So now that we've officially entered regular admissions season, I think it's time I took inventory.

Just for reference, I already got into UNC for Math Decision Sciences.

NYU (Stern)
Carnegie Mellon (Dietrich)
Johns Hopkins
Duke
Cornell
Columbia
UPenn
Harvard
Princeton

So here are my stats:

Objective:

New SAT (Superscored): 1470 (M: 770; EBR&W: 700; Essay: 23)
SAT II: 730 in Math 1 and a 660 in Math 2 (Didn’t send the Math 2 unless required)
Unweighted GPA: 3.88
Weighted GPA: 5.21
Class Rank: 5/525
AP: Calc AB, Calc BC, Stats, Environ, Bio, World, U.S. History, Psychology, English Lang (Have passed all of them or better)
Senior Course Load: Multivariable Calculus, AP U.S. Gov, AP Comp. Gov, AP Micro, AP Macro, AP English Lit, AP Spanish
Awards: AP Merit Scholar, some school awards, as well as debate stuff

Subjective:

Sports:

JV and Varsity Football (9-12, Captain my senior year, but NOT RECRUITED)
JV Baseball (9-10, was the statistician for the whole program)
Varsity Lacrosse (11-12)

Other ECs:

Spanish Club (9-12, Co-founder of the club, and I am fluent)
UNICEF (9-12, President)
KEY Club (9-12)
Speech (11-12, Captain of Extemporaneous Speaking)
Debate (11-12, Captain of Congressional Debate, also a PF Debater with many awards in both)
Math Club (11-12)
National Honors Society (11-12)
Amnesty International (12, joined because I accidentally walked in on a meeting and got interested lol)
Practicing Martial Arts (I have 2 black belts)
Helping my dad with his insurance business
Tutoring my siblings

Job/Work Experience: Worked at a movie theater between for the summer between 9th and 10th grade

Volunteer Work: I have about 120 hours thanks to my ECs

Summer Activities:
Football workouts (AKA Hell on Earth)
Helping out with Speech and Debate camps
Touring schools
Relaxing, just a bit

Essays:
Common App: 9/10. Very in-depth story about the relationship between my autistic brother and me.
NYU: 8/10. Really clever, I enjoyed writing it.
CMU: 9/10. Witty, funny, and effective at explaining why CMU is a good fit.
JHU: 7/10. I thought it was good, but I didn’t feel very passionate when writing it.
Duke: 9/10. Really out of the box and fun to write.
Cornell: 8/10. Very solid, witty, and appropriately funny.
Columbia: 7/10. Similar problem to JHU, but still good.
UPenn: 8/10. All-around a really good supplement.
Harvard: 9/10. Did a good job at conveying myself as an applicant and was pretty fun to write.
Princeton: 10/10. Had three people read it, and all three of them cried, not to mention a dope ending.

Recommendations:
Teacher Rec. #1: 10/10. My Stats teacher who has caused everyone who has read the essay to cry.
Teacher Rec. #2: 9/10. My Spanish teacher. I’m apparently the best-speaking student he’s ever had.
Counselor Rec.: 8/10. I’ve had a lot of face-time with my counselor to work out schedules and things.
Additional Rec.: 7/10. From my football coach who says that I’m the smartest player he’s ever coached, but it’s not very specialized.

Other:
Ethnicity: White
Gender: Male
State: NC
Income: $80,000
Intended Major: Statistics (or the best equivalent available)

@morgantmw I will say that you have pretty good stats for all of these schools in terms of rigor and test scores. However, the problem becomes what do the ivy league and elite schools want in an applicant. I would say you have a good chance at all of these schools in terms of test scores, but college admissions is so unpredictable and competitive, so my guess is as good as anyone else.

I wish you best of luck and let me know what the outcome is. If I had to make a list, I would say,

NYU: Accept
CMU: Accept/Waitlist
JHU: Accept/Waitlist
Duke:: Accept/Waitlist
Cornell: Waitlist/Reject
Columbia: Reject
UPenn: I don’t know (maybe accept?)
Harvard: Reject
Princeton: Reject (but if your essay is as good as you say, you might have a shot here)