Please grade my SAT essay

Hey. I just wrote another essay, and since I don’t know anybody who can grade it, I’ll post it here.

Assignment: Is it better for people to act on their feelings than to talk about them?

It is more beneficial for people to act on their feelings than talk about them. Talking about one’s feelings can bring a greater understanding of oneself, but this action rarely brings real change.

One example that proves my point is that of Malala Yousafzai, a girl from Pakistan who decided to speak up against gender discrimination in Pakistan. Malala did talk about her feelings on her blog to bring awareness about the obstacles girls face in Pakistan. However, she also user her determination and indignance in manifold actions, like giving speeches or continuing to go to school in spite of the fact that the Taliban issued a death threat against her. One day, when she was on her way to school, Malala was shot in the head, survived and later gained international support as a result. Clearly, Yousafzai’s actions are the reason for her success, and it is thanks to her feelings that she remained resolute in her fight for girl’s rights. It Malala wouldn’t have acted on her feelings, opting to instead only talk about them, she could not possibly achieved lasting results.

Another example is that of Anne Frank, a girl who lived during World War ll. As a teenager, Anne already knew what she wanted to do in life - to write. During that time, it was unusual for a girl to have her own profession, but this fact didn’t discourage Anne to follow her dream. Certain that she didn’t want to be a typical woman like her mother, Anne worked very hard to improve her writing skills. Of course, her most famous work, ‘‘The Diary of a Young girl’’, is about her feelings, but it is her decision to act that made her write it in the first place.

The previous examples clearly prove that only when one acts on one’s feelings, can one bring real change.

I may or may not have rated your last SAT essay :slight_smile:

-Intro: this can be brought out more. You need a thesis that can relate to the prompt and your examples

-Body Paragraph #1: Don’t use first person pronouns. They detract from your essay. On the sentence about Malala’s attack, don’t use “later” and “as a result” in the same sentence. I would end your paragraph with, “If Malala did not act instictively, she could not have created the profound impact that she has on the world today”. This is your strongest example.

-Body Paragraph #2: The fourth sentence is worded in a strange way so I would write it as “Anne did not want to become like her mother so she worked on her writing skills”. The last sentence has a different tense from the rest of the essay.

-Conclusion: Try to make it at least three sentences with one relating back to the question and the other to your examples. It has an abrupt ending and it sounds strange.

Thoughts: You have great examples, but you need some more development in all of the paragraphs. Remember to keep the tenses either in the past or the present. Then again, you have 25 minutes to write the essay. Not bad at all: 7/12

Yup @JMS357 , you did grade one of my past essays. Your responses are rather helpful, so thanks! Let me know if I can return the favor.