<p>Let’s be clear about one thing. Students w/o any obligation to an institution are not redshirted athletes credited to those institutions. Nor is the year at a prep school counted as a “redshirt” year for that individual. They are considered high school year, subject to all the recruiting requirements of the NCAA. However, many of those rules, including the number of “scholarships” available (since all/none at SAs are scholarship athletes) do not apply to SAs. </p>
<p>Following are some excerpts from a NY Times piece awhile back. One thing it clearly notes is that even the then head of NAPS notes these are not Navy “redshirt” (quotation marks or not). In fact, they are to be treated like every other HS recruit. But definitely NOT redshirts. Not even recruits, i.e. USNA or another SA “parking” recruits @ a prep school. One other note … redshirt athletes are not permitted to participate in official competition. NAPS kids play away, as to MAPS, USAF Preppies. I think we’re a bit confused here.</p>
<p>‘‘The normal idea of a redshirt year is a recruit who is stashed away and treading water,’’ said Capt. Charles A. Hautau, the commander at the Naval Academy prep school. ‘‘Our candidates study chemistry, physics, two sections of math and English every day, five days a week. Does that sound like a redshirt year?’’
Not only that, but the prep school students are not obligated to go on to any of the service academies after their year at the prep schools. They can choose to go to private colleges. The athletes, while playing at the prep schools, can be recruited to play football for other universities. When Navy played at Tulsa, the opposing punter was a Naval Academy prep school graduate. …
The Naval Academy football coaches lament the 20 to 30 percent of athletes who have gotten away.
‘‘We’ve lost a lot of good players that came through the prep school,’’ Navy Coach Paul Johnson said. ‘‘Sometimes they didn’t get their grades up, and sometimes they just didn’t like the military or academy lifestyle.’’
Gladchuk, the Navy athletic director, said: ‘‘They are first and foremost potential commissioned officers. They may be an athlete from 4 to 6 in the afternoon, but every other minute from 6 a.m. to 10 p.m. they are being groomed to serve their country. The kids that leave the prep school aren’t doing so to play big-time college football. They just don’t see the military in their future.’’
The prep schools, however, remain established feeder programs for the service academies’ football teams, a relationship the academy coaches do their best to maximize. They watch film of the prep schools’ games, write their prep school recruits frequent letters and make phone calls as allowed under National Collegiate Athletic Association rules. The entire Navy prep school will attend the Navy-Notre Dame game at Giants Stadium. Bobby Ross, the new Army coach, has had the football team at the United States Military Academy Preparatory School, which is in Fort Monmouth, N.J., play some of its games at West Point.
‘‘We want them to feel part of this place,’’ Ross said. ‘‘I’ve stayed in very close touch with their coaches. I must have been down there 10 times since I’ve been hired. I do believe that it is a very important part of what could lead to our success.’’
There are specific N.C.A.A. regulations about how the academy coaches can interact with the prep school players. In essence, the players must be treated like recruits at any other high school, although given the unusual connections between the institutions, there are obvious gray areas.
Clayton Kendrick-Holmes, the Navy prep school football coach, said he gives his players, ‘‘as much propaganda as I can,’’ in hopes that they will want to play football at Navy, where Kendrick-Holmes played.</p>
<p>P.S. I believe Northern Cal Mom is confusing USNA’s rules w/ NCAA, i.e. the NCAA does not care about this since none are officially USNA recruits. However, USNA cares how many recruited jocks get sent to NAPS. Gotta keep a proper front up that NAPS is not merely Navy High School for Future Navy Jocks.</p>