How to Convince My Parents That Some Schools Are Actually Generous With Aid?

<p>Hi everyone.</p>

<p>My mom basically told me that Scripps or any other college (Middlebury, Macalester, Colby) won't give kids any financial aid unless they're a minority or highly intelligent (which she said that I'm not). She said that Scripps (my first choice) relies on the government for money. She said that I'm middle class, so I won't get anything. My parents' income was roughly $52,000 last year. Surely I'll get some help, right? She also said that I'm not good enough to get into Scripps either. </p>

<p>My mom wants me to go to a college where the tuition is $5000 per year. She said she'll only pay half. And if I'll get into Scripps, she'll only pay $2500 and I'll have to take out loans to cover the rest.</p>

<p>Please help me. Please tell me that I'm not living in a fantasy world. It's not like my dream school is NYU.</p>

<p>I'm very distraught, so please excuse any errors.</p>

<p>Well, Scripps is a pretty pricey school, about $59,000 a year. However, they do meet 100% need so if you are a needy applicant I’d assume you might get quite a bit of aid. If your income is accurate and your family doesn’t have any significant assets you should qualify for a lot of aid (the average FA package is $35,000–87% of that is pure scholarship money, too. Have your mother review Scripps Website about Financial Aid, she may be misinformed and make sure you apply to a variety of schools as well.</p>

<p>Thanks! I’ve tried everything. </p>

<p>I’m applying to Scripps, Middlebury, Pitzer, Macalester, Colby, Mount Holyoke and Occidental. Are those schools fairly generous with aid? I might also apply to Trinity College in CT. My safety schools are University of Arkansas, Missouri State, Mizzou and Truman State.</p>

<p>Do a search for “Net Price Calculator” at the websites for each of the schools you’re interested in. Then fill in your family financial information and run the calculator . . . see what result you get. Have your mom sit down and do it with you, so that she can see what kind of aid you might be eligible for. The results are not guaranteed, but they should be in the ballpark of what your award would be if you were admitted.</p>

<p>I don’t think UArk is a safety school. Isn’t it OOS? If so, how would you cover the costs? It doesn’t give great aid</p>

<p>For a school to be a safety, you HAVE to know that you have all costs covered.</p>

<p>Scripps does NOT rely on the gov’t for money. And its aid is given to ANYONE with need, not just minorities. And, yes, you have need.</p>

<p>have your mom do a net price calculator on each schools’ website. She’s very wrong.</p>

<p>Hi, Chelsea. I’m sorry to hear that your mom is not exactly being very supportive. Please don’t go by her estimate alone of your capabilities–look at some of the discussion areas for colleges you are interested in and compare your test scores and GPA with those of past admitted students. Also check out websites that list statistics of admitted students, such as the colleges’ own websites. And maybe talk to your school’s guidance counselor or some trusted teachers?</p>

<p>Many private colleges, Scripps and those others you mentioned, do give quite a lot of financial aid, and if your stats are high enough, you may get a lot of your education paid for. However, you’ll at least be expected to take some student loans at these places, so you may come out of college with possibly $26,000 in debt, that’s kind of the high average for these schools.</p>

<p>There are many good schools, the University of Alabama and Indiana University at Bloomington come to mind, that will guarantee you a merit scholarship if you have a high enough GPA and SAT scores. So you might want to look into those possibilities.</p>

<p>You’re from Missouri, right? Does the University of Missouri offer merit scholarships for high-achieving in-state students?</p>

<p>Anyhow, don’t give up! Even if you have to go to community college for a couple of years, you could transfer to your state university and get a great education…</p>

<p>Mom2collegekids: I live close enough to the border that UArk will consider me in-state. I’m two counties from the state line.</p>

<p>I did do College Board’s Net Price Calculator. It said that our net price for Scripps would be about $11,000 per year. She didn’t believe it. I know that I’m not going to be able to go for free, but I don’t think I’ll have to pay the full price either.</p>

<p>Parent46: Yes, I’m from Missouri. My guidance counselor isn’t used to dealing with kids like me who want to go away to school because kids from my school end up attending either Mizzou or community college. </p>

<p>Mizzou does have scholarships for high-achieving students; however, my back-up plan is to go to Missouri State. I don’t think I would like how big Mizzou is. Mizzou doesn’t offer my intended major either. :frowning: Thanks for the advice.</p>

<p>My mom wants me to go to the University of Michigan because we have family there, but she doesn’t know how we would afford it.</p>

<p>I plan on getting a job during college as well. I don’t mind taking out a 5 or 6 thousand dollar loan. I hope that it doesn’t get too overwhelming.</p>

<p>As long as your mom is letting you apply to the more expensive schools, what’s the problem? Apply and see what the financial aid packages look like come spring.</p>

<p>Keep in mind that schools like Scripps have additional financial aid forms (such as the Profile) that your parents will need to fill out. Scripps does meet need, but they decide what your need is, and it isn’t always based on your FAFSA EFC. </p>

<p>Just keep an open mind, apply to the schools your mom wants you to apply to as well as the schools you want to apply to, and see what the financial aid offers are next March. Good Luck!</p>

<p>It sounds to me like there be more to the story than just your mom’s feeling that you won’t be able to afford a more expensive school. I am hearing (well, reading) that your mom probably pretty much expected that you would go to Mizzou, just as you said that most people in your area do, and had never given much thought to the idea that you might actually go away to school.<br>
I know I always thought that going away to school was for ‘those other people’, Like the people who jet off to Europe for lunch, or sort of thing. lol<br>
I think it’s a good idea to keep the conversation going with mom, and give her time to come to terms with the idea that you might go away to college, and then, maybe by the time the financial aid details come in, she may be more open to it.</p>

<p>Annasdad: You have a point. I guess she doesn’t care because I’ll be paying the application fees.</p>

