@ang331
I don’t think that coming to UMKC fully closes your door to doing ROAD specialities.
If you want to do something super intense: radiation oncology, neurosurgery, plastic surgery, cardio thoracic surgery or dermatology, you might have to extend by a year but that’s not a requirement.
It all depends on when you decide what you want to do with your life. Some students have had an experience early on that draws them to a certain specialty so they are able to get a head start on research and are able to avoid taking a year off for research. Of all the students that matched neurosurgery, dermatology, ophthalmology, radiology, anesthesiology, and orthopedic surgery this year, none of them took a year off to do research and they were all able to match into their preferred choices for the most part. With the exception of that one guy who matched ortho at harvard, I think he took a year off.
However, there is another student who will be joining our class who is doing dermatology and took a year off to do research. Nothing is set in stone.
Taking a year off essentially boils down to a couple things:
- Are you doing something that only has minimum spots in the country. For example, radiation oncology has like 20 spots a year (someone correct me if i’m wrong), medicine-dermatology combined program has 6 spots every year, and CT surgery only has 15 programs total. In that case, rarely do you build up enough research to make yourself “competitive” in the applicant pool even with stellar board scores and excellent clinical evals.
- If speciality is not that intense but are you making up for a flaw in your application. Some get sub par board scores but still don’t want to give up their dream for doing ophthalmology or derm, etc and take a year off to make connections and strengthen their application with like x number of publications.
- Do you want to go somewhere super intense. Like the guy who matched orthopedics at harvard this year, he was not a part of this graduating class but took a year off to do research to get his dream program. I mean I know him from around the medical school and he is just super brilliant. I mean he has presented his research at international conferences in Germany, Italy, etc. I can’t comment on the reason why he took a year off either, because he gave a talk at one of our student research interests groups and he already had like 15 or so publications before he took his year off. Maybe it was just really important to him and he voluntarily choose to do so, I’m really just speculating at this point.
I would say this: if and when you decide to come here and want to do a more competitive speciality start poking around early. Figure out what you like, and what you don’t like. Honestly, a lot of this stuff you won’t realize until you’re in your third year of core rotations anyways. But you can do certain things to help your case. If you are interested in a certain speciality you can take that elective late in your fourth year or early fifth year to see if you like it. If you are interested in surgical subspecialties but know that ob/gyn is not for you, when you set your schedule, do surgery first and ob/gyn last etc.
I know the two students who matched neurosurgery and plastic surgery this year. One fell in love with surgery after her surgery clerkship and it was completely unexpected for her. One fell in love with it after taking an elective early in fourth year and they were both able to match successfully without taking a year off.
The best resources you have will be your older years who matched into whatever it is that you like. They will give you the best first hand advice on your application, and guide you to the right mentors. But honestly that’s all something you should worry about once you start structure function at the earliest.
Again, I will re-iterate the same advice I stated above but in a slightly different way. Know that coming to UMKC does not guarantee you getting into a competitive speciality. For instance, if you see Baylor’s match list this year, they have 11 people match urology, 11 people match ophthalmology, 6 people match dermatology, 6 people match ENT, 13 people match orthopedics vs. UMKC’s 1, 2, 1, 2, and 7 respectively. I just want to show you this reality. Arguably, it is in some ways “easier” to match competitive specialities at upper tier institutions. I mean sure, those students still have to have good board scores, research, extracurriculars etc, but for them A. not only is research and big name mentors easier to find but B. they also have a well known medical school pedigree stamped on their application that admit it or not does make a difference. People can sit here and argue all day, but you have to admit if you were an admissions officer and you had two identical applications in front of you both with stellar personalities with the only difference being their school, the end of the day a well known school will beat out UMKC, it just does. Are there rare instances where that’s an exception, yes of course. Look at the girl who match Wash U plastic surgery this year. Again, its not that you won’t find those exact resources here at UMKC or find mentor who can connect you with those resources that upper tier medical students have access to, just remember that you are going to have to look harder.