<p>^If OP has a good shot at Ivies, s/he may be interested in the Honors College, and UVermont’s is very light. Since OP will be in Engineering, which is rigorous enough on its own, it may not matter, but that may explain why OP is trying to diversify?
I’d pick 2-3 Ivies, 2-3 non Ivy reaches, 3-5 medium schools you like better than UVermont, 1 or 2 more safety schools you like as much as UVermont. Total, about 12 schools. Since you have 4 super selective schools, you could go up to 15 colleges if they don’t have lots of supplements (since you should think of these 4 as if they weren’t there… but they do require a LOT of work). 12 is a good number though.</p>
<p>SUNY Binghamton (I could 100% see myself there) => definitely keep
SUNY Albany => cross out, UVermont is better
SUNY Geneseo => probably keep, good alternative if other schools don’t come through
Tulane => match
Emory=> non Ivy reach
Wash U => non Ivy reach
Washington and Lee => not sure why you picked it, it’s very different from all the others, I’d cross out since it’s an oulier
Case Western Reserve => match</p>
<p>Since these two are CommonApp, no Supplement, you can keep them both, but if you have to cut, cut one.
Siena College
Saint Michael’s College</p>
<p>Run the net price calculators to make sure all are affordable. If not, cross out and replace with an alternative.</p>
<p>FINAL RECOMMENDED LIST
TWO AMONG
Dartmouth
Cornell
U of Penn</p>
<p>BOTH OF
Yale
Stanford</p>
<p>PLUS
Emory
Wash U
TOTAL: 6 reaches</p>
<p>SUNY Binghamton
SUNY Geneseo
Tulane
Case Western Reserve
TOTAL: 4 matches (add one?)</p>
<p>Siena College
Saint Michael’s College</p>
<p>UVermont: safety, already in
TOTAL: 2-3 SAFETIES</p>