Please grade this essay for me!

Hi all!

I have been torturing myself with the writing section recently, and I was wondering if you could help.
If you can, please grade this essay below with the prompt provided. Thanks!!

Sat Prompt:

Can the daily actions of everyday people have a significant impact on the course of history? Plan and write an essay……

Response:

There are many factors that can influence the course of history. While there are a myriad of examples of rich men and women influencing history, the daily actions of average people can also affect it. This is true when the basic actions that occur daily to meet the needs for means of subsistence are hindered as seen in the failure of the French monarchy to provide bread for its people and the British crown taxing food products to raise money to repay the scourges of the French and Indian War. Both resulted in the dissatisfaction of the common citizens, and they resulted in revolution.

Towards the end of the 18th century, France found itself in debt. Wars have bankrupted the state, leaving masses hungry. The first and second estate [composed of the nobility and clergy] were able to live comfortably while peasants that composed the third estate were dying of hunger. The French Monarchy was so shamefully ignorant of this that when approached, Marie Antoinette, the French Queen, said, “Let them [the peasants] eat cake!” Thus, the daily action of eating whatever the peasants and common citizenry could procure for food turned into a flame of hatred at the French Monarchy. As known, the common people rebelled against the French Monarchy and overthrew it, making France a republic, and changing the course of history.

Another daily act that allowed ordinary people to transform history was that of the American colonists paying taxes after the French and Indian War. The war was essentially a North-American front for the more extensive Seven Years War in a struggle for colonial power. The British won the war, but paid a heavy price. The country faced bankruptcy.  Because it was fought for the “defense of the American colonies,” the British Parliament decided that it was fitting that the colonies should pay. By order of the crown, taxes of various kinds were levied on the colonists. The colonists were forced to start paying taxes on luxury items and food daily. This unprecedented act of taxation without representation of the colonies in parliament fueled anger at the British, and the colonists rebelled, forming the “United States of America.” The simple daily act of paying taxes by the common citizens changed history forever.

The daily acts of eating poorly for survival and paying taxes in luxury goods sowed dissent among French citizens and American colonists. Believing that they deserved better, they rose up in revolution, and changed the course of history forever. The Republic of France and the United States stand as living testimony that daily actions by ordinary citizens can impact history significantly.

I think you could use a third example if you can think of it. Also, Marie Antoinette never said “Let them eat cake”, but otherwise I think your essay is pretty great. So I’d give it an 11 on a scale of 12, and a 5 on a scale of 6. Good luck!

What do I need to improve?

I could not do a third example… no space.

Hmm. I think that you would get a 10, so two 5s overall. It’s a good essay!!! :slight_smile: however I have a few notes and suggestions if you really want to improve that already stellar score!

  • I was taught to keep the introduction general, without examples, but I have heard differing opinions on this.
  • You have a nice vocabulary and thoughtful examples! :slight_smile:
  • Maybe try to expound your conclusion a little, it seems a bit abrupt to me. But that final sentence is great!
  • This is very minor, but I’ve read that the essay graders love contrasting examples. So perhaps you could use your current examples, but put a positive spin on one and a negative on the other. Although it might be easier to find a new, more easily negative one. But anyways that is minor and it’s just a helpful hint! :slight_smile:
  • ANOTHER hint, although it would be hard to do with this essay. Multiple SAT-takes have told me that their essay scores have improved drastically when they talk about themselves in the example/s! So if you get the chance on test day, maybe try that :slight_smile:

But anyways I think it’s very good for 25min! :slight_smile:
Keep up the good work! And sorry if you disagree with my suggestions, only trying to help!

JeanJacket, thanks for your suggestions!!

How would you suggest that I keep my introduction general? I tried to introduce my two examples here in order to continue on with essay bodies.

And why does the conclusion seem abrupt?

No problem! Although keep in mind I’m basing it off what I was taught! I’ve read some posts that say the intro should have the later examples mentioned.
Well when I write essays I always think of the intro as an upside down triangle; you mention something general and then specify and tie it in with your thesis at the end.
But general might be the wrong term, what I mean is to not specifically state your later examples in the intro.

So you could still start with “There are many factors which can influence the course of history.” Then say how a king can do so, or other people In power. Then contrast with, but what about everyday citizens, who have little to no power? OR “but not everyone needs to have power to influence the future.” Then thesis! “History has proven time and again that even the simplest of people can rally together and spur events that will be read about, taught, and argued over for years to come.”

Then introduce your first example in the next paragraph and at the end of the paragraph reference your thesis subtly by stating: “Even the weak, starving peasants of France were able to revolt in such an emphatic rage against the monarchy that Frnace’s political system, amd history, would be changed forever.”
(Some like to start their body paragraphs with “For example” or “For instance” - I don’t know if this is frowned upon or not but I have used it)

-The above sentences are just ROUGH ideas, to help you catch my drift.

And like I said, I was taught not to mention my later specific examples in my intro, as well as the upside down triangle view, so some may think differently! I am definitely not the end-all-be-all when it comes to writing, but these suggestions have helped me become a better writer! :slight_smile:

Well it’s still a good conclusion, but I would throw in a sentence to emphasize (I know you stated it) how the people of France and the U.S. were simple, everyday citizens with very little power, and how they did still influence history and the future in major, irreversible ways.

But really, it was a very good, thoughtful essay! Your examples show you really know your history and it’s impressive you can articulate that in a 25 minute time period! :slight_smile:
Good luck!

@JeanJacket123 I wrote two more essays in hopes of improving upon what you recently mentioned.

The links to them are:
http://talk.collegeconfidential.com/sat-preparation/1793589-how-did-i-do-on-this-sat-essay.html?new=1

and

http://talk.collegeconfidential.com/sat-act-tests-test-preparation/1791420-how-did-i-do-on-this-essay.html#latest

I am interested in having your opinion on them. If you could give them a look, it would be greatly appreciated!

Thanks for giving me constructive feedback on this essay, again.