Will you grade this SAT practice essay?

<p>I'd appreciate feedback. I went a minute overtime as well (shame) so if you have any specific suggestions on what to cut, that'd help for next time. :) Thanks!</p>

<p>PROMPT
Is conscience a more powerful motivator than money, fame, or power?</p>

<p>MY ESSAY
"While many people would like to think otherwise, the desire for fame and fortune will always be a prevalent part of human nature. Historical figures and literary characters have shown us that unfortunately, the compelling attraction to wealth, power, and fame can tamper an individual's conscience.</p>

<p>Although Andrew Carnegie is known for his philanthropy, his public persona belied the steely figure who operated the steel mills from which he amassed an incredible fortune. Carnegie was harsh and uncompromising in his management of the workers, allowing little rest and low pay for the long hours they worked. Strikes were broken violently and troublemakers eliminated quickly. Many historians believe that Carnegie tried to compensate for his harsh rule by finally listening to his suppressed conscience in his later years. While he did not change the working conditions, Carnegie donated billions to charities. However, despite his philanthropy, Andrew Carnegie was obviously motivated more by money than by his conscience for most of his life.</p>

<p>Additionally in history, conscience has failed to surpass the lure of wealth and power. Several years after Carnegie's rise to fame, Senator Joseph McCarthy also rose to power. Fear of communism was rampant throughout the United States at this time, and McCarthy acted on those fears by accusing government officials of being communist spies. He fed off the public's hysteria to rise to power [I've used this phrase three times, lol] and gaining fame for his fearless dedication to purging America of communists. [ahh, I see the lack of parallelism here! ha] However, many of these accusations were false, and McCarthy's manipulation of the American public for his benefit came to light.</p>

<p>In a literary example, Scarlett O'Hara of Gone With the Wind also chooses money over conscience, although she possesses an understandable reason to. After her formerly-wealthy family loses money during the Civil War and now struggles to survive day by day, all Scarlett sees is money. When she hears that her sister's former suitor is financially secure, Scarlett turns on her flirtation skills and claims him as her own. Because Scarlett knows that her sister would not contribute a penny to the family if she married Frank, Scarlett decides that for the survival of her family, she would have to put her conscience on hold, putting money first.</p>

<p>While Scarlett O'Hara's motives weren't entirely selfish, they involved money and power, just like Andrew Carnegie's and Joseph McCarthy's. Therefore, conscience is not always a more powerful motivator than money, fame, or power. Bystepping the reasons and examples as to why, desire and necessity of wealth and power is an inherently human quality."</p>

<p>As I type this, I realize so many things I could have done better, lol. Thanks so much.</p>

<p>Also, a psychology question: Will the graders subconsciously favor an essay that takes the positive perspective more than one that takes the negative, like mine above? I usually take the positive side, but for this one, I couldn’t think of very strong examples. I know it probably won’t make a difference if the essay is well-written and supported, but I’m curious.</p>

<p>Graders might get tired if too many people choose the same angle/perspective and will subconsciously like the variety when someone chooses the minority perspective. </p>

<p>I would give the essay 10-11. Your introduction isn’t clear in answering the question. It asks if conscience is a more powerful motivator. It wasn’t very clear that you said no and you said that it can “tamper” conscience. In both the intro and conclusion, you say that desire is part of human nature but tie it into why it shows that it is stronger than conscience.</p>

<p>Also, try not to mention that Carnegie became more conscientious because it takes away from your argument. </p>

<p>The transition from the 3rd to 4th paragraph is absent. You go from historical to literary without anything tying the examples together.</p>

<p>It’s a solid essay. It’s 446 words, which is good since you usually want to fill the page. You should write between 300-500 words on the essay.</p>

<p>Yeah. I don’t think people on cc like to read super long essay posts… it is very tedious.</p>

<p>Don’t have time to read, but by just scanning the whole thing I’d say about 10. Add bigger vocab words and longer intro for higher score. Also your transitions are poor.</p>

<p>Okay, thanks for the help! I’ve been trying to work on transitions, trying to go back to using really obvious transitions after using smoother shifts for years, lol. I do agree that they could be better in this essay, so thanks.</p>

<p>I give it a 4.
Why are you asking random people online to grade your essay
when the real thing is graded by trained readers who actually
read your essay thoroughly instead of just scanning it?</p>

<p>

</p>

<p>^Lol that is false. The readers, usually high school/college English teachers, are given 2-3 minutes per essay. This is because they have a ton of essays to grade within a few weeks so that you can get your scores back on time. That is why giving a first impression in your intro and first body paragraph matters a lot. Besides all us posters are qualified to gauge the essay grade to help pinksoysauce out.</p>

<p>The conclusion seemed a bit awkward, but it overall was a nice essay. I would shy away from justifying Scarlett’s actions because it seems weaker.</p>

<p>"I give it a 4.
Why are you asking random people online to grade your essay
when the real thing is graded by trained readers who actually
read your essay thoroughly instead of just scanning it? "</p>

<p>dude, why are so rude? He is asking people on teh SAT forum because this is an SAT essay. If others are willing and nice enough to help, then why the heck do you care? And just to let you know, sat graders definitely do not “thoroughly” read essays. They read hundreds of essays on a computer right after the other. They practically skim it</p>

<p>Thanks for the help, everyone. I really appreciate it. :)</p>

<p>I would say 10 or 11. the big thing I feel you need to do is at the end of every paragraph link it back to the main theme and the use that sentence to support your thesis to make it clear the point you are making. But overall your writing is solid and you are doing a great job! =)</p>

<p>I’ll work on that. Thanks for the feedback!</p>