<p>
[quote]
Also atrmom brings up a really good point about not showing up your shipmates. Let those coming from the fleet or Naps lead the way.
[/quote]
</p>
<p>I disagree with this, and I doubt things have changed so much as to make me reconsider.</p>
<p>To begin, while prior-enlisted and NAPSters are expected to lead their classmates and provide assistance and good examples, they are not in any way given the leeway to bilge a classmate. Quite the contrary; they are expected to know better.</p>
<p>As for bilging in general: If you are asked a rate and you know the answer, it's not bilging your classmate UNLESS (and this is where things may have changed) you correctly answer a rate that your classmate just got wrong without first asking permission to help your classmate.</p>
<p>Examples:</p>
<p>Bilging your classmate:</p>
<p>Upperclassman: "Mr. Gish, how many days until I graduate?"
MIDN Gish: "Sir! 265 days, sir!"
Upperclassman: "Wrong! Mr. Door, how many days until I graduate?"
MIDN Door: "Sir, there are 267 days until you graduate, sir!"
Upperclassman: "NICE BILGE, MR. DOOR! I'M SURE MR. GISH APPRECIATED THAT!"</p>
<p>Non-Bilging:</p>
<p>Upperclassman: "Mr. Gish, how many days until I graduate?"
MIDN Gish: "Sir! 265 days, sir!"
Upperclassman: "Wrong! Mr. Door, how many days until I graduate?"
MIDN Door: "Sir, request permission to help my classmate."
Upperclassman: "Help your clueless classmate."
MIDN Door: "Sir, there are 267 days until you graduate, sir!"
Upperclassman: "Very well."</p>
<p>See the difference? </p>
<p>Now, in the absence of a classmate having gotten the same question wrong before you, you are not in any way bilging your classmates if you are asked a question and you know it, as that's your job. Where it can become a problem is if you start announcing that you know the stuff before you have been required to. Best to keep that as a secret weapon in your back pocket. If you let it out you may be tagged as a smack, and that's the LAST thing you want to be tagged as!</p>
<p>Perhaps the current mids can confirm or correct the whole helping-your-classmate thing, but I think tha general point will still be valid.</p>