<p>Shoboemom: My mom really wants me to go to the college in my hometown where the tuition is 5,000 bucks. She works there, so I can get a 60 percent discount. My main thing is: it doesn’t offer my major.</p>

<p>Thanks for your help!</p>

<p>I feel better!</p>

<p>Scripps is a great school, and attending one of the Claremont colleges allows you the benefit of accessing the other schools and resources there. Great choice. Are you a good candidate for Scripps? Are your scores/stats competitive? </p>

<p>Does your mom’s school offer tuition exchange arrangements with other schools? Can you attend other schools for the significant discount your mom’s school would offer? Its a shame to have to attend a school that does not offer what you plan to study.</p>

<p>You don’t know about a school’s generosity to you until you receive the FA offer. </p>

<p>The NPC numbers are only an estimate and that calculator assumes you entered all the detail correctly and completely. Did the NPC projections for Scripps include Stafford loans (aka subsidized/unsub?) Was that one of the line items they “subtracted,” to get to the 11k figure? If so, you’d end up with that debt. (If they did not include Staffords, then, of course, you could use them to reduce the 11k family cost guesstimate. It’s still debt.) </p>

<p>But, there’s another line item families often miss: “estimated contribution from student’s summer earnings.” It means that, on top of the “family contribution,” the Staffords and the work study, my kids were expected to kick in roughly 1800 for first year. </p>

<p>These are details you need to be aware of. Sometimes, it’s better to just look at the free money (grants,) subtract that from the total cost of attendance, and see what the real remainder is, the real financial nut. </p>

<p>If Mom says all she’ll pay is $2500/year, even IF Scripps, eg, only tagged you for only 11k (plus your student loans,) you still fall 8500 short. Most 18 year olds cannot get that level of personal loan. If your school choices offer merit, check the eligibility requirements and the amounts. Sometimes, they make the difference, sometimes they are small amounts. Just think about all the ins and outs here.</p>

<p>

</p>

<p>You can’t. Having family there does not make you a resident for purposes of tuition, and the out-of-state tuition is WAY beyond your means!</p>

<p>

</p>

<p>You can get a waiver of the application fees if you can’t afford them. Just ask your school guidance counselor for a letter stating that you can’t afford the fees. As far as I know, most colleges will accept that. If you’re not sure, ask the college.</p>

<p>At $52k/year, though, your family isn’t poor . . . and I’m not surprised that your expected payment at Scripps is $11k. What I’d do, if you can, is negotiate with your mom. She said she’s willing to pay half of $5,000 . . . see if you can get her to agree to pay half up to some larger amount that you agree on. Since she doesn’t believe it’s going to happen anyway, there’s no reason for her not to agree.</p>

<p>It sounds like a large part of the problem is that she’s just not ready for you to be on your own . . . hence she’s looking at the local school or U.M., where you have family close by. You need to explain to her what your plan is, why you want to pursue the major that you do, and why it’s important for you to attend a school that has that major.</p>

<p>Her plan for you (to go to the local school where you’d get a discount) makes sense to her . . . and, after all, she’s the one who’s been making plans for you for the past 17 years! It’s not going to be easy to convince her that you’re ready to take over that job yourself now. But that’s what you’re going to have to do. With your family income, a contribution of $2,500 is not going to cut it - even at schools that meet 100% of need. And then you have transportation costs, etc. to deal with (including stupid things like the cost of the shuttle to get you back and forth to the airport!) - so you really need to have her on your side.</p>

<p>You’ve got all summer . . . and you know her better than we do. What’s it going to take to win her over?</p>

<p>Truman State is a top-notch school, and for Missouri residents the cost of attendance (tuition, room, board) is about $15,000. You can qualify for up to $3,000 in automatic merit scholarships if your stats are high enough, and there are a number of other competitive scholarships available.</p>

<p>OP, are the some adults whom your Mom trusts who could advocate for you … her sibling, her best friend, your teacher she likes best, your priest, etc … someone she trusts and who also understands the college environment better … she may “hear more” if it is coming from someone else.</p>

<p>As others have mentioned I would also suggest having discussions with your Mom to understand her thoughts better to move from … her solution (Mizzou) … to the attributes she would like is a solution (costs less than $x dollars, y hours from home, near a relative, etc). Listen to her list … don’t argue with it … then research solutions to the issues … then provide additional info to try to move your Mom. For example, if she says it shouldn’t cost more than $5k/yr ask for clarification … does that mean she contribute up to $5k/yr. (Between student loans, the summer, and working 10 hrs/wk during school you should be able to add $10/yr on top of what your Mom will pay).</p>

<p>Also reinforcing a point of another poster … right now all you need to do is apply and you do not need her permission to do that. Personally, I’m a fan of pushing off the confrontation until it needs to happen … in this case, when you need to decide where to go … that is next May. That gives you a year to explore affordable options (given your Mom’s limitations you may want to pursue merit aid) and also to work on expanding your Mom’s world view. If some of this year’s seniors are headed away for school find a subtle way for her to see, next year have friends considering going away to school over for dinner and take about <em>their</em> plans over dinner, bring in the trusted adults., etc.</p>

<p>Good luck!</p>

<p>

</p>

<p>OP won’t be getting FA offers from the private schools on her list if her parents don’t fill out the CSS Profile. Getting the Profile done by the earliest of the school deadlines takes, in practice, a lot of buy-in and effort on the part of parents. They will have to get their income taxes filed, or at least calculated, quite early, for example. If this doesn’t happen, it will take a lot of options off the table next May.</p>

<p>A lot of the previous poster’s other advice is very good. I just wanted to make this point about the CSS Profile because it is so critical.</p>

<p>Good point, weatherga. The FAFSA will be necesary for all, and the CSS for most of the private schools.</p>