<p>A small question regarding the interview process. </p>
<p>I’ve had my Harvard and Princeton interviews (<em>gasp</em>) and I’ve had a pre-interview with the ASC director (but not real interview yet). And here’s something interesting I’ve noted.</p>
<p>The Harvard interviewer explained to me after the interview how it affects my decision. She said that the Harvard club tries to push as many people to acceptance as they can. It was unclear whether her evaluation would go to Cambridge or stay at my Harvard club in case admissions called back telling the club how many it was thinking of accepting. “We try to push everyone as much as we can, but we really concentrate on who we think are our strongest candidates.”</p>
<p>This statement bothered me. Let’s get to the Princeton interview, later that day.</p>
<p>After the pretty good and pleasant Harvard interview, I had an equally pleasant Princeton interview. She, however, mentioned that she would mail her evaluation letter to Princeton itself to become a part of my official applicant file with all of my other application pieces. I considered this much more egalitarian, and I liked it better.</p>
<p>So three weeks ago, I had a lengthy conversation with the Yale ASC for my pre-interview, before all this happened. He asked for my test scores, GPA, class rank, etc. Asked what other schools I was applying to, and all of the questions interviewers aren’t supposed to ask. He said that when my regional adcom calls in March, he’ll ask about the people he was thinking about accepting from my area. ASC Director: “And if there’s an name he doesn’t mention that I think is strong, I’ll say ‘what do you think of John Doe?’”</p>
<p>So here’s my question: To what extent to Yale ASC directors or interviewers decide the admission results? It seems very similar to Harvard’s process, and it’s contrary to all of the information I’ve heard about interviews. I’m used to hearing that the interview is the least important part of an application, and it usually confirms the adcoms’ suspicions. I’m just afraid that, to an extent, my decision will be partially made by someone who shouldn’t be involved in the admissions process.</p>
<p>Thanks for reading this long post!</p>