also not a true LAC, but it is a smaller school that has business. How about Franklin & Marshall? Good, rigorous school. Also not an easy admit (35% acceptance rate approximately). Bucknell (30%). Muhlenberg College (very nice school with about a 50% admit rate). Gettysburg (also very nice school with around a 50% admit). Skidmore (25%). Dickinson College (50%) has International Business. Rollins College in the Orlando area (65%). Oh, don’t forget about Babson (22%) and Bentley (44%). These are not LACs, but they are small, completely business-oriented schools.
I am trying to keep this short (and failing), but one good use of the US News thingie is that you can go through the “top” 50 or 75 or 100 national liberal arts colleges and see which ones offer business majors. And as another poster mentioned, maybe consider slightly larger non-LACs like Elon, Miami of OH, Fordham, Case Western, Butler (an IN school with strong business connections in the midwest), and so on. Finally, if you can get into a strong business program at a large public university, such as Indiana U’s Kelley School of Business (no easy feat), that’s a sweet get.