<p>Student A: Over-represented Minority male
ACT 31, SAT 2170 out of 2400, 4.0 UW GPA, 10 difficult APs
President of Honor Society, lots of community service
All-state pianist; accomplished cellist
Science research at local lab
Boys State
Decent but not excellent essays</p>
<p>Student B: Caucasian female
SAT 1540 out of 1600, 3.6 UW GPA, 7 difficult APs
President of debate; debate star
Top girl scouts honor
Exceptional essays and recommendations</p>
<p>Student C: Over-represented Minority male
SAT 1980 out of 2400, 3.8 UWGPA, 7 APs not as difficult as above 2
President of Key Club, lots of community service
Spent a summer working on a community service project
Varsity Sport Team Captain
Member of teen advisory council for city government
Essays better than Student A's but worse than Student B's</p>
<p>These are real people from the same school who all applied to Harvard. Guess the results.</p>
<p>What year? Did they need a cellist or a lacrosse player that year? In all honesty, it could go either way on any of the three. What were the relative rankings? Income levels?
A- deferred
B- Admitted
C- Rejected (unless C is a recruited athlete)</p>
<p>C was not a recruited athlete. jlauer was close. I'll wait till this thread gets to two or three pages, then explain. I can also tell you where else these people got in.</p>