Could Someone Grade My Practice SAT Essay?

<p>Hi CC, I am preparing for the October SAT. I finished writing this practice essay today, and I would really appreciate it if you could grade it and give me feedback. It is incomplete (I am terrible at writing five-paragraph, two-paged essays in 25 minutes), but I am posting it here verbatim because that is what an actual grader would see.</p>

<p>By the way, the examples about Joe Weller and his squad and the Chinese brothers were completely fabricated on the fly. This is the first essay I have ever written in which I used fabricated examples.</p>

<p>Prompt: Should people make more of an effort to keep some things private?</p>

<p>The world of today is a very open world. Technologies such as mobile telephones, e-mail, computers, and social networking allow people to communicate and disseminate their thoughts quickly to others. In the United States, specifically, the First Amendment's guarantee of freedom of speech allows Americans to voice their opinions, thoughts, and concerns freely. In addition, government transparency is an ideal that many in the world strive to achieve, and governments are across the globe are trying to become more transparent by releasing information they would have kept locked away years ago. However, as historical and current events demonstrate, some points of contention are better left unsaid, and people should make more of an effort to keep some things private.</p>

<p>One example of why people should keep some things private deals with discrimination. In the United States, discrimination has existed since the country's inception, and although the US is far more tolerant than it once was, openly offensive speech persists, protected by the First Amendment. Not long ago, an American soldier named Matthew Snyder was killed in action in the Middle East. The Westboro Baptist Church, an extremely homophobic and antiwar institution, sent picketers to Snyder's funeral holding signs that read "God hates fags" and Thank God for Dead Soldiers". Such blatantly explicit expressions are very hurtful, especially to a family that just lost someone. In a place where freedom of speech is upheld, people should not interpret it as an endorsement of hateful speech, and they should keep possibly offensive opinions to themselves.</p>

<p>In the military, keeping things is a matter of life and death. On the morning of March 17, 2005, an American staff sergeant named Joe Weller struck up a conversation with an Afghan restaurant owner in Kandahar. The two spoke and laughed heartily, and Weller warmed up to the restaurant owner. He told the restaurant owner where his squad would be camping out for the night, not knowing that the Afghan was a Taliban sympathizer. When Weller left, the Afghan contacted Taliban insurgents, who ambushed Weller and his squad that night, slaughtering 15 soldiers. This story truly demonstrates that "loose lips sink ships," and it also shows that some things ought to be kept private.</p>

<p>A third example of why privacy is beneficial can be found in the story of Tang Lung and his brother, Tang Li. The two brothers lived during the Ming Dynasty and [this is where the essay ends]</p>

<p>This could be the basis of an excellent essay. Just a few suggestions: You are not likely to feel that you have more time on the real SAT than on a practice. Therefore, you should evaluate what you have written in terms of the time constraints. You have two well developed examples. You do not need a third example, so don’t plan on it when you take the actual SAT.</p>

<p>The only real flaw in this essay is that some of the ideas in the first paragraph are not developed in the later essay. For example, the issue of government transparency is not explored later. Save time and increase the coherence of your essay by not mentioning it in the first paragraph. </p>

<p>The SAT graders are not supposed to base any part of the grade on the accuracy of the “facts” you include. However, I am not sure that “government transparency” is viewed as an ideal, even in the U.S.–as recent events amply demonstrate. This is to say nothing of the many repressive regimes in other parts of the world. I am not sure that the release of information is any better (at least as a percentage of accumulated information) than it was in the past. The most important reason not to mention this, though, is that it is not tied to the rest of your essay.</p>

<p>Before you start writing, think up 2 examples that are relevant to the question that is asked. Then, consider for a moment what those examples illustrate. Write a short and to-the-point introduction to the ideas that you will demonstrate with those examples. In this case, your examples illustrate that some things should be kept private, based on considerations of safety and respect (or common civility). An introduction of about 3 sentences that mentions those concepts would cover it and leave you time to write a concluding sentence or two.</p>

<p>I’m kind of confused by your second paragraph. Are you explaining how it isn’t “nice” to use hateful language (and by doing so, not keep things private)? Though I agree, I don’t think it is solid evidence because it is not a “fact” that the WBC should be more private about their opinions. Perhaps they are incorrect and hateful but, that is their opinion.</p>

<p>Your third paragraph made more sense factually for why people should keep things private. Fact: an American sergeant spilled the beans over where his group would be camped. Fact: his confidant notified the Taliban. Fact: The Taliban used the information to kill members of the group. I thought this paragraph makes more sense because it’s backed up factually with why it’s best to keep things private. I liked the “loose lips sink ships” quote also, well done.</p>

<p>I’m a high school student so I’m no expert on what to expect in an SAT essay, but that’s my two cents. I’d be more than willing to discuss.</p>

<p>Thank you very much to both of you for the constructive feedback! I really appreciate it!</p>