Help me choose!

<p>Hi everyone,
I've already posted this in other spots, I'm just trying to get as much input as possible. I got all my acceptance letters to the schools i applied to but im having trouble choosing which to go to.
I've narrowed it down to these three:</p>

<p>Umass Amherst (honors college) - $10,700 after aid
Boston University - $16,100 after aid
Boston College - $20,800 after aid</p>

<p>Umass is the weakest academically, but it's the cheapest. BC is the best academically, but the most expensive. BU is in the middle for both categories. No matter where i go I'm going to be paying it all in loans because my family can't afford it. I'm willing to pay the extra money for BC, but I'm not sure if its worth it. Any input will be much appreciated</p>

<p>Thanks</p>

<p>sal- what do you plan on studying? Over 4 years it will cost you a little less than
$22K more to go to BU and about $40K more to go to BC ( which is still a pretty good deal, considering BC is notoriously stingy with financial aid!) UMass has a couple of strong programs, but unless it was one of those, personally, I would consider one of the other two.
Good Luck!</p>

<p>Chacha raises a good point. Depending on the major at UMass, it could be better than BU or BC. When you apply to grad school, faculty members make those admission decisions and they know the reputation of academic departments and that is an important factor. Some examples: Sport management is ranked #1 in the country. Exercise science just got ranked #6 in the country. Linguistics is ranked #1 or #2 in the country. The Isenberg School of Management was just ranked #1 public university for student satisfaction by the Princeton Review. The computer science program is on every top ten list. Chemistry (especially polymer science and nanotechnology) is one of the best in the country. The combination of Commonwealth College and one of these majors is a very powerful combination and may in fact be stronger academically than BU or BC.</p>

<p>My son is in the same boat.
Money is a factor - but not the final factor.
He needs to decide between Lehigh, and UMass.
UMass has opportunities he didn't find at Lehigh, but it also has drawbacks which were not a part of Lehigh.</p>

<p>We don't know is how to evaluate the strength of the program(s) against one another, especially looking down the line, at later Grad school acceptances.</p>

<p>He has been accepted into Comm. Coll, and School of Engineering at Umass - Mechanical Engr. specifically - and accepted into Lehigh School of Engr. also.</p>

<p>Would he be "penny wise - pound foolish" to choose UMA over Lehigh?</p>

<p>His interests are (in engineering): robotics. He excels at physics and loves it. He's also interested in Carbon nanotubes, and nanotechnology.</p>

<p>Additionally, he's a musician, and has produced two award-winning documentaries for National History Day competition.</p>

<p>Help!</p>

<p>Hi everyone!</p>

<p>After reading this thread I felt it was time to finally register and share my own experiences.</p>

<p>I, too, was accepted into multiple universities with higher levels of "prestige" than UMass. In my case, those universities included Northwestern, WashU, Bucknell, BU, Northeastern, RPI, and of course, UMass Amherst (Commonwealth College). I was also waitlisted at Harvey Mudd, Harvard, and Cornell. When I applied to all these schools, I really didn't know what I wanted to do, and (as you can see) applied to a wide variety of colleges. I figured that I'd get a "better" education at a "better" school because...well, that's how it works, right? A couple weekends ago I attended UMass' College of Engineering's Open House and had the chance to explore the classrooms, labs, and buildings associated with the College of Engineering. I also had the chance to talk with many different engineering students, all of whom seemed as if there was nothing they'd rather be doing than talking to me about their beloved university. What really struck me was that these students seemed "real." They didn't hide anything when they were talking, and told both sides of being a student there.</p>

<p>As for the strength of the programs, admisscouns already has highlighted some of the better ones on campus, but I really feel that college is what you put into it. UMass has PLENTY of opportunities to give you a high class education--you just have to take the initiative. Especially with Comm. Coll, MomMary, your son will have all he needs to get a great education. Concerning you son's interests, I don't know much about UMass' robotics program, but I can tell you that they're heavily involved in nanotechnology.</p>

<p>When I went to the open house, I attended the Chemical Engineering portion, and was surprised to see the statistics for placement into grad school and jobs. Of the 35(+/- 3) members of this year's ChemE senior class, 3 were accepted to MIT, and many others were accepted to other fine schools. Also, of those who decided to go into the job market, many were receiving high-paying jobs from the get-go (some $70K+). I did happen to speak with a MechE major, who will have a job with a local company as soon as she graduates. She received multiple offers but ended up choosing the one that offered to pay for grad. school. She told me that because the job market is so strong for engineering-related positions, everyone has a job who wanted a job and who worked to make themselves attractive to employers.</p>

<p>For me, money was a factor as well (also not the deciding factor). To me, it just didn't make sense to pay $130K more to go to some "elite" private school where I'll get a similar education. Sure, the name will look better to future employers, but as soon as you land a job out of college, those employers won't be looking too closely at where you went for undergrad.</p>

<p>MomMary, I can also tell you that one of my friends, who is considering majoring in engineering, was also deciding between Lehigh and a state school (Penn State). He ended up choosing Penn State because of the resources and opportunities that a large state school offers. However, everyone is different and a large university like UMass is not for everyone.</p>

<p>I'd like to add that once-upon a time (before I got rejected) I thought I'd end up at a small, rural school (Dartmouth). However, I'm going to be joining the ranks at my state school, and I'm proud of my decision. UMass is big, but as you become more and more specialized within your college, the school becomes smaller and smaller.</p>

<p>After the open house (on a Saturday) I cancelled my trip out west, which would've included visiting Northwestern and WashU. I got my vacation week back and didn't have to draw-out my decision any longer.</p>

<p>I'll be at UMass this fall.</p>

<p>Wow UMeng2011 - what a thoughtful response. Thank you so very, very much!</p>

<p>I would agree with everything meng said. I will actually be attending UIllinois in the fall but UMass is in state for me and it was a very tough decision for me to give up UMass, but ultimately I wanted to go west for a few years. </p>

<p>My sister graduated from MIT last spring and my brother is at Dartmouth so a lot of people (we live in a small town) were pretty surprised when I said I was applying to four state schools and that was it. (I ended up getting waitlisted at UVM so my final decision was between Penn State, UIllinois and UMass)
You'll notice that there are a LOT of top notch faculty at UMass like Nobel prize winners and it was clear to me that as long as I met my university halfway (by studying hard and making faculty connections), I knew I would get a fabulous education at either UIllinois or UMass.</p>

<p>I just went to an open house at UMass on Thursday (the 26th) and all of this was confirmed, leading me to decide 2 hours before the deadline where I would go because I liked them both so much.
Around Massachusetts you hear a lot about budget cuts at UMass but when I visited the students said they didn't feel affected, so even though the landscaping could use a few more dollars, it's clear the administration is prioritizing well. And not only that, but many of their top notch departments, like biology, get a good amount of grants separately, so they aren't suffering at all.</p>

<p>To be quite honest, I don't understand at all why one would go to BU over UMass - both are large and bureaucratic, but one is WAY cheaper and still regarded as a major research institution. (I don't mean to insult BU at all, my mother got her master's there - but I just don't think I could justify to myself what all that money was really going to buy me extra)</p>

<p>As for BC, it's a different experience and that's hard to value in dollars so I can understand considering that.</p>