Please give a procrastinator feedback on her UC Essay #1?

<p>Soo I know I'm pretty late in the game. I just wrote my first draft to the first UC prompt and would really appreciate some feedback/ constructive criticism before I go on to write my final draft. Please feel free to tell me if it's too cliché or if you think I should choose a different topic. Thanks!</p>

<p>I sat anxiously in the back of the police car. I could hear my brother’s frantic cries in the car behind us while a hardcore version of “Bad Boys” played on the radio. Gosh, cops actually listen to this? Why are these seats so hard? I tried to distract myself from reality, from the tears streaming down my brother’s red, flushed face. That night, my siblings and I were taken to live in another home, but I felt like I was sent to another world. How did I get here? Why is this happening? I shut my eyes and allowed my mind to wander to the past…
“Three times five.” “Uh...fifteen!” “Yes!! She beat you again, dad.” I jumped up excitedly. “Come on, a harder one…” I looked forward to math competitions with my dad every evening. Sure, we were cramped in a tiny garage and couldn’t afford luxuries other kids had, but we were a happy family. “Dad, why can we see our reflections in windows if they’re clear? How did the concept of zero come to be? How can we be so sure that we all see the same thing?” He understood my curiosity, “It’s interesting, isn’t it?” and we’d come up with theories to those puzzling questions.
Eventually, we moved into a house, but expenses rose, life became overwhelming, and my father became addicted to alcohol. It engulfed his body and he became someone I couldn’t recognize. Violent screams, fragmented dishes, aggressive shoves, torn furniture. When my father’s violent episode concluded, we’d sit still, afraid to move, afraid to trigger the monster inside of him. Every day I hoped, I prayed, that the next day would be different and we could go back to having light-hearted math competitions and stimulating conversations. That hope was shattered when he got into trouble legally and had to leave the country. My family quickly disintegrated…
That’s how I got here. I stared out the window, at the children playing, families barbecuing, boys playing football. When I looked at my siblings, at their desolate stares, I felt hopeless. They’d grow up without parents, they wouldn’t live a normal life. I tried to convince them to go outside and play with the other kids but to no avail. Gosh, why did this happen. I prayed that we could be back in that garage where we were all connected and content. “Get a grip,” I told myself, “you’re just going to make them sadder. Don’t let them see how broken you really are. Be their anchor, keep them steady.”
Every day I strived to be someone they could look up to, who showed them that everything was okay. “There are the boys playing football. Here’s my chance.” I approached them nervously, hands shaking. I took a deep breath, smiled confidently, and asked, “Can I play?” They stared at me, glanced at each other, and shrugged, “You’re on that team.” The next day, my brothers were playing hide-and-seek with the other kids. Just because our living situation deteriorated didn’t mean we had to. I became independent, open-minded, and learned to take initiative. I pushed myself academically and socially, continued doing math proofs, pursuing music theory, and helping those around me. I was my siblings’ anchor, but they were my ship- they gave me purpose to persevere and withstand through adversity.
I look forward to the challenges I’m going to overcome in college, to uncover possibilities, to answer the “why’s” and the “how’s”. I know that life is going to be filled with obstacles, but no matter where it takes me, I’ll make the best of it and continue to lead others. “Your present circumstances don’t determine where you go; they merely determine where you start. Your choices make all the difference.” (Qubein) I’ve made the choice not to let my obstacles define who I am or where I’ll go. I will succeed in college, I will obtain an advanced degree in mathematics, I will help others pursue their aspirations. No matter how severe of a challenge I’m faced with, I will.</p>

<p>This is great! It really held my attention and described for me where you come from, and where you intend to go. You are 5 days early on this!</p>

<p>Just a caution- I have read other threads where some believe that (since CC is internet-searchable) an automated plagiarism-checker like turnitin.com might compare your essay to this posting and find them substantially alike, thus triggering a plagiarism alarm. I notice some people send essays only through PM, maybe for this purpose.</p>

