<p>You need to look beyond the "stats". This would be true with not only the merit scholarships but also admissions to the highly selective schools.</p>
<p>You probably need a certain level of academic/testing stats to get your "foot in the door" so to say, and what this level is probably varies from college to college. But, after this, it looks like it really depends on your application in its entirety -- in essence, how you represented yourself on paper and would the reader come away after reviewing it with the feeling, "I really want this kid to be in my freshman class". You don't need a laundry list of EC's, or that national title, or anything else that the kids on this board think is really "important". What the kids on this board need to understand is that the application, in its entirety, conveys something that makes the applicant stand out from the pile. Until people start posting their entire applications on this site, none of else will ever get the full picture of what makes student a different than student b.</p>
<p>My son is a perfect example of the above. He has very solid grades - 96 out of 100% with a class ranking of #4 in a generic unknown public high school. No athletic team or musical membership. No national titles. No literary clubs. But is very dedicated to a few certain extracurriculars, which include tutoring and our local temple. Had officer status in NHS and the math team. Took AP classes, but not all that his school offered - only those that really interested him. His parents are both college grad/professional school grads, so no socioeconomic "hooks".</p>
<p>If you look at my son's "stats" you would think nothing spectacular in comparison to the countless other honors high school students out there -- in fact he pales in comparison to many who have posted their "numbers" on this board (but weren't as successful with the college process). So...why did my son do so well? I think the answer rests in his application, when reviewed in its entirety. My wife is friends with his guidance counselor, and his counselor told her last October after she reviewed his packets before the school sent them off to the colleges that he is going to be accepted to all his colleges and will get many high scholarship offers. And she was right.</p>
<p>He applied to 5 schools, and accepted by all: Brandeis, Brown, Fordham, RPI, and Stony Brook. Full merit scholarship at Fordham with Honors Program and also Stony Brook with Honors College, about 80% of tuition at Brandeis covered by a scholarship, and about 50% of tuition covered at RPI through grad. school and a free laptop computer. No scholarship at Brown, since the Ivy's don't offer merit scholarhships.</p>
<p>My son's applications, in essence, told a story about him: His essay, short answers, and extracurricular/awards sections all tied together. He used any part of the application that he could to convey who he was and what he was about. The extracurricular section he chose to not merely do the standard listing of activities. He included additional sheets that only included what he felt was his truly major activities and briefly described them and his involvement. When he was all done, they all tied together and showed a full picture of him. He only listed like 3 awards which he felt were his major ones. His essay was very personal (in fact it was about an experience that I never knew he went through) -- he took risks with his use of language in it, and when you were done reading, you just sort of went "WOW". His application revealed someone who is very philosophical and is asking questions about the human existence and the prejudices in our society, is mature, is learning from his mistakes, is driven towards a particular intellectual quest, and is very dedicated to the few activities that he is involved with. After you were done going through the application, you felt you really knew this kid.</p>
<p>So, my son, would be very difficult to judge merely on stats or a listing of activities and accomplishments. His qualities really shined through in the words that he chose to put on those applications.</p>