<p>cutoff must be around 15,000 total undergrad + grad students. Stanford and Harvard both have more graduate students than undergrad, so not sure what’s going on here…</p>
<p><em>edit</em> just looked these four up:</p>
<p>–Stanford 18,000
Harvard 19,000
Penn 19,000
Miami: 15,500</p>
<p>so, don’t know why Penn, Miami and Harvard would make it but Stanford wouldn’t…</p>
<p>Undergrad only:</p>
<p>Harvard 6,700
–Stanford 6,500
Penn 9,700
Miami: 10,400</p>
<p>Based on this, there must be an undergraduate cutoff of 6,600+</p>
<p>Harvard had 19,411 students total (undergrad & grad) in 2009, according to US News. Penn had 19,311. Stanford had “only” 18,494. So my first thought was, maybe a “large” school is one with 19,000 or more students total. But some others with larger total student bodies don’t make the “most desirable large schools” list, including Columbia (24,230) and Johns Hopkins (20,483). Northwestern (18,834) would be close to that cut-off but also doesn’t make the list. Then I thought it must be based on number of undergrads.</p>
<p>Let’s see: Stanford has 6,602 undergrads. Harvard has 6,655. Penn has 9,768. so it would seem the cut-off is somewhere between 6,602 (Stanford) and 6,655 (Harvard). But Columbia, which doesn’t make the list, has 7,743—a bigger undergrad population than Harvard, which does make the list. OK, I’m stumped; just what IS the cut-off? Or did they just figure no ranking is credible unless Harvard comes out on top, even if it’s a ranking if “large schools”?</p>
<p>Note that Northwestern and Johns Hopkins didn’t make Newsweek’s “most desirable regardless of size” list, either. Nor did, among perennial US News/CC faves, Chicago, Wash U, Vanderbilt, Georgetown. And Duke is pretty far down the list, behind Notre Dame, Bowdoin, and all thee major service academies. LOL. We’re sure to hear screams that this list is “not credible” from Dookies, among others.</p>