Essay assistance and critique

<p>In preparation for taking the ACT w/ Writing on Dec. 8th, I'm writing a few practice essays since that tends to be my weakest point.</p>

<p>Warning: The essay included is probably the poorest example of writing (well, that wouldn't be fair to my Florida Writes essay...) but I'd just like to know what score it would hypothetically receive were it an essay I wrote on an actual exam.</p>

<p>I appreciate any comments and criticism.</p>

<p>Thanks</p>

<p>Prompt:
Schools in some states have changed their school calendar so that they are now year-round schools. Advocates of year-round schooling argue that the traditional summer break is a waste of students' time that could otherwise be spent learning. Opponents charge that today's students are already overburdened with the stresses of school, and need the summer to get a much-needed break. In your view, should the traditional three-month summer vacation from school be maintained?</p>

<p>In your essay, take a position on this question. You may write about either one of the two points of view given, or you may present a different point of view on this question. Use specific reasons and examples to support your position.</p>

<p>My Essay:</p>

<p>"Hey Nick, how was your summer vacation?" asks Tom. "Was pretty fun. Played video games and stuff", replies Nick, "didn't do much though".
This mock conversation is a prime example of why the continuous three month vacation break should be changed for the much more efficient year round schedule.</p>

<p>As a student, I personally feel that I forget much of the academic material I am taught after I've spent three months completely academically dormant. Proven studies show that a brain which is not continuously exercising degrades over time. Thousands of millions of tax dollars are spent to ensure a proper education to kids, but most of this money is better off thrown away if kids tend to forget the material. A long break from learning is purely detrimental to the knowledge formation of kids. In the year round calendar, students spend at most one month without going to school. This permits teachers to spend less time reviewing previously taught subjects, and instead spend more time diving into new material, thus more learning and less banality takes place.</p>

<p>Furthermore, when was the last time one heard of a student actually using his summer vacation time wisely? One doesn't! Kids either waste countless hours stationed in front of a TV or computer indulging in health-threatening activities. These kids have no hope of learning any sort of time management skills. School officials are doing a disfavor to the young population by destroying any possiblities of its growing into a population of responsible adults. Kids do not have stressful lives! They do not require any extensive three month fun time spa. The short and spread out breaks in the year round approach are more than suffice in providing children with the free time they need to alleviate their burdens.</p>

<p>One might argue though that summer break is the only time a family vacation can be taken, and that breaks found in the year round calendar are too short for these activities. Although this does hold some truth, more than three quarters of school calendars include a two or three week continuous break around the end of the year holidays, and a one month break in the summer time. Most guardians of students can't take nearly such long vacations away from their work, so these breaks are more than sufficient in the majority of cases.</p>

<p>It can be seen, in conclusion, that there is a plethora of advantages to the year round system over the traditional system, even though no single calendar can be perfect. The year round is a great alternative since it removes the loss of retention of knowledge of a child, refrains from providing unnecessary time which tends to be wasted but still provides enough time to take family vacations.</p>

<p>bumpity bump bump</p>

<p>Advice: Write an essay exactly how you would if taking the real ACT writing test (yes, that means writing it), then copy that essay word-for-word onto here, and then I will give you my opinion. </p>

<p>Reason: When time constraints are involved, typing an essay is much easier than writing one, for obvious reasons.</p>

<p>This essay was indeed written by hand and then transcribed (trans-typed??) onto here. All original spelling errors are included :slight_smile: I agree; I for one can type probably 10 times faster than I can write.</p>

<p>-i dont understand the importance of that conversation in the beginning. it doesnt add any substance to the essay and already gives your essay a really really really informal tone. use your first paragraph as an introduction to your point of view, like what you would do for an english essay. explain your stance. </p>

<p>-dont use “big” words if you arent sure how to use them. it does more damage than if you use a simpler word correctly</p>

<p>-you never say the advantages of being in school year round. you jsut explain the negatives of a summer break. and one thing: you say that all students spend their time lounging on the couch: NOT TRUE! i, as well as a lot of other students, spend the summer productively by having internships. make sure you dont make such strong accusations…</p>

<p>-you mention in your conclusion, for the first and only time, a well structured thesis. put a different version in your intro and then the graders will know what you are talking about before they deeping dive into your essay, only to find out at the end what you were trying to prove</p>

<p>that is my 2 cents…sorry for being so critical, but its the only way you learn what you are doing right/wrong</p>

<p>Thanks for the comments.</p>

<p>Could you point out to me where I used inappropriate or awkward diction? </p>

<p>I did not mean to offend you and assumed that you would not judge me based on an essay. Of course I don’t think all students waste their time; I would be the first exception. It was a strong accusation and will take care not to make such a statement without proof. </p>

<p>Thanks again. Anyone else?</p>

<p>just when you say “banality”. it sounds awkward</p>

<p>i know you werent offending me, persay, but you really have to be wary about strong opinions and general statements. thats all that i was trying to point out.</p>

<p>This looks like it would be an excellent FCAT essay, perhaps a 6. For the ACT, not so much.</p>

<p>I pretty much agree with everything that the previous posters have said, especially with the awkward diction, like “thousands of millions of dollars”.</p>

<p>Your examples are also a little weak. With this type of persuasive essay, it looks like you’ll have to appeal to logic, though there are a few other prime strategies that you can chose. Have each of your examples support a specific persuasive strategy.</p>

<p>PM me if you want a further detailed analysis.</p>