How to decide: Prestige vs. Fit

<p>ohhhhh goodness, tell your son i am so unbelievably familiar with the story it hurts me!!</p>

<p>prestige v fit was my biggest struggle last year, and i chose fit. one day someone asked me "if both schools were seriously called UVa, which one would you go to?" and i picked what was, at the time, not only a fit but also my safety (whereas UVa was my dream, reach, number 1, you name it).</p>

<p>i wonder what makes the harder one so much better? pride is a huge thing for sure, but really...college is what he makes of it. you can tell him that, but it's almost better to save your breath because he won't listen :)</p>

<p>here's another way i "justified" choosing the fit over the reach: while i could academically succeed at UVa, i could academically excel at my school now. and let me be the first to say that academically excelling first semester takes a lot of weight off my shoulders and allows me to focus on other non-academic aspects of college. you know like, leaving home for the first time, completely rebuilding my core of friends, loving my sorority...etc.</p>

<p>so, perhaps, if he did a lot of academics in high school, he would really benefit from going to a school that doesn't stress academics as much. it's really a refreshing eye opener for me to realize that the world really doesn't revolve around grades and courses and that it's okay to have fun at school or go to a football game or go to a kegger on a monday night just for the hell of it.</p>

<p>remind him that college is a package and a whole experience and then see if he still wants the top one. if he's picking it just for the name, encourage him to look somewhere else. if he really likes it and it just happens to have the better name, maybe he really could belong there!!!</p>

<p>all the best,
kristin</p>

<p>UVA is the only school that's an exception to fit/prestige. Pick UVA over anything. Cant believe you passed on UVA :D</p>

<p>It's always great to achieve both, fit and prestige. Maybe that's what's taking place. If so, fantastic. You have to remember that college is not a continuation of Sr. High. Students respond differently to different environments. My work in college had little resemblence to what I did in H.S. - I did much better in college. Your S may respond the same way. You never know for sure. That's why, to the extent possible, the student needs lattitude in choosing.</p>

<p>Thanks for sharing both sides of this with me, and sharing your personal stories as well. I have been sharing this with him as suggestions come up, and I think he is really thinking about what both schools would have to offer. </p>

<p>I appreciate all of your help,
Maren</p>

<p>Maren, I have only skimmed the thread so this may have already been covered. </p>

<p>If S has the skills Coach wants/needs for his program, Coach will still want him, even if he applies RD and Coach will still go to bat for him with Admissions if he can. If S can help the program, he will play whether he gets into the school via RD or ED. Remember, it's in the COACH'S best interest for him to apply ED. (One less thing for Coach to worry about 'cause your DS would be 'in the bag'.) S has to follow his heart, unless he is 100% sure he would love the school, don't go ED....My S seriously considered a higher-ranked school where he wouldn't have been able to play, but ultimately the fact that he could contribute to his sport AND get an excellent education was a big factor in his college choice. We thought that was perfectly understandable because sports has always played a big role in his life and he was really comfortable at the school where he ended up. </p>

<p>Not to get this controversial topic going again, but the intangible advantages of playing college sports really can't be measured! Even though it's very difficult, we parents need to back off and let the kids decide!
Good Luck!</p>

<p>I'd vote go with fit ... and the only vote that matters about the fit is your son's vote.</p>

<p>I don't think he has thought about not playing sports anymore. It has been part of his life since he was 4, and played town soccer and little league baseball at five.</p>