@homerdog, I understand your concern about drinking, but I think you’re going to end up with a very short list if you throw out all schools where a decent number of kids care about the party scene. It sounds like that will be the right list for your child, but I don’t think that list includes Grinnell, for example.
I just checked one of the student review sites, and it sounds like there’s a fair amount of drinking going on at Grinnell, and probably a good amount of pot smoking too.
Carleton, too. Here are a few reviews of the party scene at Carleton. Note the phrase “work hard, pay hard” in the second review.
If your son really doesn’t want to be around drinking, I would look at religious schools and schools with dry campuses. Carleton does not sound dry at all.
“Since everyone lives on campus, it fosters a sense of community through partying unlike many state schools with frats. Parties are always fast to get to, and people party hop all the time. You can walk into parties and not know people but still feel welcome. There is always plenty of alcohol and the RA’s are so relaxed you don’t have to worry about getting in trouble for drinking or partying.”
“Nightlife, HA! Partying is limited to weekends and once during the middle of the week. Our motto is work hard, play hard. When we do get together, we make up for lost time. However, often the party is dead by 1 or 2. That’s what you get in a small town. One bar only. Most gathering are 5-10 close friends drinking and playing some games.”
“While there aren’t many (read: any) places to go in Northfield, there are always plenty of parties on Wednesday and weekend nights (especially Saturdays). It’s easy to find alcohol if you’re underage, but if you’re not into that kind of thing nobody will judge you. You can really go to a “wet” party and not drink or stay in.”
“not much of a bar or club scene (only three bars in northfield) but there are a decent amount of parties on the weekends. the school is also very chill about underage drinking.”
“Trivia Night at the Cow! You should not come to Carleton for a ragin party scene; still, there are a fair number of nighttime social options, many of which reflect the Carleton academic humor. There are a few pubs in Northfield, including Froggy’s and The Contented Cow, the latter of which features trivia competition every sunday. Nightlife is commonly friendly to those looking to drink and those who are not, regardless of age.”