Apparently, this is a new stance from USC Admissions and a direct result of the application pool augmenting to 80K+ in total between EA and RD submissions.
I do not recall such statements from USC back in 2014 or 2017, when my two daughters were applying. Back then, a direct quote from the head of Admissions was as follows… “Students often ask me how they can let the admission office know that USC is their first choice. It’s simple: Just tell us. Tell us in your application, over email, telephone or in person. And we make note of that. We add these things to your files if you ask us to, and we keep them in mind as well.” Times have changed though it seems, and now USC Admissions is trying to not become overwhelmed via applicant updates. And that does seem to be a reasonable request on their part.
My daughters simply followed the prior advice. They did each send one short email to their assigned AO in mid-February re-confirming their interest, stating that USC remained their first choice and committing to attending if admitted. They were both eventually admitted in March, and each did in fact enroll. Both have since graduated from USC.
If applicants are receiving contrary advice from Admissions now, then they are each free to proceed as their own thoughts guide them. In my family’s case, I think that my daughters would have always regretted not stating what they did in writing had the admission decision gone the other way. So, they at least wanted to make it known clearly. Knowing them, they would likely still send that one email… even under the conditions of USC’s new guidance.
But every applicant moving forward needs to decide for themselves. Maybe they should consider things like… How crucial would an update or statement actually be? Do you really feel compelled to send it? And if so… Would USC Admissions actually disqualify an applicant that they were planning to admit already for making such a commitment or for simply supplying a crucial update? Or… could such a commitment or update be the difference between being admitted or not for an applicant on the bubble?
I personally see no harm in making a short and sweet commitment within such an email… if true. It is after all also an environment wherein 90%+ of all applicants will fail to achieve that coveted admissions offer. If an applicant does not do so… and if an offer of admission does not come… that applicant might always wonder if it could have made a difference. But, it is clear that USC is asking applicants to no longer do so. So, the decision is yours. Every applicant needs to reflect and decide for themselves.
Good luck…