First essay attempt - please let me know what you think!

<p>I read through the example essays and then tried my hand at it. Please score out of 12 if possible, but more importantly I'd love to hear any suggestions you have for improvement. Unfortunately, I didn't distribute my time well and didn't have time for a proofread. This version has all the original errors and awkward versions. Enjoy! :)</p>

<p>PROMPT:
The old saying, "be careful what you wish for," may be an appropriate warning. The drive to achieve a particular goal can dangerously narrow one's perspective and encourage the fantasy that success in one endeavor will solve all of life's difficulties. In fact, success can sometimes have unexpected consequences. Those who propel themselves toward the achievement of one goal often find that their lives are worse once "success" is achieved that they were before.</p>

<p>ASSIGNMENT: Can success be disastrous?</p>

<p>ESSAY: Success can be one’s downfall. If one becomes too entranced by a goal, one becomes blind to the threats that may have surfaced while in its pursuit. This assertion can be supported using evidence from literature and current events.</p>

<p>In the tragic Theban trilogy crafted by Sophocles in ancient Greece, Oedipus, King of Thebes, hears that his people are being menaced by plague and misfortune because the murderer of his predecessor was never brought to justice. Thus, he fervently vows to catch the perpetrator and come down on him with the full force of the law. As the story unravels, it becomes gradually clearer that Oedipus himself is guilty of the crime. Furthermore, the ghastly truth that he has killed his father and borne children to his mother surfaces. Had he stopped digging for the truth, had he not been seduced by the promise of success, the tragedy would never had occurred.</p>

<p>The Egyptian people, after having finally overthrown the despotic powers of Hosni Mubarak, seem at times also to have forgotten what their true goal is: to establish a stable, democratic state in Egypt. However, much of the population seemed instead more concerned with putting their fallen former leader on trial for crimes already committed than establishing a new, transparent and populist government with expedience. The longing to satisfy their thirst for vengeance at times seems to have blinded some individuals and shrouded their view of the priority.</p>

<p>One cannot let the fear of failure cause an exorbitant longing for success. After all, what would the world come to if all people were concerned with single goals? Conflicts of interest would be rampant, and people would seize to work in anyone’s interest but their own.</p>

<p>7-9/12 depending on your reader. Your thesis wasn’t very clear or well-articulated and you didn’t connect your examples back to your thesis. You also didn’t address a counter-argument in your essay, which will affect your grade. Lastly you have a very awkward structure which will also hurt your grade. Sorry and keep practicing.</p>

<p>Thanks for your input. :slight_smile: Let me try to apply your suggestions. </p>

<p>Current thesis: If one becomes too entranced by a goal, one becomes blind to the threats that may have surfaced while in its pursuit.
New (clearer?): If one becomes too narrowly focused on achieving a single goal, one might fail to notice other problems arising.</p>

<p>Resolution back to thesis paragraph 1: Had he stopped digging for the truth, had he not been seduced by the promise of success, the tragedy would never (have) occurred.
Revised: Because Oedipus was so eager to achieve his goal, he ignored evidence that his success would also mean his ruin.</p>

<p>Resolution back to thesis paragraph 2: The longing to satisfy their thirst for vengeance at times seems to have blinded some individuals and shrouded their view of the priority.
Revised: It appears that some now have skewed priorities; they do not see that even if they achieve their goal of punishing criminals, they have not solved the overarching problem of preventing future crimes from happening.</p>

<p>Does this address the problem at all? I’m not sure what you mean with awkward structure. For me, this is a standard 4 paragraph essay format.</p>

<p>I would definitely give your essay an 8. I liked the examples you used, but sometimes they weren’t developed very clearly and sometimes left the reader confused. Like the above poster said, you didn’t really connect back to the thesis. I liked the vocab you used and your grammar was decent.</p>

<p>^^</p>

<p>10char.</p>