<p>I do not know if it is a concern. Just passing on what I have seen posted.</p>

<p>@ItsJustSchool‌ Thank you for the feedback. </p>

<p>Is there anything I should add/delete?</p>

<p>It looks really good to me. Hopefully, others will chime in. Meanwhile, you may want to read this posting:</p>

<p><a href=“Editing Your College Essays - College Essays - College Confidential Forums”>http://talk.collegeconfidential.com/college-essays/25018-editing-your-college-essays-p1.html&lt;/a&gt;&lt;/p&gt;

<p>This is excellent. Change the first sentence though to something even more surprising if you can. Use a stronger verb and delete the adverb “anxiously.” Make that first sentence come alive. Because the main dish – your essay – is truly succulent, but I’m afraid your opening sentence is a rather insipid appetizer. </p>

<p>The paragraph where you discuss the questions you would ask your father: Each sentence needs to be in its own set of quotation marks or else it seems as though you bombarded him with ten questions without waiting for replies.</p>

<p>Also, this sentence doesn’t sound natural and I’m not sure what purpose it serves: “There are the boys playing football. Here’s my chance.” I approached them nervously, hands shaking. Simply describe that you saw some guys playing football and then go in to the “Can I play?” dialogue bit.</p>

<p>Delete this “I became independent, open-minded, and learned to take initiative.” Your story already reveals that you become these things. Let the college admission officer attach a label on your character, not you. </p>

<p>" I will succeed in college, I will obtain an advanced degree in mathematics, I will help others pursue their aspirations. No matter how severe of a challenge I’m faced with, I will."</p>

<p>Each phrase that begins with ‘I’ needs to be its own sentence.
Change the last sentence to something like, “No matter the obstacle, I will.”</p>

<p>Once again I liked this and kudos to you for rising above your hardships with your dad.</p>

<p>@ladyly‌ Thank you so much! I’ll definitely follow all of your suggestions.</p>

<p>I just realized that the UCs say not to use quotations because they want to see our words, not somebody else’s. Should I omit the quote by Qubein?</p>

<p>Once you don’t begin your essay with a quote it should be fine.</p>

<p>Hey, this essay is pretty good! I loved the first paragraph. A few suggestions:</p>

<p>Delete the first sentence, it is underwhelming. Just put the reader into the action.</p>

<p>“How did the concept of zero come to be? How can we be so sure that we all see the same thing?
^ this sounds unnatural for a kid to say. You should rephrase these questions (especially the first one) to be shorter, less technical/specific, and more kid-like. </p>

<p>This is a personal opinion, but if I were to write this essay, I would definitely phrase it so that the 2nd and 3rd paragraphs were in first person, present tense. It seems more natural (when people daydream about the past, they feel as if they’re in the past, not remembering about the past). Frame it feels like you’re really in the moment, trying to block out your painful situation.</p>

<p>I strongly disagree with ladyly. I thought that the quote sounded forced and unnatural. Your essay would do much better without the quote. </p>

<p>I will succeed in college, I will obtain an advanced degree in mathematics, I will help others pursue their aspirations.
^ the "I will"s makes it a bit forced, rigid, (stubborn?), in my opinion. Others might disagree and say that it shows determination, but maybe it’s more bodes to say leave it more open ended.</p>

<p>@YuiHirasawa‌ Thank you for the suggestions! I’ve always struggled with first sentences, I think you’re right about deleting it.</p>

<p>Regarding the questions I asked, I actually did ask those questions when I was a kid.</p>

<p>I like you’re idea of writing the memories in present tense. I’ll give it a try!</p>

<p>Well Qubein is someone I really look up to and I try to live up to his speeches and quotes every day. That quote actually helped guide me so I kind of feel like I should keep it in there.</p>

<p>The prompt says to show how our backgrounds have shaped our dreams and aspirations, so I included the “I wills” to show where I’m going but maybe you’re right…I don’t want to come off as stubborn.</p>