Match a junior with less than perfect GPA [3.83UW, 1530 SAT, physics]

I don’t think you have many/any match schools other than perhaps some UCs. Purdue, UIUC, Michigan all reach/high reach. I would focus more on matches as your reach list is substantial if your child is not in the top of their class. My kid got into Purdue Honors and was waitlisted at UIUC for mechanical engineering. Top 10 student in the class at rigorous private school. Of the remaining top 10 students, 3 headed to Ivies and 3 to Georgia Tech (where my kid is headed).

Though the school does not rank, admissions officers will absolutely know where your child falls in the class due to the school profile that is required to be submitted along with the transcript. It will have a breakdown usually by quartile or decile as to what GPAs fall within these various percentages.

1 Like

I would think applying for physics major at Purdue should be a target. Engineering and computer science would be a reach even a high reach for computer science.

If big schools with strong Physics departments are being considered then Ohio Sate with predictable admissions decisions in their EA round and merit opportunities should be considered.

1 Like

I am not sure how much it matters if a college is classified as a target or a reach. The most important category is going to be the safety schools. RPI seems like an outlier given the rest of your son’s list. If he would be happy attending either of the safeties, it’s perfectly fine to apply to a bunch of high match or reach schools.

Since your son is at a private school, his college counselor should be able to give you an idea of your son’s chances better than anyone on CC can. Our private school didn’t rank either, but as @VirginiaBelle stated above, colleges will be able to figure out from his school profile where your kid stands in his class. That being said, class rank is not everything (especially if your school is sending a high percentage of the class to elite universities). Rigor matters too. My son is a physics major in college and took all of the notoriously tough APs in high school - Calc BC, World History, Chemistry, Physics C etc. as well as multivariable and linear algebra. He had classmates who took “easier” APs and had GPAs that were as high or higher than his. Even though his rank may have been lower, he was accepted at colleges where those other kids were rejected.

Do you or your son have a geographic preference? You seem to have west coast, Midwest and Northeast. Am I correct in assuming anything in the South isn’t under consideration? My son just finished his first year at the College of William and Mary in Virginia. It would probably be a match school for your son. Although it is called a “college”, it is a research university with about 6000 undergrads and has a great physics program. The physics department is large for a school it’s size (30 fulltime teaching faculty plus another 15 in purely research positions). They have partnerships with both NASA Langley and the Jefferson Lab. It functions more like an LAC with small class sizes and an emphasis on undergraduate teaching and research. All of the classes and labs are taught by professors rather than TAs. My son is really enjoying the personal relationships with his professors and the ability to be involved in research as a freshman.

4 Likes

Also, the counselor and teacher recommendation forms (at least in The Common Application) include questions where the recommender checks a rank range box.

3 Likes

Yes, and the counselor will also indicate whether the student has taken the most rigorous schedule.

1 Like

Thank you for your thoughtful response! We will look into College of William and Mary.

One point to clarify: what do you mean by RPI is an outlier?

RPI is a tech focused school with a significant gender imbalance. I think it is still close to 70 percent men. The other schools on your list are all universities where there will be a significant portion of the students who are not STEM majors and a much higher percentage of female students. RPI is just a very different environment than any of the other schools you are considering. My dad and brother are both proud RPI alums. It is an excellent school academically, but has the reputation of being a pressure cooker. (Not that physics or engineering are a walk in the park anywhere. :grin:)

1 Like

This topic was automatically closed 90 days after the last reply. If you’d like to reply, please flag the thread for moderator attention.