<p>@ Crazyshow</p>
<p>“Obviously its up to you to choose where you want to go to school, but I find it hard to reconcile the ideas that you’re someone who is extremely talented enough to be competitive at CMU, and yet youre deciding on not going there because of the perceived failure of their admissions department to live up to a standard constructed by impatient, waiting students.”</p>
<p>Correct me if I’m wrong, but if you’re making the assumption that I’m not “competitive” enough to get into CMU based on THIS post alone, then perhaps like me and CMU, you make wild accusations about people without considering other factors. I’m not going to play the stat game or the “i got into THIIIIIS many colleges so shaddup” game with you, but that was frankly uncalled for. </p>
<p>Admittedly, this post was more a vent of frustration and anger than anything else, but like the other posters I’ve also settled on an attitude of indifference towards CMU.</p>
<p>All in all, it’s just disrespectful for the canidates that are waiting in agony for a string of grey letters saying “accept, waitlist, deny” while their peers are already getting fat packets in the mail! </p>
<p>Perhaps it’s an ego thing, but I just don’t like being kept in the dark while others get good news. And maybe I’ll be the first to admit it, CMU has wounded my ego. Fueled by the posts of “acceptances were first…etc.etc.” CMU Adcom office has made me feel less of myself. How can I appreciate/want to go to a school like that? </p>
<p>I mean let’s be reasonable here. I can totally understand if any given school has SLIGHT fluctuations between decisions. If CMU had only done snail mail, of course someone in Pennsylvania will probably get a decision letter before me. But the online decisions are just ridiculous! How can you justify the fact that it has been a week between the first online decisions to now and some people have still not gotten ANY notification? </p>
<p>I don’t believe the frustrated posters on CC are making a “mountain out of a molehill” so to speak. I think it’s all on CMU’s serious lack of organizational skills (and perhaps compassion). The class of 2009 is supposed to be the most competetive year so far, and we really want to know where we stand. Are we doomed to go to our state schools or not? Can we make it into the top 20 colleges or not? </p>
<p>A day or two or three is a reasonable discrepancy. A WEEK is totally unacceptable.</p>
<p>Plus many of us were told that decisions would be up on Saturday FROM the very office themselves. So they actually DID tell us “These are when your decisions are coming out.”
We stayed up till 12 A.M. feeling that Kingdom CMU was finally upon us. And we were jyped! Your argument is one-sided too because you are/were not in this situation. Perhaps you’ve gone through the decision process, but the CMU Adcoms didnt LIE and tell you that decisions WOULD be out when they weren’t. </p>
<p>Perhaps I need to reconsider the situation of the CMU Admissions team, but perhaps you also have to reconsider our situations as well.</p>